2 ms·
No an insight does not have to be communicated to someone else it can purely be for my own benefit. Insight and value IS two sides of the same coin, that's the
by ThomPete 8y ago
No an insight does not have to be communicated to someone else it can purely be for my own benefit.
Insight and value IS two sides of the same coin, that's the point.
You try to make them separate but insights without value are per definition not insights. It's the very point of insight that it has some value:
1 : the power or act of seeing into a situation : PENETRATION
2 : the act or result of apprehending the inner nature of things or of seeing intuitively
OTHER things can have value too but insights cannot not be valuable unless you don't mean the ability to see into a situation or understanding the inner nature of something is valuable.
- Retra 8y agoThere are valueless insights. Especially if you don't communicate them. If you're on an imploding submarine on the bottom of the ocean and you get a flash of insight about how to do cold fusion... there's no value there. You're dead. It's just a shame you didn't figure out something relevant to your situation, rather than someone else's.
- ThomPete 8y agoYou just defined the value and utility of it thus it is valuable whether he dies or not. Your argument is like saying that understanding cold fusion has no value because no one has communicated a valuable understanding of cold fusion. It might not be possible but if you by your own definition figure out how to do cold fusion then that is a valuable insight, whether or not it comes to fruition or the person dies. Insights cannot not be valuable, they don't have to be implemented to be valuable which is easily demonstrated by a simple thought experiment. If you had a time machine and could go back in time on that submarine right after he gets the idea on how to do it, extract that information and leave before he dies, would that be valuable? Of course it would. Getting an insight in the shower or getting an insight on drugs/mushrooms doesn't change the value of the insight whether it gets implemented or not.