2 ms·
This kind of has a very simple point - advice is useful iff your problem is caused by bad choices, and advising to make better choices can help. If your problem
by PeterisP 8y ago
This kind of has a very simple point - advice is useful iff your problem is caused by bad choices, and advising to make better choices can help. If your problem is caused by external forces that your choices can't change much, then it's better to devote all your energy to doing stuff instead of looking for advice on how to do stuff better, because there's no silver bullet, you can't do significantly better, and you don't need to waste effort on looking for it.
If after non-negotiable expenses you have barely any money to budget, then budgeting advice is useless as your budgeting choices don't matter much. Career advice, on the other hand, may be useful in that case.
If you're unable to work because of a disability or other factors, then career advice is useless as your career choices don't matter much, but financial tips on how to get the medicine you need in the most affordable way may be useful.
- village-idiot 8y agoAlso, budgeting and finding ways to save money take time, energy, and skill. The author of this article literally couldn’t afford one of the more popular budgeting apps, You Need a Budget, from the liquid cash they had on hand. Same goes for saving money by cooking at home. It works, but it takes skill and time. If you’re working 60-80hrs a week then it’s very hard to justify that time expenditure, and triply hard to justify the up front cost of tools and ingredients. $20 for a mediocre kitchen knife is 6-10 McDonald’s meals ($1,$2,$3 menu), putting someone who is already broke deep into the red before seeing any returns.