6 ms·
In my experience, few people are NOT trapped in a filter bubble. If you've ever moved from a conservative area to a liberal area of the country, or vice versa,
by chrisco255 8y ago
In my experience, few people are NOT trapped in a filter bubble. If you've ever moved from a conservative area to a liberal area of the country, or vice versa, you'll feel this in your interactions with people. In modern politics, it's far more difficult to find people who are able to constructively engage with both sides than it is to find blatant partisans. Simple test for this is to ask some one to describe the positions of the other party and why they feel the way they do without using any disparaging or cynical terms. Fun experiment, I invite you to try it.
- MrQuincle 8y agoYour approach sounds like a confrontational approach. In "The culture map" it is described that the US culture is far less confrontational than e.g. France. It might be difficult to engage in a discussion without disclaimers such as "let me play devil's advocate". As in this book is explained, an American was wondering why the French at the dinner table were laughing together after a heated discussion on a topic short before. A discussion is not a personal attack. However, in the US it is quicker felt this way. Hence, that people are not trapped in filter bubbles should not be countered by an argument based on a personal confrontational approach about how constructively they engage in political discussions.
- honestoHeminway 8y agoIn the cult of the individual, any confrontation is heresy. To be tortured for the comon good in the public plaza, by having your opinion attacked, that is pure evil. Rather fan out and form a thousand little new countries, within the country, declaring independence from washington or the rust-belt.
- lanevorockz 8y agoFrench are not heavy users of social media. It is social media and agenda driven journalism that creates the polarisation.
- sharemywin 8y agoThat's not what causes polarization. Those just speed it up and amplify it.
- barrow-rider 8y agoWhile social media usage is lower in France[1], it's laughable to say that it's not a force. Nor is agenda & social-media driven journalism less of a thing, it's just mitigated by government fairness doctrines[2] -- but certainly still there. Hell, you can make a prima facie argument that this is totally true just by looking at the massive riots happening all across France. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/284435/france-social-network-penetration/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/284435/france-social-net... [2] https://www.extradigital.co.uk/articles/social-media/social-media-use-france.html https://www.extradigital.co.uk/articles/social-media/social-...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beobab 8y agoI've found that it's important to discover whether the other party understands the word "argument" to mean "disagreement" or "logical reasoning". If you don't agree on basic word meaning, then it's hard to hold a rational conversation.
- new299 8y agoThe word can be used in both ways, depending on the context?
- jonathanstrange 8y agoYes. It's a peculiarity of the English language.
- godelski 8y agoIt is always strange to me how this happens. You are exactly right in asking how one describes the other party. People are really similar, just with different beliefs.
- snaky 8y agoSpeaking of that, > We provide a set of results that, given a set of individuals' belief systems, allow a systematic determination of which topics will reach a consensus, and which topics will disagreement in arise. https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.05138 https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.05138
- gammateam 8y agoEvery time your parents or grandparents say something insensitive about a group of people, I always think about how it is currently socially acceptable to think of the other party as irreconcilable dangerous mentally unstable people This kind of thought was acceptable and comforting to your parents about people that now contribute greatly to society Everyone is doing it across the party line right now and it is ridiculous and they dont know that people in the other party are taking the exact same approach Almost no party and no issue is based on the exact opposite reasoning for not agreeing So that means people are a lot more reconcilable than some party line quip would suggest
- dchichkov 8y agoUse of disparaging terms is arguably caused by the need to belong to local community. That is, if you don't want to be outsider, you have to use "appropriate" language and show "correct" values (on climate change, abortion, etc). So arguably it is more of a local, group identity effect, like being a fun of a local sports team, than a true bubble / filter effect.
- chrisco255 8y agoGroup identities are the best way to create filter bubbles. Once you've aligned yourself with a group, you're less likely to be swayed by "outsiders". You'll resist, even if subconsciously, any suggestion which opposes your team's view, because you'll begin to develop an identity around those viewpoints. Few people are well-practiced at challenging their own identities. Check out this excellent essay by PG, "Keep Your Identity Small", for a better description of this phenomenon: http://paulgraham.com/identity.html http://paulgraham.com/identity.html
- RodericDay 8y ago"keep your identity small", advises white rich straight dude with no political opinions that threaten the status quo
- dchichkov 8y agoThank you. It is of an excellent quality. I would add, a modern definition of a "humanist", which includes "scientist" in its core might be a good core for a modern minimalistic identity. And thank you again, for bringing this to my attention. I'm going to put it into my AGI research notebook ;)
- RodericDay 8y agoyeah hate it when I have to pretend to have the "correct" values on slavery, flat earth theory, and women's suffrage just to fit in
- sien 8y agoYou've described an 'Ideological Turing Test' : https://www.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/the_ideological.html https://www.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/the_ideological.htm... It's a fun thing to try and do.
- elliekelly 8y ago> If someone can correctly explain a position but continue to disagree with it, that position is less likely to be correct. And if ability to correctly explain a position leads almost automatically to agreement with it, that position is more likely to be correct. Wow, really interesting. Thanks for sharing!
- watwut 8y agoThe moment you framed it as two sides you pushed people toward creating one overreaching characterization for both sides. It is effectively asking for partizan position, because no other is possible. The other question is, what if the cynical disparaging term is factually correct one for portions of each party?
- Applejinx 8y agoAnd of course 'both sides' is itself a filter bubble reducing analysis to one particularly rigid point of view…
- chrisco255 8y agoWell if someone is even able to describe the other side in a nuanced way, breaking down some of the points of view of the various factions that make up each side...I would say they're half way there. A cynical, disparaging term is opinion, not fact. So you can't be "factually correct" when evaluating someone's opinion.
- watwut 8y agoA lot of disparaging comments express real things. Coward, racist, flip floper, unprincipled. These exists and are also disparaging. I think that if you start with assumption of two sides and your question forces the person to be in one, then you already stopped being nuanced. Because the other side are those whose views are as far from mine as possible by definition.
- chrisco255 8y agoI think insults definitely have utility. They're persuasive tools that cut through cruft...but they're also opinions. It's not a "fact" that someone is being cowardly, for example...that's just an observational opinion. From a certain point of view, someone can seem like a coward and from another point of view they can seem heroic. These are perceptual things...so they're not facts.
- 8y ago
- lazyasciiart 8y agoI'm not sure that has any bearing on whether they are "trapped in a filter bubble". It is quite possible to very deeply understand the motivations and thoughts of a group and still be blatantly disparaging - ask a historian, for instance.
- chrisco255 8y agoLet's say you have a historian who believes that historical group X were terrible human beings. How likely do you suppose that this historian would be open to new information that shed new light on group X, with some positive and possibly redemptive qualities? I reckon, based on my understanding of human nature, that historian would take a while to come around, if they ever revised their perspective at all.
- watwut 8y ago> Let's say you have a historian who believes that historical group X were terrible human beings. How likely do you suppose that this historian would be open to new information that shed new light on group X, with some positive and possibly redemptive qualities? Pretty much all historians face that whenever analyzing WWII. Answer is partly in historians not making direct moral judgement in their historical work. The goal is not to decide whether people were "good" or "bad". That is for philosophers and fiction writers.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>How likely do you suppose that this historian would be open to new information... New "information", yeah, not very likely at all. New "evidence", very likely indeed. "Evidence", can be investigated for veracity. Information, is no better than you and I sitting around making up stuff. I think that's a subtle but important distinction that I think a lot of people don't understand about the work of a historian. You have plenty of people who wrote down a story about Agincourt for instance. Plenty of people will still tell you some story about Agincourt today. But only a very, very, few of those stories are consistent with the evidence. For example: ---- Hmm, there are a shit ton of arrow heads at Agincourt. Wow! They're all laying in EXACTLY the distribution that long dead historian X indicated given his account of the battle. Hmm. None of them are where long dead historian Y indicated given her account of the battle. ---- You analyze historical site after historical site, and after a while, you figure out that the accounts of long dead historian X nearly always align closely with the physical historical evidence. So... yeah... naturally after a while, over the hundreds of years that pass, more and more historians start believing long dead historian X rather than long dead historian Y.
- jonathanstrange 8y agoYou're from the US, right? What you describe seems to be the default behaviour of humans on the one hand, and the effect of political polarization in the US on the other hand. Neither of those phenomena are necessarily based on filter bubbles.
- mirimir 8y agoI've always hated shaving. And I also hate trimming beards. When I was working in meatspace, I just kept my head and face at about 3-5 mm. But now, I'm just Mr Natural. So now, among my friends and their families, I'm just another old hippie. But in conservative areas, I can easily pass as Duck Dynasty :) Especially if I'm wearing my NRA hat ;)
- agsdfgsd 8y ago>Simple test for this is to ask some one to describe the positions of the other party and why they feel the way they do without using any disparaging or cynical terms That doesn't work because liberals are unable to understand and empathize with conservative views. They lack the same fundamental values, and so they are unable to see conservative views as being within a set of values that are different from their own. Instead they see conservative views as being contrary to values, period. Liberals being asked to answer a survey the way they think a conservative would will answer agree/disagree questions like "one of the worst things a person could do is hurt a defenseless animal" with disagree, but actual conservatives say agree. On the other hand, conservatives are able to accurately answer the same survey as a liberal would. Moderates are able to answer accurately as either a liberal or a conservative. https://theindependentwhig.com/haidt-passages/haidt/conservatives-understand-liberals-better-than-liberals-understand-conservatives/ https://theindependentwhig.com/haidt-passages/haidt/conserva...
- dyeje 8y agoCan you provide the actual study? I find this anecdote hard to believe.
- agsdfgsd 8y agohttps://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0050092 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- abritinthebay 8y agoSo what you’re saying is that you, and the authors of the article, failed the Untellectual Turing Test then? Because that’s verifiably nonsense if you actually talked to anyone liberal. Most liberal policy even stems from empathetic roots! I totally understand—-and often agree with—-conservative (in the political sense) values. In fact, when you get down to it they are not very complex and different. The disagreement is generally in how to best promote & empower those values. Not about them. Very vigorous disagreement. There will, of course, be some values each side fundamentally disagrees on. That’s ok, it’s expected.