4 ms·
The only way the sun could be powered by gravity would be if it were gradually collapsing. If the radius of the Sun is constant, no gravitational energy would
by pfdietz 8y ago
The only way the sun could be powered by gravity would be if it were gradually collapsing. If the radius of the Sun is constant, no gravitational energy would be released. In this situation the pressure in the Sun is not a source of power, any more than the pressure in the tires of your car could be a source of power.
This was actually the theory of how the Sun was powered, a century ago. This caused problems, since the maximum age of the Sun under this scenario is just tens of millions of years, and the Earth was clearly older than that.
We now know the Earth is 4.55 billion years old. The Sun cannot be powered by gravitational collapse, or it would have stopped shining long ago. The pressure and temperature of the core of the Sun set up the conditions in which fusion can occur, but they are not the source of energy that is powering the Sun.
- dogma1138 8y agoAgain do you understand what dynamic equilibrium is? We have awarded a Nobel prize for this, a star is powered by fusion which is maintained by gravitational collapse it collapses to the point where it achieved a hydrostatic equilibrium between the force of gravity and the outward pressure of the fusion reaction that wants to blow it up. If the fusion reaction overcomes gravity it expands until fusion stops, if gravity overcomes fusion it collapses again until another equilibrium is reached by either fusing heavier elements or through degeneracy pressure, if that cannot be stopped then we get a black hole. >The Sun cannot be powered by gravitational collapse, or it would have stopped shining long ago. The Sun isn't powered by gravitational collapse, it's fusion reaction is maintained by it, just like we must maintain a fusion reaction by having the right pressure to allow for proton fusion in the first place and countering the radiation pressure from the fusion reaction which is why we need to constantly supply the reaction with energy to maintain it. The fact that you still do not accept this is simply mind boggling, consider reading up on hydrostatic equilibrium and stellar nucleogenesis. "An interstellar cloud of gas will remain in hydrostatic equilibrium as long as the kinetic energy of the gas pressure is in balance with the potential energy of the internal gravitational force. Mathematically this is expressed using the virial theorem, which states that, to maintain equilibrium, the gravitational potential energy must equal twice the internal thermal energy." Ironically enough this is exactly with what you've tried to counter my initial post, gravity doesn't go away it is what is keeping the reaction going, if you turn off gravity the gas would cool down due to the expansion and all fusion reaction would stop, but as long as gravity is there the reaction will continue until there is no more fuel to fuse.
- pfdietz 8y agoYou wrote this: "So in essence stars aren’t energy possitvie (or if so only slightly relative to the energy of the reaction) they just convert one type of energy into another." which is utter crap, at least in the case of a star like the Sun, as I demonstrated several messages back. They are massively energy positive. The fusion energy output is orders of magnitude higher than the gravitational energy that was liberated as the Sun formed.
- dogma1138 8y agoWhat confines the fusion reaction and prevents the star to blow out due to the outward pressure from the gas pressure and the radiation pressure powered by the fusion reaction? Basically why isn't a star a giant thermonuclear bomb? This is gravity, yes no energy is technically extracted, but you can no more have fusion in stars without the constant pull of gravity which confines the fusion reaction in the same manner as magnetic confinement fields achieve the same effect on earth.