3 ms·
Consider not going on a modern airliner. Every commercial passenger jet since the A340 has been fly-by-wire. (military jets have been so longer).
by gumby 8y ago
Consider not going on a modern airliner. Every commercial passenger jet since the A340 has been fly-by-wire.
(military jets have been so longer).
- jolmg 8y agoBut you have more time to react on a plane and switch to manual override. It's not like people fly with just a few meters distance to other airplanes. There's also a good distance to the only other thing you can crash into, the ground, as opposed to driving between walls or with a cliff to one side.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hexane360 8y agoOP said "fly by wire", meaning there's no non electronic systems to fall back on. If the electronics fail there's no "manual override".
- vvillena 8y agoOf course there's a fallback. If the fly-by-wire system fails, there's another whole fly-by-wire system ready to take over. Usually this is safer than the old redundant hydraulics systems where all the lines ran close together, making them vulnerable to localized impact damage and fire.
- hexane360 8y agoI specifically said "non-electronic" fallback.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bdavis__ 8y ago737 Looks like cables, air, and hydraulics to me.
- gumby 8y ago737 is a much older aircraft. The A320 and subsequent Airbus jets and Boeing jets since 777 have been electronic.
- labcomputer 8y agoThe Embraer ERJ series does not have fly-by-wire, just to name one. So the assertion that every "Every commercial passenger jet since the A340 has been fly-by-wire" is simply false.
- blattimwind 8y agoDepending on what fails how in a car, you may have less than a second to recover. Apart from being hit with a high-explosive anti-air missile, I can't think of any failure mode in a plane that has such a narrow recovery window.
- jhomedall 8y agoAircraft autopilots and fly-by-wire systems are vastly more simple than self-driving cars.
- Too 8y agoReliably implementing a few control loops and exhaustively testing all possible input/outputs for bugs - difficult but manageable. Reliably implementing image recognition from multiple cameras and AI that should respond to ever changing weather, inconsistent roads, signs, maps and other human drivers erratic behaviour within milliseconds - Not even in the same league. Not saying aircrafts are simple but self driving is just orders of magnitude more complex. Otherwise we would have seen them on the roads already. Aircrafts also have much stricter maintenance schedules, failure investigations and completely different economic, media and moral incentives.