13 ms·
Presumably they structure it as an investment fund and not a bank account? I think "what am I missing?" is the whole point really: this thing doesn't fit withi
by ajross 8y ago
Presumably they structure it as an investment fund and not a bank account? I think "what am I missing?" is the whole point really: this thing doesn't fit within existing regulatory structures. It likely wouldn't qualify for FDIC insurance either.
The question then becomes whether this is a good kind of move-fast-and-break-things a la early Uber breaking into an over-regulated market, or if it's defeating an important protection that consumers need.
- mrfredward 8y agoI did some quick research. Discover has a money market account for 1.9% APR that is FDIC insured and has a debit card. Money market accounts have been around a while. Is Robinhood's account different because they are subsidizing it to hit 3% APR?
- stilky 8y agoDifference is the FDIC insurance, mainly. Being member FDIC means that you have to go through a ton of regulatory requirements to be sure that you're financially stable. A bank can offer whatever interest it wants on its account if it manages to stay in compliance. If Robinhood were to become member FDIC and offer 3% I imagine there'd be no qualms about it. SIPC on the other hand is more relaxed because it covers less. It only covers when a member broker becomes insolvent and is unable to return a security to you that you own. There are similar funds that invest in short term treasuries and often that you can write checks against, however they don't offer 3% and they're very transparent that you own these securities and are subject to the (very low) risk that comes with owning them. Robinhood's marketing sounds a lot more like a standard FDIC insured bank account but they're saying it's SIPC insured instead, and the SIPC is confused about what securities they would actually be insuring
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]