7 ms·
Is the Psychology of Deadly Force Ready for the Courts?
- chmod775 8y agoSeems to be missing the fact that if you are unable to handle stressful situations you have no business being a police officer in the first place. Becoming a police officer is akin to stating: "I will approach confrontations level-headed and try to deescalate" and I'm sure police officers receive training to that end as well.
- iseeyoubydesign 8y ago"stressful situations" ... then you do it
- vorpalhex 8y agoNobody is prepared to handle life-or-death stressful situations. Training at least makes those experiences less terrible, but the only life-or-death stress response you have born in you is your fight-or-flight meant to ward off primarily large predators.
- lostmyoldone 8y agoI don't know about that, while there might be some kinds of life-or-death situations that nobody can handle, there seems to be plenty of people that is as capable of handling some life-or-death situations better than I handle grocery shopping.
- aqme28 8y agoSure, no one is fully equipped to handle the moment of their death, but that's not what is being talked about here. Training should equip officers for the not-uncommon case when a suspect has a knife but is otherwise nonthreatening.
- vorpalhex 8y ago> when a suspect has a knife but is otherwise nonthreatening A knife is a deadly weapon. Even a non-deadly strike from a knife means a loss of organs (lung puncture, liver intrusion), limbs, facial tissue, eyes, etc. If someone is threatening with a knife (attacking cop cars, etc), especially if they are not acting entirely sanely, they are an active life-or-death threat and yes, you might absolutely be walking into the moments before your death. Even if you have a gun, you have at best a few heartbeats to make a judgement call if they decide to lunge for you. Especially if your firearm is in it's holster, in the time it takes for an attacker to lunge at you, you need to: 1. Establish a positive grip on the firearm 2. Defeat any safety measures on the holster (snaps, buttons, interlocks) 3. Clear the holster with a duty sized firearm 4. Draw firearm to combat position 5. Secure off hand grip to firearm 6. Obtain sight picture 7. Check target and backstop 8. Squeeze trigger The person who intends to kill you meanwhile needs to do the following: 1. Lunge forward with knife angled outwards If it's available in your area, I recommend taking a use-of-force seminar and seeing how well you do with the above kind of scenario.
- jki275 8y ago21 foot rule.
- aqme28 8y agoNone of that is relevant here. This was a man _walking away_ with his back turned. That's what I meant by nonthreatening.
- vorpalhex 8y agoIf someone threatens your life with a deadly weapon, the fact that they've turned their back for a moment and headed towards other people (innocent people, your comrades, etc) doesn't make them not a threat anymore. As a police officer, you have an obligation to keep the public safe, and that includes from knife wielding nutcases. Yes, it'd be great if cops could bear hug everyone into submission, but that's not the reality of the situation.
- deleted 8y ago
- trhway 8y agoFor example there are medical tests for pilots and other professions where the lives depend on sound mental and physical health of the operator. The same should be for police - can't handle the stress, got overflooded with stress hormones so that mental function drops below threshold - you dont get the right to kill. Carrying the gun knowing that stress severe impairs your perception and executive function means negligently putting public in danger akin to drunk driving.
- alistairSH 8y agoMy similar thought... isn't this an argument to disarm police officers? If their brains turn them into killers, take away the tool they use to commit the killing. Police isn't even one of the top-10 most dangerous jobs - they're beaten out by auto service supervisors (not even the guy with the wrench!) and airline pilots.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>they're beaten out by auto service supervisors Being a supervisor where work involving heavy equipment is happening is can be more dangerous because you're not as familiar with all the heavy equipment around you and depending on how much of an ass you are or aren't your team might not be comfortable speaking up when you do dumb things. It definitely depends on the supervisor though. That said, the numbers don't lie. Policing is not nearly as dangerous as it is made out to be.
- alistairSH 8y agoI'm sure police officers receive training to that end as well You would be mistaken in that assumption. Police in the US receive a fraction of the training provided to their counterparts in Germany and the UK. This is across the board, all types of training. They receive even less deescalation training, and in fact sometimes receive the exact opposite (training akin to "police as warrior").
- alexanderwept 8y agoThe Court's authority is derived from deadly force, they better be prepared to grapple with its use.
- btilly 8y agoGiven the replication crisis, is psychology ready for much of anything? Yes, I admit that this is snarky, but it is also uncomfortably true. There is good evidence that things said by psychology that also fit common sense are probably true. However things said by psychology research studies have a good chance of being false. And things concluded by individual psychologists upon a chain of research based on those studies should be viewed with significant skepticism. This will change when psychology can get from their current 50% replication rate (on a good day) to having a significant body of established research that we have good reason to believe is about 90% likely to be replicable. Until then I'd advise against placing too much trust in anything that it says which you can't find independent reason to believe.
- SpikeDad 8y agoYou have hopes that psychology is a robust enough science that it can improve it's replication rate? Not sure there's evidence of this at all.
- btilly 8y agoYes, I have hope that psychology is trying to replicate what they thought were established results. After a few rounds of that we'll have a limited body of knowledge that has been successfully replicated enough that, despite the overall replication rate, we can trust those results. Once that body of reasonably certain psychological observations is established and starts growing, it will be possible to make some statements about psychology with a high degree of confidence. But whether that coalesces into a paradigm about how to understand people that turns it into a recognizable science is another story.
- SpikeDad 8y agoSeems difficult to imagine such positivity with replication considering how much psychological science depends on subjective information from subjects using "evaluation tools". Who knows what it means when I answer the question "How depressed am I" with 5?
- 8y ago
- pjc50 8y agoThe key question is: is the "stress" argument ever going to be successfully deployed to exculpate someone who, in a stressful situation with a weapon, shoots a police officer? No, of course not. The American use of deadly force by police is far in excess of other first-world countries, and it has become a deadly part of the culture war. Various people have commented that the US troops in the occupation of Iraq had more restrictive rules of engagement.
- tylerflick 8y ago> Various people have commented that the US troops in the occupation of Iraq had more restrictive rules of engagement. That's a generalization. Certain areas of operation had different rules of engagement, which also changed over time. As a base though, if you could prove hostile intent, you were cleared for the use of deadly force.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoHostile intent is still a much, much higher bar than "I was spooked" which seems to be the current requirement for cops to use deadly force.
- turc1656 8y agoExactly. We've seen countless examples of "I thought he had a gun" and "I feared for my life" from cops. Can I shoot someone if I think they have a gun but, oops, it turns out I was wrong? I'd be fine, right? I'm sure I wouldn't face any serious consequences. And therein lies the problem. There's a separate set of (lower) standards applied to the very people who are trained for this sort of thing and who are allegedly held to a higher standard.
- CompanionCuuube 8y ago>Can I shoot someone if I think they have a gun but, oops, it turns out I was wrong? I'd be fine, right? I'm sure I wouldn't face any serious consequences. If the totality of the circumstances show that a reasonable person would believe that they had a gun and there was a threat to your life, then I would expect you not to have serious consequences in the form of criminal penalties.
- SpikeDad 8y agoInteresting article. I wonder if there's evidence that the mindset of a police officer reflects the general public. Sorry to have to generalize here but I've had a lot of exposure to police over my life as a volunteer EMT and an ex wife who's department was part of a police department. I have a lot of friends who are police officers. They have one thing in common (mostly) - they think they're right about every situation. I don't think the general public thinks the same way. Of course I have no idea if that's a selected behavior or something they learn during their time as police officers. I can certainly see how it's a beneficial behavior from a stress standpoint but we can see how it turns out with respect to these deadly force encounters. I have a lot of respect for law enforcement but also personal knowledge enough that their decision making strategies are not like mine.
- pjc50 8y agoWell, if you had a gun and permission to shoot people for being "uncooperative" or "resisting" or "refusing to obey orders", you'd be right all the time too.
- philwelch 8y agoThere's a cognitive bias where bad things stick out more than good things, which is helpful from a problem-solving perspective by helping you focus on problems that need to be solved, but it has a side effect where any job that involves dealing with the public leaves you increasingly convinced that the world is filled with people who are just plain awful at least in some respect. Of course, the world is filled with these people, but not to the proportion it seems. You just remember the bad a lot more easily than the good. Also, police officers tend to disproportionately deal with awful people anyway.
- mc32 8y agoIn my youthful interactions with police, the sense I got was they were sure the knew the _law_ correctly. They didn't think they were always right outside of that, but they thought they were always right about the law and the events that unfolded (they might have been giving events their own interpretation to which they assigned certainty). Now, of course, this is typically the meat of the matter when interacting with police, but I'm pointing out that outside of this space, in my experience, they did not presume more knowledge than your average person.
- edflsafoiewq 8y agoThis looks like nothing so much as the old determinist's "how can you be morally culpable when the outcome was predetermined by natural laws?" dusted off and dressed up with some psychology jargon.
- intralizee 8y agoI think the jury would have a better time first understanding predetermination & determinism, than the psychological jargon as you put it. Maybe psychologists have found a stigma against determinism by the free will thinkers and so they find the need to dress it up as something else.
- markbnj 8y agoIt feels to me like the question of how humans react to life-threatening situations is less relevant here than the question of how humans judge what _is_ a life threatening situation. Are you in imminent danger of death if you encounter a teenager walking away from you in the middle of the street at night? I think most people would judge that situation to be non-life-threatening and I guess the jury in the referenced case agreed.
- turc1656 8y agoThe real issue here is whether or not this same logic will apply to the average citizen. And we know it won't. Nor should it. At the end of the day, we are responsible for our actions with only very, very few exceptions that are already laid out in the law (i.e. temporary insanity, severe mental illness, etc.). It sounds like what is being argued for my Miller is that we expand the exception list in a big way. One that society likely will find unacceptable. Also, I'd be really curious to see if Miller wants to apply this same standard to everyone across the board. Because right now, if I shoot someone - even if in self defense - there's a good chance that I will be charged and have to defend myself in court to prove it was in self defense and a lawful act because the bar for me being apply to apply deadly force is very high. The rules are already very different for cops in the current state of affairs. They already have every advantage and already face extremely low odds of being charged. As the article mentions, only 96 officers have been charged since 2005, which is ridiculous. We've seen a lot of absurd cases that were major news where officers weren't even charged. Sure, I would bet that the overwhelming majority are totally legitimate. But I also think there are way too many that go un-charged. And I'd bet my life (no pun intended) that this same logic will definitely not apply to the average citizen if they shoot another citizen. And I'd bet my child's life that this logic would never, ever, ever be used in defense of a citizen if they had the gall to shoot (gasp) a police officer. We the people bear some responsibility for this situation of officer shootings. Juries routinely either fail to indict in the grand jury or acquit if it actually goes to trial far too often. And these jurors themselves do not apply the same standards that would apply to the rest of us. Accounting for population difference, on a per capita basis US police officers shoot citizens at a rate 37 times more frequently than the UK. Now, you can either choose to believe that the US has 37 times more serious violent crime that would justify that level of violence by cops. Or you can choose to believe there is a problem with US the way US police go about their business.
- adrianratnapala 8y ago> Accounting for population difference, on a per capita basis US police officers shoot citizens at a rate 37 times more frequently than the UK. The UK is not a good example, since it is one of the few countries where most cops don't have guns.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoThe current system has two sets of rules, one for cops, one for everyone else. It's like how in medieval Europe a knight would be justified if he cut down a normal person in circumstances where a normal person could not engage in violence against another normal person. That's all fine and dandy (I'm being sarcastic when I say that) except that out current societal norms and laws prohibit double standards like that. This is just an attempt at bastardizing science and law in order to uphold the double standard when what we really need is to apply the same standard to police use of force as we do to normal people
- onemoresoop 8y agoDr. Laurence Miller: "His fee as an expert witness in cases that require travel is $10,000 per day of testimony" I don't know how Mr Miller gets to be an expert witness but it seems to me that Law Enforcement pays him quite well to be in the business of being a witness...
- CompanionCuuube 8y agoHint: it's those letters in front of his first name.