4 ms·
> Note that there are few software innovation identified in recent times. I believe that part of the reason is that over the last number of years some key softw
by GuB-42 8y ago
> Note that there are few software innovation identified in recent times. I believe that part of the reason is that over the last number of years some key software markets have been controlled by monopolies. Monopolies typically inhibit innovation; a monopoly has a strong financial incentive to keep things more or less the way they are.
I disagree. It is hard to talk about software innovation without mentioning Xerox PARC. The PARC existed because Xerox was a monopoly with too much money on their hands. Kind of like Google X today.
Monopolies in the software industry are actually quite fragile. Today's monopolies started small and took over the monopolies of the past in a relatively short amount of time. And the same fate will happen to them unless they keep innovating.
Tech is not like railways, where you can't build tracks anywhere you want because of things like land ownership and city planning. It is not like heavy industry where capital investments are huge and margins are low. Even their trove of personal data doesn't mean much: these get outdated rather quickly and machine learning rely less and less on huge datasets (see AlphaZero). Unsurprisingly, AlphaZero is a Google initiative, that's the kind of innovation that could be disruptive in someone else's hands, so they invest in it in order to keep their position.
- hyperpallium 8y agoXerox was a monopoly, but not a software monopoly. They didn't use the innovations of PARC to further their monopoly. Physics had a time of rapid innovation.
- jandrese 8y agoSeems like it's just an S curve. At first nobody knows what they are doing so it starts off slowly. Then you get the phase where the low hanging fruit gets picked off rapidly by everybody in the field. Lots of names get attached to fairly basic but important concepts. After some time the easy stuff is mined out and the pace of discovery slows substantially. Worse, it may take a good chunk of a lifetime to learn about everything that has already been discovered so you have an idea of where to look next. Or at least to get an idea of what not to investigate because it has already been discovered.
- porpoisely 8y agoXerox PARC is certainly important to computing and software history, but it was important as a research unit rather than an innovator. I may be just arguing semantics but my take is that researchers discover and innovators make it useful and bring it to the masses. Xerox PARC may have discovered the GUI but it was APPLE who made it useful and brought it to the masses. Although monopolies can innovate, there is no denying that monopolies are risk averse and have internal incentive to quash any innovations that may negatively affect their cash cows. Younger and smaller companies are more likely to take chances and be disruptive.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I disagree. It is hard to talk about software innovation without mentioning Xerox PARC. The PARC existed because Xerox was a monopoly with too much money on their hands. Kind of like Google X today. Xerox PARC can be understood as putting a bunch of smart people in one place and giving them essentially basic income. This seems to be a great way to do research work; beyond corporate monopolies, another successful source of basic income for researchers was DOD grants during the Cold War. A software monopoly that actually tries to monetize the research output directly interferes with this scheme a bit. > Tech is not like railways, where you can't build tracks anywhere you want because of things like land ownership and city planning. We don't have that, but we now have software patents, which are even worse in the way - not only you have to pay a lot of money to just be able to work, with software patents it's easy for existing players to just lock out whole areas of development by speculatively applying for, or buying, patents.