3 ms·
Apropos of nothing, I'd like to throw out a longstanding personal idea for improving dating sites. All of the current dating sites work by matching similar inte
by Alex3917 19y ago
Apropos of nothing, I'd like to throw out a longstanding personal idea for improving dating sites. All of the current dating sites work by matching similar interests. This is really dumb, because most people don't want to date people with the same interests; rather, they want to date people with any compelling set of interests as long as there aren't any red flags. So rather than matching people with similar interests, dating sites should let you add tags to your profile and then let show you everyone in your area except for those with tags you are filtering out.
For example, show me everyone within 10 miles of 14850 except those whose profiles contain: jesus, single mom, smoker, republican, pulp-free orange juice, george bush, herpes, bbw, us weekly, horses, etc.
- hooande 19y agoThat's a good solution. I think you are very right...dating is about filtering more than matching. Just from my experience, the hard part is getting people to accurately fill in all that information. You've definitely got the right approach though.
- Alex3917 19y agoWhile people do lie on normal dating sites, they tend to lie about predictable things: Men are most likely to lie about their height and income, and women are most likely to lie about their weight and age.[1] It's hard to say whether people would lie more or less on a filter-based site, but it seems to be worth a try if only because no one (AFAIK) has ever tried it. As for getting people to fill out the information, I think you could come up with some novel ways of encouraging people to add tags. As for the tags themselves, you could easily datamine hot-or-not to figure out the most popular 1,000 or so. [1] There is an academic study by Catelina Tomas (sp?) about this.
- wumi 19y agoI rather think this idea would be better deployed in an existing social environment. (Facebook, MySpace, Hi5, etc.) I'm not sure how much people would trust a NEW dating site, especially with all the information out there about fake profiles -- how will you gain enough organic traffic not to turn people off with fake profiles? And if you use fake profiles, then it's self-defeating, and although monetization should be easily achievable, won't help people find a potential partner. Why not a dating application that doesn't intrude in people's lives?
- derefr 19y agoPerhaps, instead of specific people meeting specific people, people create a large database of "characters" (profiles of sorts), and then you select a few and rate yourself on how well you match each of them. You then select a few "characters" you like and rate those, and you are matched with people who are rated highly at being like those characters. Tagline: You can meet a person, but you're looking for an ideal. Why not admit it? (Of course, the ideals could become simplified, one-word-ified and adjectivized, and become tags. But the extensible system is more interesting in that it allows you to select a batch of tags at once. A character could still exist in the tag system, as a set of tags with weightings.)
- wumi 19y ago"this is really dumb, because most people don't want to date people with the same interests; rather, they want to date people with any compelling set of interests as long as there aren't any red flags." I´ve found that in my own personal relationships and those of friends, that in many relationships the partners share a core interest or set of interests that unite a partnership. Could be something as simple as having attended the same University, holding the same religious/theological beliefs and practices, or speaking the same non-English language (in the US). To assume that "most people don't want to date people with the same interests" is a very big assumption, but then again, I guess you can always put your money where your mouth is. :) That being said, I do think many dating sites are broken, but in my opinion it has more to do with the structure of the sites, and also the ratio of men seeking women to women seeking men is often unworldly disproportionate. You are defining dating and relationships in your own eyes "show me everyone within 10 miles of 14850 except those whose profiles contain: jesus, single mom, smoker, republican, pulp-free orange juice, george bush, herpes, bbw, us weekly, horses, etc." but that may not work for everyone.
- ericb 19y agoActually, speaking as a former psych major, similarity is one of the greatest predictors of attraction--including similar interests.
- Alex3917 19y agoIsn't it the proportion of commonalities rather than the absolute number of commonalities?