3 ms·
You're fundamentally going to be limited by the fact that magnetic force is roughly exponential with regard to distance whereas coil springs are roughly linear.
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
You're fundamentally going to be limited by the fact that magnetic force is roughly exponential with regard to distance whereas coil springs are roughly linear. By stacking a bunch of magnets in the article they reduce the travel of any one magnet pair so it's closer to linear. If you look at short enough segment of a graph of an exponential equation it will look linear, this is basically what they're doing.
- stiglitz 8y agoYou mean quadratic, not exponential.
- bzbarsky 8y agoActually, the answer is probably "it's complicated". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Force_between_magnets#Force_between_two_bar_magnets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Force_between_magnets#Force_be... gives an approximation in the x >> R case, but in the pogo stick situation we're not in that case, especially once we get to 5 magnets or so. But even there, if x >> L also holds (which it would in this case, since the magnets shown have R and L of about the same size), the force goes as 1/x^3 or so, because the 1/x^2 terms cancel out if you go through the small-L approximation. Which, again, is not relevant to the problem because our case has small x. For small separations, the exact geometry of the magnets starts to matter. http://www.magnetsales.com/design/faqs_frames/FAQs_2.htm http://www.magnetsales.com/design/faqs_frames/FAQs_2.htm has some experimental results that show the field going up a bit over 3x when distance drops from 1 to 0.5, then ~2x when going to 0.25, then ~1.5x when going to 0.125 and only changingby 1/8 when going to 0.063... all distances in inches from _surface_ for a magnet that's radius 0.5 and length 0.5 in the same units. Note that this means that the distances from the _center_ are approaching 0.5. All that said, the force is almost certainly not exponential, I would guess.