3 ms·
We all know the right answer is 42 ;) Anyways, asking the right question is just a consequence, not a cause. If you are searching for the "right question", you
by GuB-42 8y ago
We all know the right answer is 42 ;)
Anyways, asking the right question is just a consequence, not a cause. If you are searching for the "right question", you won't find it, it is something that comes naturally with knowing about things.
In the penicillin example, he asked himself the right question "why did the mold kill bacteria" only because he knew about how bacteria and mold proliferate, and that he was confident in his experimental results.
To make an analogy, if you roll a dice and get a 7, you will definitely ask yourself the question, inspect the dice, etc... But that's only because you know that dices only go up to 6, that question is a result of you knowledge of dices. Now imagine you know nothing about dices, you wouldn't even ask yourself the question: the last roll was a 6, so why not 7. Worse, you may find yourself questioning the next roll, a 1, because by chance, you never rolled it before, and by the time you finally understand that it is normal, you have forgotten about the 7.
- ZainRiz 8y agoI wouldn't say it comes naturally. It comes from noticing points of confusion in the world and making an effort to ask the big Why? question. And then refining your question to arrive at a different question, which may be a better question. E.g. Why is my father in law so difficult to get along with -> Is my father in law difficult to get along with? Well, he gets along just fine with others... -> Why is it so hard for my father in law to get along with me? What is different about our dynamic? One question leads you to the next, but you have to put some effort into the process. An excellent book on the topic: A More Beautiful Question https://www.amazon.com/More-Beautiful-Question-Inquiry-Breakthrough/dp/1632861054 https://www.amazon.com/More-Beautiful-Question-Inquiry-Break...
- Twisol 8y agoHeya. This is only a minor point, but I thought you might like to know that "dice" is already a plural. The singular is "die". It's just one of those weird words, like "vertex" and "vertices", that don't fit the usual patterns we're familiar with. On-topic, I agree with your broader point. There are times in development when I'm new to a subject that needs automation, and I'm trying to figure out what I should be doing. I can't really ask the "right" questions because that presupposes knowledge about the domain I'm supposed to be working with. It's a tough nut to crack.