5 ms·
If you like this, then you may be interested in Pathological Demand Avoidance, an autism profile characterised by better social skills relative to other people
by nicoburns 8y ago
If you like this, then you may be interested in Pathological Demand Avoidance, an autism profile characterised by better social skills relative to other people with autism but a lot of anxiety around the everyday demands of life.
It's increasingly being recognised in the UK, but is only just beginning to spread abroad. (I haven't yet been diagnosed, but I believe that this describes me exceptionally well.)
Article: https://www.autism.org.uk/about/what-is/pda.aspx https://www.autism.org.uk/about/what-is/pda.aspx
Book: http://amzn.eu/d/fPCq5LU http://amzn.eu/d/fPCq5LU
- zozbot123 8y agoGenuine question and not a dismissal - what makes this a form of autism, of all things? Plenty of people who are generally considered NT are indeed anxious, sometimes to an extreme and pathological extent. And it's only natural for anxiety to center on demands of some sort that may have been placed on the individual.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoI have two daughters on the spectrum and this profile of Pathological Demand Avoidance describes their challenges very accurately. There are many factors that go into an autism diagnosis, but to your specific question of how this autism profile differs from an NT with anxiety challenges - I think it's the degree to which the extreme avoidance occurs and the downstream effects. For instance, a request to brush teeth can result in a 3 hour violent meltdown. Attempting to get a 60-pound child from the car into school can result in an injury and visit to the ER for a para-trained, full grown adult. And it's not just once in a while, it is every single demand asked of the child every single day.
- nicoburns 8y agoA very reasonable question, and there is still some controversy over that in the medical community. For me, it's because it comes with a whole host of classically autistic symptoms like struggling with eye contact, overload from sensory processing, difficulty understanding social norms, etc, but only at times when I'm stressed or otherwise in a low energy mood. I also had to put a lot of effort into learning other people's social norms - my intuitive ones were different in ways which seem similar to other people on the autism spectrum - but unlike some forms of autism, I have been able to learn the rules of neurotypical people to the point that you probably wouldn't be able to tell I was autistic if you met me. I still find a lot of these rules utterly bizarre.
- wpietri 8y agoWhen I read their official description of it, it strikes me as a pretty reasonable response for a not-as-social person forced by social context to engage with much-more-social people on an ongoing basis. Of course they'd be anxious and avoidant. Of course they'd become skilled at getting out of things that are unpleasant and unrewarding for them. I should read more, but at first blush I'd see this not as a disease, but a coping strategy.
- nicoburns 8y agoThe trigger for the avoidant behaviour in PDA people isn't socialising, many of them including me very much enjoy socialising (although there may be stressed around social expectations). It's anything that's perceived as a demand (i.e. something that must be done, or is expected). For many people with PDA (esp. children) this can be things as simple as putting their shoes on or brushing their teeth. It may also include activities that they otherwise enjoy. (Side note: if you're from the US, then you may see much more forced socialisation. In europe, quiet people are allowed to be quiet to a much greater degree. It's not seen as rude to be quiet here)
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoWow, we don't quite know what autism is (don't know if it is a spectrum or a set of separate conditions) therefore it becomes possible to assign the label to almost every condition. I think that's amazing.
- Nomentatus 8y agoAnd I was unaware that children with foot infections, say, stubbornly refuse to brush their teeth as a result as you seem to suggest. (Sarcasm for Sarcasm.) Many children would rather avoid brushing their teeth. Few children are radically opposed to tooth-brushing, say to the point where they'll skip a meal to avoid it. I don't think you understand how unusual the behavior being discussed, is.
- mr_overalls 8y agoFrom the article: "Demand avoidance can be seen in the development of children, including those on the autism spectrum. It’s the extent and extreme nature of this avoidance, together with displays of socially shocking behaviour that leads to it being described as 'pathological'."
- chongli 8y agowhat makes this a form of autism, of all things? Autism isn't a fact about the world, it's a category we use to group traits we think belong together. What's actually going on may be varied and rather complex. We do this with a lot of words over time. The word atom, for example, means indivisible. For a long time we believed atoms were the fundamental units of matter. To say to a pre-nuclear physicist that we can now "split the atom" is to speak nonsense; to utter a contradiction. The same goes for universe. Centuries ago, people thought the earth was the centre of the universe and that the stars and other heavenly bodies were fixed upon spheres. Then came the sun-centred model of the solar system, and the universe grew a little bit larger. More recently, the Hubble ultra-deep field dramatically expanded our view of the universe yet again. But now there are physicists who speak very seriously about about the idea of a multiverse. What the heck does that even mean? It means we decided, after a certain point, to stop changing the meaning of the word universe.
- QuantumGood 8y agoI was classically autistic, but identified eventually that if I was supposed to do something (use green fingerpaint) it created a strong anxiety response, but if I was simply allowed to do something (fingerpaint however I wanted to) there was no anxiety. I learned to put dishes away by just putting one away, or moving a group from one spot to another, then making another move, but never saying "I'll put them all away" as that created anxiety.
- bitwize 8y agoI think some societies have a case of Pathological Demand Imposition. Reading this, I'm reminded of a passage from Dostoyevsky in which he said that men would do anything at all -- even self-destructive things -- to prove that they weren't piano-keys; even just to spite you for assuming that they were.