4 ms·
This, yet again shows just how far the computer science is from real natural language processing, despite of all "AI" companies' claims. Unless they have all a
by baybal2 8y ago
This, yet again shows just how far the computer science is from real natural language processing, despite of all "AI" companies' claims.
Unless they have all and everything hardcoded, even such natural thing are impossible to process for the "natural" language processing programs.
All cloud "AI" and "natural" language processing services should really be called "lots and lots of hardcoded stuff language processing"
- blattimwind 8y agoState of the art virtual assistants offer little intelligence over a command line interface, except instead of typing the command line in, you say it. Besides that, not much difference; the syntax is rigid and the computer doesn't understand your utterance more intelligently than GCC understands "gcc -o my_prog my_prog.c".
- yters 8y agoIt would be interesting if AI assistants were described honestly in this manner as a "spoken command line interface" instead of as equivalent to human speech recognition. AI is mechanical turks all the way down.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoMy girlfriend routinely asks questions with convoluted grammar and gets a relevant response much of the time. I'm always amazed when it happens.
- taeric 8y agoExamples? I seem to constantly get nothing from simple grammar questions. :(
- PascLeRasc 8y agoI use a Google Home, not Alexa, but I ask it oddly-worded things all the time. Here's two from the past week that worked: "Can you see if Reply All has a new episode and if so play it?" "Can I still use these green peppers I got two weeks ago?"
- taeric 8y agoThat first one sounds promising. I'll have to see if I can adapt it. My devices are basically just gateways to audible, radio, and general timers. I have begun using the announcement features, but it is amusing to see the kids basically having announcement wars.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoAnd even with a rigid structure they only work for common cases. Using Siri in Italian and trying to get an English album playing is night impossible and vice versa.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoAlexa's shopping list definitely has room for improvement if it wants to be more natural. If I want to add bread and peanut butter to my shopping list, I need to say "Alexa, add peanut butter to my shopping list <pause> Alexa, add bread to my shopping list". If I say "Alexa, add bread and peanut butter to my shopping list", it adds a single item called "bread and peanut butter"
- gok 8y agoThat is literally the opposite of what this article says.