3 ms·
Nothing will happen till a global carbon trading scheme exists and is enforced... More oil was burnt last week than ever. https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/weekly
by londons_explore 8y ago
Nothing will happen till a global carbon trading scheme exists and is enforced...
More oil was burnt last week than ever.
https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/weekly/article_images/twip181212fig3.png https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/weekly/article_images/twip1812...
- simion314 8y agoIt is very hard to get to what you propose in one giant step, making small steps is better then doing nothing.
- StavrosK 8y agoYes, but not by much.
- akvadrako 8y agoIndeed it makes almost no difference to act alone. Even if somewhere like the USA completely cut all CO2 emissions today, with liberal estimates by 2100 it would reduce the temperature by less than 0.15°C, which is about 1 standard deviation of measurable temp.
- mac01021 8y agoThat's maybe like 5-10 percent of the reduction we need, though. Quite a large fraction.
- hutzlibu 8y agoNothing will happen before renewable energies are a better(cheaper) alternative. Otherwise all the oil will be burned, no matter how many global regulations there are. There is no global governemnt which could enforce a carbon tradung scheme and I doubt is is a good idea in the first place. Too complicated to check and therefore too many holes to circumvent any regulation. And since many states(and people) are really struggeling and in conflict, the danger of global warming is too abstract for most, to provide enough motivation to serious limit their economy which would weaken them, when they do not trust their neibhours to follow it. Also ... is it just? The west and especially the US used soo much more oil to get to where we are now and now all the others who want to get in the same place are supposed to not fuel/kickstart their economy like we did? I doubt it. So I would focus energy directly to invest in all the alternatives. The sun still provides much much more energy than we need, we just have to use (and store) it adequately. So lots of work to be done there, but we are getting to it. But I doubt the efficency of conferences. There have been so many and the outcome so little than talk talk talk and some papers.
- londons_explore 8y ago>Too complicated to check and therefore too many holes to circumvent any regulation This isn't really true. We could make a global rule that each country is only allowed to extract a certain amount of oil, gas, or coal from the ground, and if they want to extract more, they must buy the right to from another country who does not. It's fairly easy to track that - it's quite hard to smuggle millions of tonnes of coal! That in turn will cause the price of oil, gas, and coal to include the environmental cost. Suddenly, green technologies will be a sensible investment because they are cheaper, rather than because they cause good PR. How do you implement that? You get as many countries as possible to get on board, have a big negotiating phase to decide the caps each country should stick to, and then everyone sign a deal that they will close their borders to any country who does not participate in the deal. That forces everyone to participate unless they want to be the next North Korea.
- hutzlibu 8y ago"We could make a global rule that each country is only allowed to extract a certain amount of oil, gas, or coal from the ground, and if they want to extract more, they must buy the right to from another country who does not. It's fairly easy to track that - it's quite hard to smuggle millions of tonnes of coal!" So many glitches here. If country A transports to country B which is their neibhour - who can check how much was traded? You want to have the UN to check every border? And then of course you can just use the coal directly and just export the gas from which you can export much due to better carbon tax. "You get as many countries as possible to get on board, have a big negotiating phase to decide the caps each country should stick to" and good luck with that. During sunshine days you get good intentions and when tensions rise like they do now since a while, not even that anymore. In my oppinion a waste alltogether. All those energies (and actual lots of fossil energy used to make those conferences happen) should have gone to really constructive things instead. Organizing cooperation in research. Infrastructure. etc. Technical solutions to a technical problem. You can't heat peoples homes nor power industries with nice speeches or resolutions.
- yostrovs 8y ago
- mac01021 8y agoI don't think an explicit trading scheme is required. Each country needs to put a price on carbon, taxing fossil fuels at the point where they enter the national economy (mine, refinery, port, whatever). They also need to put a price on imports that embody carbon emissions (especially steel, cement,...). But if the origin country has already imposed a fee on the emissions, the fee imposed on import can be waived. If a few large countries adopt such a policy, the rest of the world will be incentivised to follow suit, and we'll get a global price on carbon emissions. There's such a bill in the US Congress right now, though one whose chances are abyssmal under the current administration. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Innovation_and_Carbon_Dividend_Act_of_2018 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Innovation_and_Carbon... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fee_and_dividend https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fee_and_dividend
- londons_explore 8y agoI don't think such a scheme is workable because what would the import tax be on a macbook? (it's made from millions of components and hundreds of materials, and the exact quantities aren't known) How about the tax on a google search? (all the energy into that remote datacenter) Also consider where the fee goes... Lets say you're Saudi Arabia. You decide this plan is great, so you stick a massive $50 per barrel fee on oil out of your wells. You then realise that your oil isn't selling great in the world market, so you end up giving the oil industry support in the form of investment to dig new cheaper wells, since to do so is good business for both you and them. As long as you only give them $49 of support, you're still coming out ahead overall. Unless the 'tax' is given to a benevolent world leader, then whoever collects this carbon tax will have an incentive to increase carbon emissions to collect more tax.
- arbitrary_name 8y agoYour second example makes no sense. Saudi subsidising their industry to establish new oil and gas wells is not going to happen for the following reasons: there is no lower cost extraction, otherwise it would have already been tapped. Look at the pain us shale extraction is causing saudi and opec. Supply in this context (50 per barrel tax) cannot be provided without increasing prices, which will reduce consumption on a net basis. There is no two ways around it. I drive less when gas is 3.90 a gallon. So will everyone else.
- chewz 8y agoWhy such a pessimism? A lot will happen. Governments will use this policy agreement as an excuse to tax poor to death and pass the money to corporations to modernize.
- shaki-dora 8y agoA lot has already happened. Just look at the economics of solar power, which are now competitive with even coal. That’s no accident, and not the inexorable progress of science. It’s the direct result of first Germany, then the EU and Obama admin incentivizing research & deployment.