4 ms·
>Too complicated to check and therefore too many holes to circumvent any regulation This isn't really true. We could make a global rule that each country is o
by londons_explore 8y ago
>Too complicated to check and therefore too many holes to circumvent any regulation
This isn't really true. We could make a global rule that each country is only allowed to extract a certain amount of oil, gas, or coal from the ground, and if they want to extract more, they must buy the right to from another country who does not. It's fairly easy to track that - it's quite hard to smuggle millions of tonnes of coal!
That in turn will cause the price of oil, gas, and coal to include the environmental cost. Suddenly, green technologies will be a sensible investment because they are cheaper, rather than because they cause good PR.
How do you implement that? You get as many countries as possible to get on board, have a big negotiating phase to decide the caps each country should stick to, and then everyone sign a deal that they will close their borders to any country who does not participate in the deal. That forces everyone to participate unless they want to be the next North Korea.
- hutzlibu 8y ago"We could make a global rule that each country is only allowed to extract a certain amount of oil, gas, or coal from the ground, and if they want to extract more, they must buy the right to from another country who does not. It's fairly easy to track that - it's quite hard to smuggle millions of tonnes of coal!" So many glitches here. If country A transports to country B which is their neibhour - who can check how much was traded? You want to have the UN to check every border? And then of course you can just use the coal directly and just export the gas from which you can export much due to better carbon tax. "You get as many countries as possible to get on board, have a big negotiating phase to decide the caps each country should stick to" and good luck with that. During sunshine days you get good intentions and when tensions rise like they do now since a while, not even that anymore. In my oppinion a waste alltogether. All those energies (and actual lots of fossil energy used to make those conferences happen) should have gone to really constructive things instead. Organizing cooperation in research. Infrastructure. etc. Technical solutions to a technical problem. You can't heat peoples homes nor power industries with nice speeches or resolutions.
- yostrovs 8y agoYoung folks with great imagination and endless optimism about the human race will not see these as problems that don't work in practice, that cause more strife than they solve. Even some adults...
- hutzlibu 8y agoWell, I suppose I have great imagination and optimism (and youth) too, but that is also why I do not want a political enforced solution. I am optimistic that humankind as its whole, will see the benefits of overcoming the dirty fossil technology on their own. Also for cleaner air, cities, etc.
- mikestew 8y agoI appreciate your optimism, but we’ve done the “without politically-enforced solution” experiment, and it was an abject failure. See: pre-EPA/CARB Los Angeles. Also: Cuyahoga River fire. [0] Or any of those recent collages of what the U. S. looked like before politicians enforced a solution (EPA). Point is, left to our collective selves and people being people, none of what you wish for will come to pass. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuyahoga_River https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuyahoga_River
- arbitrary_name 8y agoYour perspective holds no water whatsoever. Clean air can be enjoyed by someone actively polluting the air for their neighbours. Or water downstream. So don't act like it's as simple as us deciding to act. It requires a consistent solution that will impose costs on some participants and less cost on others. Almost 40 years of proven science and we're sitting on our hands. And don't get me started on the fact that the current approach of ignoring the problem, sabotaging efforts and rolling back legislation is a politically enforced solution itself, of the negative type. More than half Of all us citizens recognise climate change as a threat and want something done. We have leadership that have hijacked that will to stifle progress.
- 8y ago