12 ms·
Elon Musk Unveils Boring Co's First Tunnel
- enyone 8y ago"Unfortunately, our website is currently unavailable in most European countries."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- imjasonmiller 8y agoGoogle’s AMP seems to circumvent this: https://www.google.nl/amp/s/www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-elon-musk-tunnel-20181218-story.html%3foutputType=amp https://www.google.nl/amp/s/www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-m...
- korijn 8y agoSo is Google AMP or LA Times then in non-compliance?
- cronix 8y agoLA Times didn't want to play the GDPR game so they blocked most of the EU, as is their prerogative. If Google circumvents that and provides access, that's on Google imo.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rsynnott 8y agoAs long as AMP is GDPR-compliant, neither have a problem. The issue is that LA Times doesn't want to deal with getting the appropriate consent for their tracker scripts.
- rataata_jr 8y agoAlong with North Korea and some backwards Middle eastern countries.
- a_imho 8y agoAny reason not to simply flag it?
- keyle 8y agoIt will come down to cost to build and time to build... I took 2 tunnels to and from the airport today. Each way, over $10. But I'm damn glad I took them because they go all the way from north of the city, to south of the city, including under the river, where our bridges are massive bottleneck. I saved at least 30' and a lot of sanity, and this was before work. I'd be dead tired if I had to deal with traffic jams for 45'. Heck I'd even chose a bumpy tunnel over the surface.
- warent 8y ago> "But Musk told reporters that Boring officials have abandoned the concept of the skate, saying it was “far more complex” than his new plan: guide wheels that can be attached to the front tires of autonomous, electric cars, steadying the vehicles as they move forward through tunnels." So basically this only works with Tesla vehicles at the moment. I'm wondering how that's going to expand in the future--if at all. Do they have a standard which other vehicle manufacturers are expected to include in their car designs to be compatible with these tunnels? This is making me question the viability of it, because without buy-in from manufacturers, it seems seriously unlikely that any government is going to approve a sprawling Tesla Guide Wheel Tunnel™ network.
- npunt 8y agoYes he mentioned it would be a standard any autonomous EV could add, and specifically said it would not be a walled garden. Makes sense to add these to the vehicles so the tunnel can be as ‘dumb’ as possible, since we’ll need a lot of tunnels to make a dent in traffic. Note also Tesla’s prior commitment to opening their patent portfolio for OEMs to use. Seems similar approach (platform play).
- simon_acca 8y agoThe intention seems to be to standardize: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1075227724430471168 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1075227724430471168
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoAnother question is why the autonomous vehicles would need guide wheels? Sounds decidedly non-autonomous to me.
- npunt 8y agoIt’s for added safety factor at high speeds (150mph).
- semi-extrinsic 8y ago
- neonate 8y agohttp://archive.is/VcFEe http://archive.is/VcFEe
- modeless 8y agoThe video of the launch event: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8GrUJo9ofJg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8GrUJo9ofJg
- snowwindwaves 8y agoThe tone of the article is surprisingly hostile. Maybe I'm just used to Canadian media.
- yborg 8y agoIt felt completely neutral to me. Admittedly, the reporter didn't genuflect before the altar of Elon, which some of his fans might interpret as implicit hostility.
- npunt 8y agoIt felt a bit persnickety - focusing on some minor details of the event that weren’t perfect, probably as a proxy for author’s larger skepticism. Skepticism is warranted given the big claims & article wasn’t too bad overall.
- carlivar 8y agoSome journalists have become openly cynical about Musk, probably now that so many promises have failed to materialize.
- Isinlor 8y agoHe may have delays, but what have he failed to deliver? Everything is either work in progress or delivered. - internet payment platform, check - first privately founded company to do orbital launch, check - reusable cheap rockets, check - biggest rocket available + it's reusable, check - Dragon spacecraft, check - crew spacecraft, check (still needs testing, starting early next year) - Model S, check - Model X, check - Model 3, check (work in progress on 35 000$ version) - Boring Tunnel, check (work in progress on scaling up) - Starlink, check (test satellites are flying over your head, work in progress on full deploy) - Big Falcon Rocket, work in progress
- nickik 8y agoSome people have a hard time keeping relative and absolutes apart. There are lots of people, even on this site who often claim that he is 'not even an engineer'. People emotions simply get the better of them in situation that are so public, every little detail gets blown out of proportion in either direction. The plain fact that he controls and builds multiple US based billion dollar companies seems to get lots AT THE VERY MOMENT when US based manufacturing has been on of the prime political debates is astonishing for me as an outsider.
- kilroy123 8y agoAre they really boring tunnels cheaper and faster than traditional construction companies though? Seems like that's the real goal with the company.
- npunt 8y agoYes, mentioned in live stream was that other co’s only spend 1/5 the time actually boring and the rest on logistics of putting up retaining walls and the like. Part of Boring Co innovation is to automate that and keep the borer working all the time. Also they 3x’d the energy output of the boring machine vs competitors. Should add up.
- hobofan 8y agoThat's all still speculation, isn't it? IIRC this tunnel was built with a boring machine from a competitor.
- npunt 8y agoIt’s mostly speculation for sure. I forgot what parts were real from the live stream (the 3x power output was real) but it seemed like this is mostly the rapid learning and planning stage. Buying a competitors device is a really smart move as a first step, since much of the low hanging fruit gains are in the activities around the machine to save that 4/5s of time when it’s idle. As a startup it’s almost always best to bootstrap with the competition’s product if you can, makes rate of learning so much faster.
- youngtaff 8y agoDon't most TBMs already work non-stop in a continuous process - with tunnel lining being fitted as the cutting head moves forward, and trains bringing lining segments and moving dirt away. Was certainly how the CrossRail and Channel tunnel machines worked See diagram on https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17365934 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17365934 Musk keeps showing this comparatively tiny machine, whereas in reality they're 150m long
- carlivar 8y agoTwitter thread on the physics to go 150mph in this tunnel: https://twitter.com/Model_4_/status/1075270290978963458?s=19 https://twitter.com/Model_4_/status/1075270290978963458?s=19 Note that air resistance is a much bigger problem in a cheap, narrow tunnel.
- npunt 8y agoI imagine it’ll also probably be hell on tires. You’d need W- or Z-rated tires to do that and those are $$. Perhaps smooth concrete will mean lower rolling friction along with lack of sudden maneouvers. Still, going that fast is expensive in all sorts of ways.
- carlivar 8y agoAnd it's best not to think about what happens if a car stops for any reason, or worse, catches fire. I do not believe any escape hatches were part of the demo and cost calculations.
- npunt 8y agoTunnels looked wide enough to get out and walk thru. They’ll need ventilation and will probably get maint / esc hatches for regs. Dunno about ADA. Didn’t seem like a detail worth hashing out in a debut tho.
- carlivar 8y agoAgreed not necessary in the demo, but should acknowledge this in the cost information.
- npunt 8y agoTrue, lots of info yet disclosed & some impt questions raised. Seems like an Elon intro where it’s vision first and then lots of details sorted out later and/or changed last minute (lookin at you BFR).
- jm1234567890 8y agoWhat happens if a car breaks down in the tunnel?
- sschueller 8y agoIs this safe? I didn't see any escape paths. What happens if there is a fire and you are in the sixth tube down? Electric trains are considered quite safe yet tunnels have a lot of escape paths and service tunnels built parallel to the main one.
- ardit33 8y agoIt is not, per general EU regulations no 'single bore' tunnel can be longer than 1km (0.62miles0. Tunnels that are longer than that, either have to be double tunnels, with escape doors between them, or one large tunnel and an emergency smaller one. This looks the size of a emergency tunnel. Still, the cost of building it seems pretty low. Boring Co could build two side by side, (one for each direction) and have emergency hatches between them.
- npunt 8y agoYeah practically I think there’s almost always going to need to be two tunnels side by side, given density of stations and the need for long distances to slow vehicles down as they exit from the main tunnel (up to 150mph) to the stations. It may be that stations wind up quite a bit denser than one every mile- certain parts of LA could use them every 1/4 mile really.
- agumonkey 8y agoBut would it still be that cheap with escapes and links ...
- ryanmercer 8y ago>Is this safe? As safe as any cave open to the public, which there are many of in state and federal parks often with only 1 or 2 exits. Also, barring an act of terrorism, it's probably as safe as driving a car, safer than skiing (water or snow), exponentially safer than sky-diving etc. >What happens if there is a fire and you are in the sixth tube down? Compared to the feat of actually tunneling the machine, boring small escape tubes would be relatively trivial. Employ magnetic-electric security doors that can be remotely released or unlock in the event of a power failure and anyone able bodied could climb a ladder out, make them wide enough to get a rescue harness down and fabricate in an anchor point for a safety line and anyone not capable could be lifted out not unlike how rescue helicopters lift people with a winch. And really, the operator could install the harnesses and winches too and have them be both electric with a way to easily connect them to an external power source and/or manual for redundancy. All you'd have to do is test them once or twice a year and lubricate as necessary. I'm pretty risk-averse but I wouldn't hesitate to use one, even without escape shafts.
- p1mrx 8y agoDoes anyone know the track width? It's more likely to become a global standard if they picked a nice number in meters.
- kwhitefoot 8y agoWhy would that be? The nearest thing to a global standard rail gauge is standard gauge and it isn't a simple number in either SI, 1.435 m, or US Customary units: 4 ft 8 1⁄2 in (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard-gauge_railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard-gauge_railway). There might already be a standard of some kind that could be used either directly or as a sub-multiple the same way that European kitchen fitments are generally 600 mm wide modules. There is nothing magical about units of measurement, neither SI nor what Americans persist in calling Imperial (when they mean US Customary or even worse US Survey Foot).
- pdq 8y agoThe elevators in and elevators out are the bottleneck. Then inside it looks like a safety and escape hazard nightmare. What happens when someone gets a flat tire?
- npunt 8y agoSeems like it needs to be centrally controlled automation so they’d be able to adjust fleet speed in relevant area for any issues that arose. Flat tire seems easy, probably a limp home mode to nearest exit + slow down nearby fleet. There should be many exits and relatively close to each other since they’re so low cost. I’m more concerned about fire & earthquake.
- haxton 8y agoGenerally speaking tunnels are much safer than outside due to the lack of falling debris. And the fire issue is solved my any half decent sprinkler / ventilation system.
- npunt 8y agoTrue. My concern (as a former Angelino) is what a ~2+ inch shear on the track would do to a vehicle traveling over 100mph. Lots of LA is on some fault or another that can cause these shears. Maybe it’d just be a big thud and the car goes into limp mode. Worth modeling and having risk assessment on either way.
- youngtaff 8y agoIsn't water a no-go if it's a lithium battery fire?
- MertsA 8y agoNo, for a battery fire it's quite the opposite. It's going to release all of that stored energy and burn up the electrolyte one way or another. Flooding it with water is the best way to deal with all of that energy.
- Tiktaalik 8y agoWhat a gong show and waste of everyone's time. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1075230308545454080 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1075230308545454080 How can this man honestly think this sort of system could be higher capacity than a subway?
- unmole 8y agoI think the term you're looking for is "reality distortion field".
- noobermin 8y agoI don't understand this. HN is better than most forums but seriously, the level at which people's minds online turn off for Elon is staggeringly confusing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- newnewpdro 8y agoI thought it was obvious this would quickly become an expensive express option. It's not going to fix traffic for the masses, it's going to fix it for the rich.
- de_watcher 8y agoTunnels under the cities in Switzerland are pretty useful for the masses... oh, wait, they're all rich.
- noobermin 8y agoWith snark but really though, isn't this the real issue? Are we trying to make transit better for everyone or just a few wealthy folk?
- npunt 8y agoWorth considering that a single family luxury car is not the only vehicle type that could be in these tunnels. Automation allows for all sorts of new options in vehicles. This is a platform and many services can sit atop it. No reason why people can’t develop a carpooling service for 6-12 person vans and run those on this. Or services that travel to clients rather than visa versa. Also, and very important to the cost argument, is that system cost is offset by individuals and external services purchasing fleets. This makes it a lot more practical a transit option to build than typical public transit or freeway fixes which require multi-year, multi-billion dollar outlays and consequent decision making apparatus. Consider what properties an ideal transit option has: a) easy to add very incremental capacity (vs big long projects) b) doesn’t have to deal with right of way c) shares costs with private market & individuals d) can reach any location point-to-point e) offers broad access to citizens Seems this + autonomous fleets serving different market segments and needs has these properties. If it works.
- twblalock 8y agoWhy would I take a van if I could take my own luxury car? If I was going to take a van I might as well take the subway. It would probably be more comfortable and roomy.
- npunt 8y agoIf there’s no subway nearby, how would you do that? Also not everyone can afford a luxury car. Just imagine lyft, lyft line, and a bigger lyft line. They can all coexist.
- twblalock 8y ago> Also not everyone can afford a luxury car. Ok fine. Why would I take a van if I can take my own car, period?
- npunt 8y agoCost? We haven’t heard anything about how much it costs to take one of these per mile. And ideally these systems mean less cars on the road / less car ownership, with higher utilization (cars sit idle 96% of the time, they’re the worlds most underutilized asset)
- ZeljkoS 8y agoVersion of article that can be viewed from EU: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/12/19/elon-musk-unveils-boring-company-tunnel.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/12/19/elon-musk-unveils-boring-com... LA Times version says: "Not available in your region"
- strainer 8y agoThats a different article. The LA times one discussed is archived here: http://archive.is/VcFEe http://archive.is/VcFEe
- mrarjen 8y agoFirst thing I noticed, why is there a loose hanging cable on the side of the tunnel, plus how will a slightly taller car fit? Seems there is plenty of work still to be done.
- garmaine 8y agoThe goal was to bore the hole, and that's what is being announced. You sure as hell can't drive in it today.
- cyphunk 8y agoI can't see how autonomous cars and Musky holes will be good for common people and not just turn into another form of exclusive transport for the rich.
- ryanmercer 8y agoBy taking those 'rich' off the surface streets for a good chunk of their commute and relieving congestion.
- konschubert 8y agoIf they manage to reduce the cost of tunnel boring then that's super exciting and I congratulate them. But all this discussion of what to put in the tunnel seems very silly to me. Are they just re-discovering subways? Do they know that there are subways in the world (e.g. Paris) that run out rubber tires?
- ztjio 8y agoDuring the presentation, Musk specifically compared to subways and how their vision is an improvement. I didn't and won't read the article, since I watched the presentation, but, if it doesn't even mention that fact, this article is a waste of time. The presentation was quite informative of their ideas and visions for using the tunnels and gave clear explanations of how their approach is superior to existing ones.
- ohhhwell 8y agoThe problem with subway systems is that they are great once they have enough reach and stops to reliably and frequently get you were you need to go without needing a car. However, a small subway system with infrequent service and only a few stops isn't all that useful. If we take the claims here at face value (not saying we should) then this is a solution that provides value immediately for people commuting by car, and if the network becomes widespread enough it becomes easier to rely on it as a pedestrian. Essentially it might be a great way to bootstrap a transition to public transport in car-centric systems. Also note that if you get an increased amount of people commuting in these tunnels without their own cars, new public transportation built by the city becomes a lot more valuable as well, since there's already a lot of people getting around without cars. That said it is funny how private companies seem to rediscover public transport. Looking forward to Uber Train.
- xauronx 8y agoUber buying a major cities metro system and making it not shitty would be pretty great. NYC subway is basically what taxis used to be, dirty and hostile toward the user.
- puranjay 8y agoThe big win from this experiment would be better tunneling technology. The tunnels and the sled system itself can fail, but if we walk away from this with tunneling tech that can meet Elon's claims by even 50%, it's a massive win
- skywhopper 8y ago> "Still, the $10 million is orders of magnitude lower than a typical subway project, Musk said." Umm, and the capacity of these tunnels is also orders of magnitude lower than a subway. It would also be a lot harder to use and available to far fewer people. This entire idea should be laughed out of existence, but despite everything, Musk still gets fawning coverage for any crazy idea he spouts. Maintenance will be impossible. Breakdowns of any sort would go from being annoyances to a few to being catastrophic failures for the system. Even if the tunnels never degraded, even if no car ever had a flat tire in the middle of the tunnel, and even if you could actually achieve 150mph (which would be extremely unpleasant for the passengers anyway), you couldn't physically fit enough cars through the tunnel to compare to real transit system. Given that this thing requires rigging something up to your vehicle, the onload and offload points would immediately become major bottlenecks to any serious throughput even if you could cram them in bumper to bumper.
- dwild 8y ago> Maintenance will be impossible. How so? Maintenance happens all the times in subways. In Montreal they do it during 4 hours each nights. In ours, they close everything down, thus we can no longer use it, but if we had multiple smaller one, we certainly could close one at a time and lower the perturbation. They could still close them all, theses tunnels aren't meant to be the only ways to drive either, even the biggest highways are closed from time to time to maintains them. > you couldn't physically fit enough cars through the tunnel to compare to real transit system That's seriously so weird to see that kind of comment on Hacker News. Never heard of horizontal scaling? There's more than a ways to increase capacity and the size of the unit sure is one, but the number of units is another one. It's like saying Google is impossible because you could never fit that many website on a single core, yeah luckily we can just add cores. > Given that this thing requires rigging something up to your vehicle, the onload and offload points would immediately become major bottlenecks to any serious throughput even if you could cram them in bumper to bumper. Then they'll come back to the skate system, which would fix the tire issue at the same time (and many others).
- Balgair 8y ago
- mrep 8y agoIs digging down really cheaper than going up? Chicago has got an elevated train [0] and even double decker streets [1] and those don't have lots of the problems that tunnels do like ventilation, escape tunnels, and moving all the dirt. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_%22L%22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_%22L%22 [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wacker_Drive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wacker_Drive
- scirocco 8y agoBut man is that train loud...
- Tiktaalik 8y agoThis is the sort of moronic "solution" one arrives at when they're unwilling to abandon the constraint of car ownership.
- purplezooey 8y agoMy first thought looking at the pic of the car coming out was geez, the exhaust fumes must be thick in that room...
- Tuna-Fish 8y agoThe tunnels will be EV-only.
- sibeshk96 8y agoOne of the things I don't get about this concept is how they plan to avoid the surface bottleneck - if everyone's trying to get into the same number of limited holes in the road, then there's more and more congestion and traffic wanting that access. To make a 3d network of roads work, you'd also need a 3d network of buildings, other wise it's not really solving any problem.