5 ms·
I'll give a crack at some cliffnotes: A debt is a very natural thing for humans, because we feel compelled to provide value to people who can't pay us yet. Ev
by jazzyjackson 8y ago
I'll give a crack at some cliffnotes:
A debt is a very natural thing for humans, because we feel compelled to provide value to people who can't pay us yet.
Even before money people had gifts and favors - we give with the expectation that we'll be given something in the future - or we say 'you owe me one' when someone has helped us through an issue without sending us an invoice.
So the genius of fiat currency is that you get to represent these IOUs as a standard, fungible currency, such that I can take the debt you owe me and transfer it to someone else, so now you owe them. Being able to trade debt like this essentially turns debt into the currency.
The benefit of this being that economic growth is not limited to how many gold coins we can mint -- we can become as indebted to each other as we like -- the more people go into debt, the more money we have to trade. Pretty neat.
- ssalka 8y agoThe problem is that if everyone were to try to collect all the debts owed to them, there would not be enough currency to fulfill it all. We freely create debt, but the result is a deficit that can only be resolved by creating enough value to offset the debt. And if that is somehow infeasible, economic collapse occurs.
- RobLach 8y agoOr society works because people do things for others without expecting repayment and there’s enough social pressure for the vast majority to not exploit that system. Problems really only arise if debt is systemically expected, like a housing market that works only on a foundation of mortgages.
- ScrimptonDeluxe 8y agothere’s enough social pressure for the vast majority to not exploit that system What fucking world are you living in, pal?
- talltimtom 8y agoCurrency is debt. If you have a 20$ bill that means essentially that the government owes you the equivalent in value. If everyone converted all their debt to currency that just means the state buys all the debt and prints sufficient government IOU’s (bills) along the way. If there is not enough value to cover the debt, the notes just lose value as others refuse to trade them at their previous rate.
- posix_me_less 8y ago> If you have a 20$ bill that means essentially that the government owes you the equivalent in value. This may be true in some theoretical sense, but in practice, it is hard to believe. How would I go around to make the government accept my 20$ and give me some equivalent of that? What could government possibly give me for my 20$? Dollar bills are for buying things. I could go to a store and buy a bottle of expensive wine for that bill. But I wouldn't say the store owes me.
- jganetsk 8y ago"I could go to a store and buy a bottle of expensive wine for that bill. But I wouldn't say the store owes me." That's a misunderstanding. A $20 bill is the government's liability, not the store's liability. You and a third party are using government liabilities as a currency. Every $20 bill is on the liability side of the central bank's balance sheet. Every entity accepts its own liabilities as a form of payment. Governments issue currency which they then must accept as payment for taxes. Banks issue credit which they then must accept as payment for debt service. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TDL4c8fMODk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TDL4c8fMODk
- posix_me_less 8y agoInteresting video, but can't help to notice it paints too simple and dandy picture and probably has an agenda behind it. If you read the comments, not everybody believes in this "the government created the money so there is no problem in creating some more" idea. In principle yes, the government has that power. But in practice, this is being prevented by powerful people in and out of government and only gets a pass in special cases (like saving the big banks yes, funding public healthcare no).
- kijin 8y agoA owes $100 to B. B owes $80 to C. C owes $80 to D. D owes $90 to E. Total debt is $350. A pays $100 to B. B keeps $20 and pays $80 to C. C pays $80 to D. D adds $10 of his own money to pay $90 to E. Everyone's debt has been repaid, but only $110 of currency is needed for all these transactions to take place -- assuming all debts are paid in cash. All you need is sufficient liquidity. I could loan you five quadrillion dollars provided that you also loan me five quadrillion dollars. No currency has changed hands, but we've just increased the world's total outstanding debt by ten quadrillion dollars!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- posix_me_less 8y agoThis is like summing up temperatures of stars. It makes no sense to do that. When you have a group of subjects that are indebted to another, separate subject, then it makes sense to calculate the total debt.
- barrkel 8y agoCurrency is just a fungible way of trading value. It means you don't need to use barter. A government could easily print enough currency to represent all the debt available, but they'd want to own the corresponding assets and income streams in return.
- Geee 8y agoEach IOU is actually a promise to work. Before money it could have been 'I will work for you 30 years' and if someone believes that, they can trade that promise for a nice house for the person to live in. A promise is basically analogous to a debt. In todays world, the promise is made to a lender (a bank), which then creates a fungible IOU, i.e standard currency for that promise, which can be exchanged for equivalent amount of work. The whole system is a collective promise to work, and that keeps the society running.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoThat's a very cool way to think of it, thanks