3 ms·
Or they could have just bought all rights at the start. Then the author gets paid / is happy and they can do what they want.
by protomyth 16y ago
Or they could have just bought all rights at the start. Then the author gets paid / is happy and they can do what they want.
- AngryParsley 16y agoThank you, Captain Hindsight!
- protomyth 16y agoIt wouldn't be hindsight for Dragon magazine. They were publishing "Best of" volumes throughout their run. It isn't like we are talking ancient history, the CD-ROM and collections of magazines were well within the time era of most of their issues.
- camiller 16y agoThat gets back to the other part of ja27's argument "...they never imagined that they'd want to republish articles electronically...". I'd be willing to bet that almost no print media is currently securing the rights to directly load content into the brain. They may regret that 50 years from now.
- ja27 16y agoI wonder how someone like National Geographic does it, since they seem to have no problem publishing electronic versions. Maybe they've just automatically secured all rights? Or only used staff writers/photographers so they only publish things produced as "work for hire"?
- ghaff 16y agoIt's been a legal issue: Greenberg v. National Geographic Society http://www.publaw.com/erights3.html http://www.publaw.com/erights3.html
- alexqgb 16y agoActually, most rights clearance agreements have boilerplate language about the agreement covering "all mediums and distribution forms, existing or yet to be developed, throughout the universe, in perpetuity." Basically, 'anything, everywhere, forever'. The language was probably developed by the insurance companies that handle claims for E&O (Errors & Omissions), and who know exactly how common these problems are. Chances are, that's where the $2k came from too; not Hasbro, but Hasbro's underwriter.
- plorkyeran 16y agoPaying for rights that you don't intend to use until 20 years later sounds like a good way to ensure that your company doesn't last long enough to take advantage of those rights.
- protomyth 16y agoWell, depending on how good the article was and how long they retained the rights, it might make it difficult to publish one of their "Best Of" collections. I would imagine (haven't see a contract lately) that everyone is reserving all "electronic" means.