2 ms·
The idea that people who report being intensely allied to particular political parties would automatically be the people who we should be most concerned about b
by pessimizer 8y ago
The idea that people who report being intensely allied to particular political parties would automatically be the people who we should be most concerned about being in filter bubbles is bizarre, and is part of a broader media narrative that all opinions right or left of the NYT and WaPo editorial pages are the result of manipulation. This seems like one of a cluster of centrist articles attempting to debunk this idea, specifically targeted at Republican bleating about tech-media companies hiding left-wing bias behind claims that they have objective algorithms that have no particular political content.
They're twisting the finding, culled from mashing together a number of studies (not any particular study) and summarized in a whitepaper, that find when you monitor the people who self-report the most partisan consumption of news, it turns out that they actually read a lot of different sources. In other words, they've discovered that the most angry readers of news spend as much time hate-reading as reading outlets that they agree with.
Interesting finding by itself. Instead of reporting that, though, they transform the group that most self-reports being in what the authors would call a filter bubble (i.e. they report only watching Maddow or only watching Fox) into the group most likely in a filter bubble, they find that group to not be in a filter bubble, then they declare the non-existence of filter bubbles. It's really garbled logic.
I'd submit that the people most likely to be affected by a filter bubble would be the people who read political news the least, and where the few examples of what they look up would create a skewed algorithmic perception of their interests. I'd further submit that those people would far outnumber the extreme party partisans, but their votes would count equally, so the fact that extreme partisans who are already absolutely sure how they will vote are not trapped in filter bubbles is of far less importance than the people who are not sure about how they will vote, and are affected by new information.
- Nasrudith 8y agoTo be frank it seems like old media is increasingly wearing its envy on their sleeve relatively recently. They tried ignoring them at first. then they tried integrating where after ignoring everything on the internet suddenly leaping onto twitter. Then when that doesn't work they started getting angry and trying to make tech the new villain for everything. Like claiming that outright fabricated news for an agenda started with them - no just look at Hearst for one. There is the incredibly obvious 'tech-lash' astroturfed push and trying to invoke antitrust - all while dutifully ignoring the actual monopolies and media conglomeration. And the Sinclair 'hive-mind' dystopian propaganda pushing that received far less attention than Facebook selling ads.