4 ms·
That was powerful. I once spent weeks packing donated children's toys and also spent a while in an auto plant. And there's this awful feeling I had at both. I
by Waterluvian 8y ago
That was powerful.
I once spent weeks packing donated children's toys and also spent a while in an auto plant. And there's this awful feeling I had at both. I would describe it as the place being contaminated by depression and if you stay too long you'll succumb to it.
These fulfillment centres are like Chernobyl in that sense. It all looks normal: there's merchandise we see at home, there's other people, there's music, there's employment. But it also just feels like you've entered a foreign environment that isn't capable of sustaining healthy human life.
I felt it again just reading this story. That urge to fight and cry is a sign that you're being exposed to too much contamination.
We need to get the humans out of there and send in robots to do that work.
- badpun 8y agoMy family member has been working at an auto plant for over a decade now. She does not seem depressed. She is grateful for the job (had to use personal connections to get it) and would be scared of the thought of robots replacing her.
- matt4077 8y agoI believe Amazon has built a somewhat more dreadful work environment than traditional factories. First, it seems like they have optimized every last detail to the point where people are robbed of their individuality. If your wrist watch tells you when to pee, that leaves traces not just in your underwear, but in your psyche. Second, traditional blue-collar work came with a social support network, build-in. There was a sense of belonging that can be described as anything from “class consciousness” to just the typical camaraderie of working a job, any job, with the same team for years. Amazon actively works against this when, for example, working against the formation of unions. They also inadvertently prevent it through their reliance on temporary work, and rapidly changing assignments, work procedures, etc.
- ataturk 8y agoPeople have choices. You don't have to be a beat down slave all your life. You can revolt. It's just that the will to revolt hasn't risen in recent times. But it would be interesting to see it happen again because I simply can't see how contemporary culture can continue a whole lot longer. What I basically found out trying to "retire early" is that there are the "high" paying career jobs in offices and everything else is $10-$15/hr. crap work. There is barely anything in between, mirroring what is happening to the middle class--it is being hollowed out so that there will only be rich and poor and nothing else. Places like Mexico are already like this. It is sad and completely avoidable, but oligarchs and autocrats don't want it that way. So revolution it will be. Only a matter of time and hunger.
- badpun 8y agoWhat about skilled trades? Electricians, carpenters or plumbers (esp. self-employed) must be making more than $10-$15/h.
- freddie_mercury 8y ago> I believe Amazon has built a somewhat more dreadful work environment than traditional factories. I kinda feel like you are comparing highly paid, often unionized factories with Amazon. Of course Amazon will come up short. But when I read, say, about how modern chicken processing plants work, Amazon doesn't sound so horrible. Here's the 2017 list of worst OSHA violations; Amazon doesn't appear on it. https://www.safetyandhealthmagazine.com/articles/16362-oshas-top-10-most-cited-violations-for-2017 https://www.safetyandhealthmagazine.com/articles/16362-oshas...
- rpeden 8y agoThis kind of dehumanization isn't at all new in factory-type environments. Frederick Taylor's The Principles of Scientific Management[1] was very popular 100 years ago, and included things like time and motion studies[2] which served to optimize processes as much as possible and remove individual variations as much as possible. The whole point was pretty much to make every worker a replaceable cog in the industrial machine. I'd argue that this is actually pretty much what happened - and as the abilities of robots and other forms of automation grew, it was easy to replace humans because so much of the work had already been precisely measured and systematized. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Principles_of_Scientific_Management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Principles_of_Scientific_M... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_and_motion_study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_and_motion_study
- flattone 8y agoAgree. Not everyone is walking around with the "repetitive work is depressing" brain". In fact any change to an almost robotic daily productivity routine turns some folks into temporary ptsd patients.
- badpun 8y agoYep. In her case, she is definitely not a fast learner, but is very scrupulous. She's a great fit for a repetetive manual labor job. Of course, the work is very demanding compared to what we do, but she does not know any other kind of work, so she's okay with it. I suspect that was the issue with the author of the original article - moving from being a freelance writer (sounds like a relatively cushy job) to an Amazon site worker must have seemed like entering hell.
- flattone 8y ago>moving from being a freelance writer (sounds like a relatively cushy job) to an Amazon site worker must have seemed like entering hell. Agree. Everyone has some version of their own hell. Somewhere out there.
- Waterluvian 8y agoYeah, that's a very fair point. I am speaking from my own context, which isn't the context that everyone shares.
- zackmorris 8y agoI moved furniture for 2 years and delivered appliances for 1 year in my early 20s in order to finance my shareware business. There is a bleakness to physical labor jobs that can't be understood by someone working mental labor jobs. It's not just the low pay, the early/long hours, the dangerous environment, the constant barking of orders, the hustle and bustle of being pushed to work 10% faster than is sustainable, the staff of ex-military and ex-cons (some of the most disciplined, hardest working and nicest people I've ever met - as long as you don't cross them). It's the fact that you have to do this tomorrow. And the next day. And the day after that.. as far forward into the future as you care to speculate. Knowing that 100% of the money you make goes to living expenses, children and debts. That any portion you spend on basic recreation like beer will be frowned upon by people who don't have the willpower to work as hard as you do. You have to develop a tough skin and shut down your conscious mind, going into another place in yourself in order to make it. I watched dozens of people try to do it over the years and most of them never made it more than 2 weeks. By the end of it, I learned that the only winning move is not to play. By working there, I had taken someone's job who needed the money more than I did. What's worse, is I had lowered everyone's pay by increasing the size of the labor pool. I had squandered my own potential. The only good thing to come from that job is it made me realize that I must dedicate my life to ending labor as we know it. We need to automate these jobs and use the free capital to fund a moonshot reeducation program. Give everyone the opportunity to use their minds - not their bodies - for income and move to a UBI to liberate the unlimited human potential that we steal through wage slavery.