4 ms·
6. Moderate alcohol intake, especially wine. The position that moderate alcohol consumption promotes health has been overturned [1]. Data now shows that the on
by chongli 8y ago
6. Moderate alcohol intake, especially wine.
The position that moderate alcohol consumption promotes health has been overturned [1]. Data now shows that the only safe level of alcohol consumption is zero. Every single drink increases your risks of alcohol-related disease. The previous data showing a benefit to moderate alcohol use may have been a result of some confounder such as social economic status or reverse causation (diseased people quit drinking).
[1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)31310-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- phreeza 8y agoI have seen this reference before, but if you look at Figure 5, it does not seem to agree with the statement that 0 is the only safe amount. Am I missing something?
- mxwsn 8y agoFrom the paper > In estimating the weighted relative risk curve, we found that consuming zero (95% UI 0·0–0·8) standard drinks daily minimised the overall risk of all health loss (figure 5). The risk rose monotonically with increasing amounts of daily drinking. Yet as you point out, from figure 5, 1 drink/day has an exceedingly minor increased risk from 0 drinks/day. Statistically, the health risk is increased, but the impact may be low enough that people may find it worthwhile to continue to drink a modest amount due to social, emotional, or other benefits.
- LanceH 8y agoSaying "any alcohol consumption is unsafe" probably overstates it. "Any alcohol consumption carries health risk" would be more correct.
- vokep 8y agoYes, this. Any driving is unsafe. Any life living is unsafe.
- chongli 8y agoYes. My point wasn't to suggest that all drinking is unsafe. My point was to refute the claim that moderate drinking is actually better for your health than no drinking. The study I linked does an excellent job of that. The conclusion that each drink carries a small but monotonically increasing risk with it completely contradicts the prior claim. And that only makes sense. If alcohol is a carcinogen, then every time you expose your cells to it you run the (very tiny) risk of producing the 'perfect storm' of mutations that causes cancer.
- johnchristopher 8y agoIs it safe to drink two or three beers in the same evening but every 5 or 6 months ?
- jayalpha 8y agoOthers would disagree: The Truth We Won’t Admit: Drinking Is Healthy https://psmag.com/social-justice/truth-wont-admit-drinking-healthy-87891 https://psmag.com/social-justice/truth-wont-admit-drinking-h... (Before you downvote, google the author Stanton Peele)
- littlestymaar 8y agoRefuting a peer-reviewed study (in the Lancet, no less) with an opinion post in “Pacific standard” is interesting. An the argument of authority never holds, we've seen Nobel prize winners beeing fond of conspiracy theories or other bullshit before…
- jayalpha 8y agoONE Study? I am sure I can google you a dozen other studies that show that moderate alcohol consumption, red wine consumption oder resveratrol consumption (must be the resveratrol, can't be the alcohol) is healthy. And had you actually read the article and not just vomited here into the forum then you would have realized that Pele cites and discusses many studies in the article.
- littlestymaar 8y agoThat's obviously how science works: just counting how many studies there is on each side, without paying attention to the publication or the methodology (preferably without even reading the abstract), and the truth is the one with the higher score… I've read your article (as well as the study cited above, did you ?) And it doesn't discuss several studies: it cherry-picks some that go in his direction and dismisses the others … Had you read the study, you'd have realized that: - the study came 4 years after the opinion post you shared. - the main argument of the post “a little amount of red wine is beneficial”, which is what we though in the past, has been refuted since: it's an artifact due to a co-founder (social status) and if you control for it, this surprising effect disappear (an so does the argument). On a historical note, you can find scores of this kind of article published in the 50s but talking about the absence of health impact of tobacco. Including many big scientific names of the time, most of them were smokers btw :).
- vokep 8y agoDoes this control for benefit from social anxiety reduction? Or benefit from experiences which wouldn't have even begun to occur (due to social anxiety)? "The only safe level of driving is 0" and yet its trivially clear that someone who chooses not to drive due to fear of the risks, may experience stress and other factors equal to or outweighing the risks that would result from driving. I'd guess a more accurate statement would be that there is no risk-free level of alcohol consumption. Because, ultimately, there isn't a safe level of being alive. When your metric of "safety" applies similarly to what makes life even worth living at all, and decries life "unsafe", it doesn't seem very useful.
- nonbel 8y agoThese types of studies (correlate [common behaviour] with [common health issue(s)] will "discover" whatever the prevailing opinion is of the day. The structure of the statistical models and what features get included is totally arbitrary, so they just play with it until the "right" result appears. In some cases you can even code male = 1, female = 0 and see (for example) alcohol is positively correlated with a health issue, but then reverse it to be male = 0, female = 1 and see alcohol is negatively correlated (see a simple example in [1]) Totally arbitrary. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16714522#16719754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16714522#16719754
- scottlocklin 8y agoThat study seems ... wrong. Estimating actual alcohol drunk from estimates of sales? Separate model for tourist consumption? Non linear spline model for distribution of drinking at 0-12.5 a day rates? No accounting for differences between cultures which binge drink (Northern europe) and countries with steady, consistent alcohol consumption with meals (southern europe). Yeah, seems legit. Not. And then figure 5 basically tells us the common wisdom ... a drink a day is harmless or good for you. I think it's pretty well established that drinking a whole lot is pretty bad for your health, and not drinking so much is at least not real harmful. Anything that gives totalitarian proscriptions of booze, particularly when accompanied by figure 5; well, that reminds me of back in the day when they insisted smoking a joint would poke giant wholes in my pre-frontal cortex and make dying of a heroin overdose inevitable.