6 ms·
Do you think the bomb maker could be held liable if the package were to be opened in a moving car that subsequently crashed because of glitter getting in the dr
by criddell 8y ago
Do you think the bomb maker could be held liable if the package were to be opened in a moving car that subsequently crashed because of glitter getting in the driver's eyes? I'd be a little nervous about doing this myself.
- PakG1 8y agoIANAL, but is that seriously a legal risk? The guy would have to explain he stole it.
- jayess 8y agoHere in the USA, everyone is litigation crazy, so an enterprising lawyer would probably happily file a suit against the maker if someone was injured because of it.
- devman0 8y agoThe issue though is since the box is so expensive (4 cell phones, custom boards, etc) stealing it was likely a felony. So you'd have to admit to a felony to sue or press charges against box maker. Second when committing a felony, in many jurisdiction the felon is automatically on the hook for any further 'bad things' that happen during the crime up to and including deaths. So if the felonious package thief got in an accident while opening a stolen package, it could all fall on them as a matter of statute in many places.
- duiker101 8y agoWhat if I just buy something very stupid that could scare someone but I actually wanted it for myself? Or what if I actually bought the same device in the video but I wanted it for some other use or for checking out how it's made?
- criddell 8y agoIntent matters. If you have a baseball bat in your car along with your glove and cleats, you have a piece of sports equipment. If you step out of your car with the bat and smash a car that cut you off in traffic, it's a weapon.
- jwdunne 8y agoIn the UK, if the police find a bat without a ball or some kind of proof it's for sports, they can consider it an offensive weapon.
- criddell 8y agoBooby traps are illegal and this feels like a booby trap. https://definitions.uslegal.com/b/booby-traps/ https://definitions.uslegal.com/b/booby-traps/
- MattSteelblade 8y agoFrom your link, "A booby trap may be defined as any concealed or camouflaged device designed to cause bodily injury..." There is nothing about his project designed to cause any bodily injury. This is a very important detail.
- raverbashing 8y agoIf being on your phone is bad, opening a package in a moving vehicle is probably worse
- Kirth 8y agoCould be opened by a passenger.
- toast0 8y agoTheif steals package, opens it while driving, crashes into another vehicle or otherwise damages property, life or limb. Maybe the theif has a hard time seeing you, but the other injured parties would likely sue you under the biggest pockets doctrine.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoUnlikely unless the circumstances are exceptional. You can sue anyone for anything. That would be a very uphill lawsuit in normal circumstances (the thief is being negligent by trying to open a package in a moving vehicle and any harm is a result of that negligence). When you add in the fact that the package is stolen it's highly unlikely to succeed. However, I write this from a US perspective. If self defense case law is any indication I suspect that the thief may have a case in the UK.
- Jonnerz 8y agoJust label the box with "DO NOT TAKE IN A CAR"
- alexandercrohde 8y agoRight, thief should have read the EULA
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 8y agoYes, if you create a hazard and then conceal it and by doing that harm someone else, you're going to be liable --- for the same reason that if you know about a hazard on your property, fail to correct it, post no warning, and it injures a burglar, the burglar will often have a civil claim against you (except here your liability is even clearer, since you deliberately created that hazard). I would be less worried about the thief's car and more worried about the car the thief runs into.
- j_m_b 8y agoIANAL... but banks use dye packs. This seems very close to that.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoA dye pack is designed to protect the cash by rendering it unusable, not to injure or otherwise affect the person stealing it.
- seattle_spring 8y agoDoes glitter cause injury?
- rtkwe 8y agoWe're in a universe where yes it did because the package was opened while driving or just happened to spray glitter in the thief's (or potentially a third party not associated directly with the theft) eye.
- gnopgnip 8y agoThe risk is minimal, you would have to open the box while driving for it to go off.
- kamaal 8y agoYou would have to prove, that you firstly stole the package(then you open a pandoras box of previous crimes), then prove that the person put it in the package(Very hard to prove, like whats the evidence). At the end you would just end up going to the police confess the crime, open the door to be prosecuted for other crimes. And yet end up proving nothing about the other person from whom you stole. It would be shooting in the foot at epic proportions.
- criddell 8y agoI was thinking more about civil liability and not necessarily from the thief. Say the thief crashes into pedestrians - the victims families might go after the thief and the bomb maker.