4 ms·
The term "alt-right" is used so frequently by the left that it has lost any meaning. But if it is meant to refer to far-right extremist movements, I don't think
by cm2187 8y ago
The term "alt-right" is used so frequently by the left that it has lost any meaning. But if it is meant to refer to far-right extremist movements, I don't think that should apply to either Peterson, Harris or Rubin.
- MikePemulis 8y agoI think the broader point is that the 'free speech' sites that these guys make end up being overrun by the alt-right and the out-and-out fash. But, on the question of Peterson being alt-right, his arguments for a willful re-adoption of mythical 'archetypes' as a basis for modern society is... well, excatly what happens with all far right ideologies, where a conception of social order is influenced by lobsters. (Cherry-picking bits of animal behaviour to explain human society is a mug's game, but if we were going to go down this route, why not create some vision of frozen gay ice cream orgies and child rearing, based on penguins?) But the real smelly herring in Peterson's schtick is his conflation of Marxism, post-moderism, and general identity politics. It's an invented bogeyman, detached from any real analysis of the cornerstones of modern poltiics. Again, it's absolutely a key strain of any rightish movement. A lot of this could be explained as him being more of a grifter than anything, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- raarts 8y agoThis makes me wonder. Would it be useful if HN added the age of an account which each comment?
- MikePemulis 8y agoKewl comment bro
- sctb 8y agoCould you please read the guidelines and start following them? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- yorwba 8y agoHN differentiates new users from the rest by giving them a green username.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lobs 8y agoNot that I agree with him, but in Peterson's defense he talks about lobsters just to show how fundamental the mechanisms related to hierarchies are in animals (point being they have existed for hundreds of millions of years, so they must be really important). You can't say the same about the behavior of penguins.
- diminoten 8y agoIt hasn't lost meaning with me, when I read "alt-right" I read "racist trolls". If you're saying it doesn't apply here, that's possibly fair, but one incorrect application doesn't wipe out the term. And to echo the point in my sibling comment, these new sites that emphasize free speech (definitely a good cause) tend to immediately face the question of, "how free is speech, really?" I honestly don't know if Reddit or Twitter, if started today, would have survived the onslaught. I don't know if anyone's figured out what to do that feels both "adhering to free speech concepts" as well as not becoming the next alt-right forum.
- sparkie 8y agoYour delusion is that you associate everyone on these platforms with the alt-right because some of them are alt-right. The reason alt-right flock to those platforms is because they are de-platformed elsewhere. This does not make the non alt-right people on those platforms suddenly become alt-right. And the reason "alt-right" and "racist troll" mean nothing is because they are used so liberally where they do not apply, and a few minutes of investigation would conclude that they do not apply. Consistent incorrect usage of language applied to something that it is not makes them lose their meaning. A solution to the "adhering to free speech" would be to allow free speech on platforms, and make it clear what is or isn't allowed on the platform, instead of using vague terms like "hate speech", which could be literally anything that some person finds undesirable.
- diminoten 8y agoIt's not a delusion, it's the association that kills new startups. You can rail against suppression of speech all you want, a company whose loudest and most active users are white supremacists either has to lean-in to that culture, remove it from the site entirely, or hide it. The first option is moral bankruptcy, the second option is an uncomfortable practicality on the limits of free speech, and the third option makes your new site look dead from the outside. You act like this is a simple problem to solve, but it's far from simple, and getting it even slightly wrong means startup death, period.
- 8y ago
- zimpenfish 8y ago> if it is meant to refer to far-right extremist movements No, "alt-right" is people who haven't gone "far-right" (yet) or who are hiding their "far-right"ness for an easier life / speaking gigs / patreon money / etc. > Peterson He certainly pals around with a lot of alt-right figures (Tucker Carlson, notably) and seems to have no problem appearing at Turning Point USA’s Student Action Summit which has quite the strongly conservative/alt-right/far-right[1] list of speakers. https://www.tpusa.com/sas/ https://www.tpusa.com/sas/ [1] Definitely Gorka and Farage.
- cm2187 8y agoI don't know. If I take the wikipedia definition [1] > The alt-right, or alternative right, is a loosely connected and somewhat ill-defined grouping of American white supremacists/white nationalists, white separatists, anti-Semites, neo-Nazis, neo-fascists, neo-Confederates, Holocaust deniers, conspiracy theorists and other far-right fringe hate groups. I don't see how Peterson fits in that category. In a way the fact that the term is abused by the left to refer to all sort of non extremist people seems to have given a new meaning that you are refering to. Kind of like far-left movements refering to "facists" anyone to their right in the 80s. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alt-right https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alt-right
- ghostly_s 8y agoPeterson is a vocal proponent of race "science" and regressive anti-feminist social structures. He's as right as they come, and he's "alt-right" because he's devoted his career to re-framing these ideals in ways that shake off the stigma they now carry.
- mpweiher 8y agoWhere is he a proponent of "race science"? Citation needed. And being an opponent of some of the more ludicrous off-shoots of modern feminism is not "alt-right", it's just common sense (and mainstream: for example only 9% of women in the UK consider themselves feminist[1]). And science, etc. Now I don't necessarily agree with his stances, but they are nothing if not well-reasoned and supported by data. Which is probably why he gets so much hate. [1] https://metro.co.uk/2016/10/18/we-asked-women-why-they-refuse-to-be-called-feminist-6198546/ https://metro.co.uk/2016/10/18/we-asked-women-why-they-refus...