3 ms·
True although paradoxically there is one aspect that is reversed - genital surgery is harder and less functional to construct a functioning penis from a vagina
by Nasrudith 8y ago
True although paradoxically there is one aspect that is reversed - genital surgery is harder and less functional to construct a functioning penis from a vagina than to create a more or less functional vagina from a penis. Put crudely but succinctly as 'it is easier to make a hole than build a pole'.
Reminds me of the one bit of weirdness with birds - they have the opposite convention of sex assignment being based upon ZW where males are ZZ and females are ZW. Females also have two ovaries but only one of them is active and the inactive one produces testosterone - meaning that if the primary one lost functionality they would start spontaneously masculinizing.
- JamesBarney 8y agoThis is one of the reasons you see a higher standard deviation for traits in female birds than male birds. The opposite of humans.
- nicoburns 8y agoAm I correct in interpreting your comment as saying that human women generally have less variance in (gendered?) traits than human men. That's an interesting observation if it is what you meant.
- Nasrudith 8y agoWell part of it is also that any X-linked traits are more likely to tend dominant with the back-up copy. Look at colorblindness for one. Women would need a 'bad' gene on both Xs. A man would lack a backup copy on the Y and thus only needs one for it to express.
- JamesBarney 8y agoYeah you see it in a couple of traits like height, etc.. Basically it's if you have a gene on the x chromosome that increases height by an inch in a man, it will only increase a woman's height by half an inch. And vice versa with removing an inch.
- collectibles 8y agoOkay, one last comment before I wear out my welcome: this is actually super fascinating. The reason for this difference has to do with genital homology[1]. Basically, apart from the vagina itself, almost every part of male and female genitalia is made of the same essential “stuff”, just smooshed around to suit different roles. Crucially, all the most important nerve endings are there— so if you rearrange stuff to be in more or less the right place, you get something that works more or less the way you’d expect. The only issue is, if you got the deluxe variety pack at birth, you probably have a bunch of extra “vulva skin” that you don’t really need, and it’s hanging out in just the right place to make a neovagina out of. Neat! But if you’re stuck with the original flavor, you’ve probably only got a tiny little bit of “penis muscle” to make do with, so you have to get much more creative. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homology_(biology) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homology_(biology)