4 ms·
>The 2016 election was swingy and it was uncertain. I don't remember it that way, in fact I remember seeing a lot of very shocked faces in the Democratic camp
by paganel 8y ago
>The 2016 election was swingy and it was uncertain.
I don't remember it that way, in fact I remember seeing a lot of very shocked faces in the Democratic camp when the results were beginning to take shape. I don't remember having seen similar confused reactions after any previous US presidential elections, not even after the Bush vs Gore one which was a lot closer in terms of electoral votes.
Back to the article, I think Nate Silver's failure only shows to the general public that electoral predictions are rubbish. Maybe "failure" is a strong word because he genuinely seems to be the best at what he's doing, it's just that the domain in which he's involved is turning out to be bogus. I'm sure that there was a crystal-ball viewer that was the best at what he/she was doing, it's just that crystal-ball viewing turned out to be bogus.
- FactolSarin 8y agoHowever, FiveThirtyEight gave Trump a 30% chance of winning, and in the days before the election was stressing the fact that a Trump win was very possible. They didn't predict his win, but they did better than anyone else in the mainstream.
- scott_s 8y agoI agree. I think people's shock was a failure of imagination. They couldn't imagine a Trump win, so even though the polling data showed he could, they discounted it. That, I think, explains why Silver was criticized so heavily for saying what he did days before the election: they couldn't imagine a Trump win, therefore he must lose, which Silver must also think, therefore Silver is trolling.
- paganel 8y ago> They didn't predict his win, but they did better than anyone else in the mainstream. Kind of proving my point, as it shows that Nate Silver was the best at crystal-balling the election result. Afaik 30% is still bellow the 50% (or 0.5/1) threshold generally needed to make a decision, as the article also mentions.