4 ms·
Everybody knew? Talc deposits often occur near asbestos deposits. There's a govt standard for 'cosmetic' talc that addresses asbestos content, that's been aroun
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
Everybody knew? Talc deposits often occur near asbestos deposits. There's a govt standard for 'cosmetic' talc that addresses asbestos content, that's been around since 1973.
- microcolonel 8y agoNot only that, J&J appears to meet or exceed that standard, if the article is anything to go by.
- user5994461 8y agoThey exceed the standard that they lobbied the government to set. How surprising.
- snek 8y agoI doubt the average consumer is aware of the way that talc and asbestos deposit, but moreover, this article is claiming that J&J went above that limit.
- dpau 8y agoYes, everyone knew, especially the ceramics community. Back in 2006 a potter successfully sued Vanderbilt for contracting mesothelioma due to his use of Nytal, a talc widely used in the pottery community [1]. As of last year this brand of talc is no longer available due to the issue of asbestos contamination. It's widely known that many talcs contain asbestos or "asbestos-like" minerals and can be damaging to the lungs. It's a wonder that those old cartoons show mothers liberally applying clouds of baby powder to babies, those fine particulates hang around in the air for a very long time. [1]: https://www.levylaw.com/talc-asbestos-mesothelioma/ https://www.levylaw.com/talc-asbestos-mesothelioma/
- thegabez 8y agoNot the millions of mothers who've put it on their infants.
- schaefer 8y agoYep, here in Nevada, we have naturally occurring asbestos near some of our most popular water recreation areas [1]. I know one gov. employee that is required to wear a full hazmat suit to go to the beach if they're on the clock. On the weekends, they wear a regular swimsuit... "Asbestos" is a scary word to some, just like "radiation" is to others. but unless the discussion includes concentration levels we're not discussing risk, we're discussing fear. [1] http://www.clarkcountynv.gov/airquality/announcements/Pages/InformationonNaturalOccurringAsbestosinSouthernNevada.aspx http://www.clarkcountynv.gov/airquality/announcements/Pages/...
- rmrfrmrf 8y agoIsn't that kind of irrelevant though since asbestos is only a problem when it's airborne? I mean the whole thing with baby powder is that it's practically designed to be aerosolized.
- jasongill 8y agoDid you read the entire article? The FDA was guided by J&J to set the standard at 10x higher than their original proposal, and to reduce testing to an inexpensive test that only detects the least common type of asbestos. Basically, the article contends, the standard that "everybody knew" about is meaningless and was not much more than positive press for J&J.
- JoeAltmaier 8y ago...and is the health issue of talcum powder real? Is that standard wrong? Is it's risk above the environmental noise level of cancer-causing substances? Anything else is not much more than ragging on J&J.
- maxlybbert 8y agoThe solution to regulatory capture isn’t “create more regulations.”