2 ms·
If you want to engage productively, remember that people tend to say things they think are true, so look for a way to read it that makes sense rather than going
by lmm 8y ago
If you want to engage productively, remember that people tend to say things they think are true, so look for a way to read it that makes sense rather than going out of your way to find a way to read it that makes it false. (I guess nitpicking the phrasing for a "middlebrow dismissal" is the best way to get upvotes here nowadays).
> nothing about this list implies "runs fast."
It doesn't imply it, but it enables it; read "allow" that way.
> Is a memory leak meant to be the "worst sort of bug" or a "security vulnerability?"
Maybe the one that makes sense rather than the one that doesn't make sense.
> The implication is that memory-safe languages do not have memory leaks, which is completely false.
There's no such implication, only that memory-unsafety leads to memory leaks, which is true.
> Or is Swift meant to be included in "garbage collected languages?"
Yes it is.
> No these are not the same and this is an absurdly wrong conflation.
They are the same; traditional dynamic typing is exactly unityping. That it's possible to combine dynamic typing with other things just means that alternatives are possible, not that dynamic typing is something different.
- jlokier 8y ago> > The implication is that memory-safe languages do not have memory leaks, which is completely false. > There's no such implication, only that memory-unsafety leads to memory leaks, which is true. If we're going to read in the spirit of "looking for a way to read things that make sense rather than going out of your way to find a way to read it that makes it false"... Then it depends which sort of implication. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implicature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implicature
- newen 8y agoNot really. p therefore q implies not p therefore not q is a very basic logical fallacy. Making a statement does not imply it's inverse.