3 ms·
What's wrong with this picture let me count the ways. - Packagers are free volunteer labor that make your software available to the multitude of platforms your
by michaelmrose 8y ago
What's wrong with this picture let me count the ways.
- Packagers are free volunteer labor that make your software available to the multitude of platforms your software could potentially run on. On a lot of platforms the work required to turn your source into a useful package is work your end users wont do if someone doesn't package it for them. If you want people to do this laborious chore you at least speak to them kindly. After all they only get your and your users thanks for their work.
- Not being able to work without a very specific set of libraries and versions isn't necessarily broken but not being able to and not being able to express that in the build is highly suggestive that it is a huge pile of hacks. Reading their own words thereafter it is indeed a huge pile of hacks.
- The repo is a staging area for development of instructions to build software not a means to distribute software to end users. The makefile is a textual description of steps to build the software and other required libraries. On the one hand its dubious that it is copyrightable on the other if it is then copyright would lie with the github user developing openbsd. Further almost all of the code to be built strictly speaking belongs to the mozilla foundation. They are in fact asserting their trademark as a way to try to block people distributing machine readable instructions for building mozillas software.
Trademark exists to keep merchants from distributing confusingly branded goods. This is actually machine instructions for building their actual goods from their actual sources with settings they don't approve of.
To distribute the combined work would require rebranding. To distribute instructions to build their sources no more requires permission than saying the word palemoon here.
- They do not possess the wherewithal to pursue legal action especially legal action that would cost tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars to protect imaginary rights that they misunderstand. They have no revenue to speak of. Anyone can send a strongly worded letter and write cease and desist along the top in bold all caps printing. It doesn't make them a credible threat. When anyone can see the threat has no teeth it makes you look poor to make it.
- It's incredibly predictable that someone with no investment or gain in helping you distribute your software will simply stop helping you if you threaten them with lawyers or talk shit. Since this is a negative outcome why do it? 10 seconds to pause and speak respectfully would be such a small investment.
- They never realized their error and acknowledged their mistake.
- Normal behavior for people that build your software in an unapproved way is to refuse to support users using unapproved configuration. This is a social norm.
- Openbsd devs seem to have had good reason for their configuration choices that are perfectly reasonable.
Do we need 7 more bullet points?
- cweagans 8y agoIt may surprise you to hear that I don't disagree with any of your points. The software is probably not even worth downloading, much less using. However, you seem to be conflating arguments about the quality of their software and whether or not they should/shouldn't enforce their license. It's entirely possible that they wanted that repo to stop distributing their software.