6 ms·
> Isn't it exactly as unlikely that the 1st is the most long-lived, as the 17th being the longest-lived? No, because lifespan is not some completely random thi
by cortesoft 8y ago
> Isn't it exactly as unlikely that the 1st is the most long-lived, as the 17th being the longest-lived?
No, because lifespan is not some completely random thing. It is continually improving over time.
This would be like if the fastest 100m time was set 30 years ago, and hasn’t been broken since. This would be very strange, since the record actually keeps improving over time. It is not impossible (the long jump record stood for many years) but is at least not probable.
- Bartweiss 8y agoThis is generally a good point, but I'm not entirely sure it applies to high-end outliers for aging? We've improved medicine in a lot of ways, but rising lifespans (even measured from adulthood) are almost entirely driven by preventing certain premature deaths and increasing life expectancy for other terminal conditions. Very elderly people have generally escaped a lot of common mortality risks already (heart disease onset is 85% by age 80 in the US, implying that someone who doesn't have it at age 100 isn't likely to). Meanwhile, they rarely benefit from our improving treatments for other risks - we can substantially improve life expectancy for even incurable cancers in adulthood, but centenarians can't tolerate the sort of aggressive treatments we use for that result. (Interestingly, I had thought Alzheimer's was similar to heart disease, but annual onset rates at 90+ are almost as high as at 65-89 combined - it appears to simply be a steadily rising risk. Of course, we can't treat it well and incidents rates haven't changed much, so it's not really a factor in which cohort should have the longest lifespans.) The best visualization I've found is a bit messy, but nicely breaks down life expectancy by age over time. Since 1850, 70-year-olds appear to have gained about 7 years of expectancy, and I'm guessing 100-year-olds have gained substantially less. https://ourworldindata.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Life-expectancy-by-age-in-the-UK-1700-to-2013.png https://ourworldindata.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Life-e...
- scj 8y agoShe died about 20 years ago, which means we're only one generation away since her record was set. But there's a simple explanation: all of the people represented on the top 10 eldest list were contemporary to WW1, the Spanish Flu, the Depression, and WW2. In general, one side of the list would have been middle aged by the time WW1 started, and the other just barely met drafting age by the time the war was over. The people who would have been born in the early 1890s were hit hard by world events, their absence on the top 10 is likely a temporary dip that we're now just starting to come out of.