5 ms·
A very reasonable question, and there is still some controversy over that in the medical community. For me, it's because it comes with a whole host of classica
by nicoburns 8y ago
A very reasonable question, and there is still some controversy over that in the medical community.
For me, it's because it comes with a whole host of classically autistic symptoms like struggling with eye contact, overload from sensory processing, difficulty understanding social norms, etc, but only at times when I'm stressed or otherwise in a low energy mood. I also had to put a lot of effort into learning other people's social norms - my intuitive ones were different in ways which seem similar to other people on the autism spectrum - but unlike some forms of autism, I have been able to learn the rules of neurotypical people to the point that you probably wouldn't be able to tell I was autistic if you met me. I still find a lot of these rules utterly bizarre.
- wpietri 8y agoWhen I read their official description of it, it strikes me as a pretty reasonable response for a not-as-social person forced by social context to engage with much-more-social people on an ongoing basis. Of course they'd be anxious and avoidant. Of course they'd become skilled at getting out of things that are unpleasant and unrewarding for them. I should read more, but at first blush I'd see this not as a disease, but a coping strategy.
- nicoburns 8y agoThe trigger for the avoidant behaviour in PDA people isn't socialising, many of them including me very much enjoy socialising (although there may be stressed around social expectations). It's anything that's perceived as a demand (i.e. something that must be done, or is expected). For many people with PDA (esp. children) this can be things as simple as putting their shoes on or brushing their teeth. It may also include activities that they otherwise enjoy. (Side note: if you're from the US, then you may see much more forced socialisation. In europe, quiet people are allowed to be quiet to a much greater degree. It's not seen as rude to be quiet here)
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoWow, we don't quite know what autism is (don't know if it is a spectrum or a set of separate conditions) therefore it becomes possible to assign the label to almost every condition. I think that's amazing.
- Nomentatus 8y agoAnd I was unaware that children with foot infections, say, stubbornly refuse to brush their teeth as a result as you seem to suggest. (Sarcasm for Sarcasm.) Many children would rather avoid brushing their teeth. Few children are radically opposed to tooth-brushing, say to the point where they'll skip a meal to avoid it. I don't think you understand how unusual the behavior being discussed, is.
- wpietri 8y agoI'm totally open to this being a diagnosis. But I think the point is more that a kid with a foot infection who refuses demands would probably be called "independent". Stubborn, even. But it wouldn't necessarily be medicalized. There was a recent study on ADHD and birthdates; the upshot was that kids on the younger end of the age spectrum are medicated for ADHD more if they're young for their grade. Which implies that some number of kids are medicated more for "teacher inconvenience syndrome" than any real disease. There's a long history of medicine treating different as bad. (The formal academic term is "medicalization of deviance".) So I think it's worth being a bit skeptical that traits that teachers and parents might inconvenient are diseases on the order of foot infections. Rather than, say, how homosexuality was medicalized for decades.
- pseudoanonymity 8y ago> I still find a lot of these rules utterly bizarre. Like what?
- ericabiz 8y agoNot the person you replied to, but his description resonates with me too, so I can help explain. One of the ones that bothers me constantly is the "buffer" of small talk that (particularly American) culture forces on us. For instance: We work together. You have a pencil sharpener. I need to sharpen my pencil. My preferred way of handling this situation: Hey Mike, can I borrow your pencil sharpener for a minute? Now, this is OK in American culture, but ONLY IF you've spoken to each other recently. (I had to learn this the hard way.) If you haven't, the conversation has to go like this: Me: Hey Mike. Got a minute? You: Sure. What's up? Me: I was wondering, could I borrow your pencil sharpener really quick? I have this pencil I need to sharpen. (And you should always insert a reason there; see https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/brain-wise/201310/the-power-the-word-because-get-people-do-stuff https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/brain-wise/201310/th...) If you don't insert this social "fluff", you come across as rude. Where this social buffer comes naturally to most people, I get frustrated and annoyed by it. I just want to borrow the dang pencil sharpener and get back to work! I have come to understand I don't resemble neurotypicals when it comes to this interaction (and it is likely that many others here on HN are not neurotypical either.) NTs enjoy this fluff, and it helps them feel connected to each other. When I don't play by their rules, I'm viewed as cold and callous. So...I play by their rules, because even though I'm not NT in this way, I still have basic human needs of wanting to feel loved and desired, and I don't want to upset other people.
- zozbot123 8y ago> If you don't insert this social "fluff", you come across as rude. Isn't this a bit overstated? I'm pretty sure that you could also use bog-standard politeness markers (like, "could you please", "I would really appreciate it", "sorry about asking") and so on and so forth. (You might then come across as being a bit formal and old-fashioned, but certainly not rude!) The underlying motivation in both cases is that you need to make it very clear that you're not issuing an outright demand - and you do this by making it easy for Mike to say no (for any reason or no reason!) and providing plausible deniability. There are things that are closer to "fluff" in other contexts, but even they have their own explanation.