6 ms·
Yahoo screwed up so many times. They could've been Google. They could've been Facebook. It's sad because in the 90's, they were the "go to" place. I knew so ma
by icedchai 8y ago
Yahoo screwed up so many times.
They could've been Google.
They could've been Facebook.
It's sad because in the 90's, they were the "go to" place. I knew so many early internet users who had their home pages set to Yahoo.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoThey could of probably have bought out MySpace at its prime even.
- icedchai 8y agoProbably! Yahoo had a lot of social networking features early on, before it was really even called that: games, chat, personals, message boards (for stocks/finance, etc.) Yahoo was so great in the 90's! It was hard finding things on the early Internet. What they were doing with directories and search seems primitive now, but it really ground breaking. I still remember the first time I discovered it. Probably late '94 (before it was called Yahoo) or '95...
- bdcravens 8y agoIt was called Yahoo in 1994, though they were still part of the stanford.edu domain at that time.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoWow, having used Yahoo since the early 2000's I didn't even know about that. Their history is quite a fascinating read altogether: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Yahoo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Yahoo!
- glenstein 8y ago>Yahoo had a lot of social networking features early on, before it was really even called that: games, chat, personals, message boards (for stocks/finance, etc.) Exactly. Yahoo had more organic pieces of a true social network than Google ever did. In addition to the ones you listed, there were their news properties, groups, fantasy sports, and later on, properties like Delicious, Flickr and Tumblr. They could have had something really interesting under good management (admittedly a huge caveat). They had the pieces to a more plausible facebook competitor than Google ever did, and even Google's best potential seed of a social network, Google Reader, was mismanaged in a failure of strategic vision. In any case, I'm not among those who think Yahoo was doomed. They had the pieces to become something interesting.
- athrowaway3z 8y agoI can't say i know a lot about Yahoo. ( Too young and European ). But i'm not sure they could have been Google or Facebook. I've always perceived Yahoo as arrogant without a vision. An analog IT company if you will. Most support seems to be nostalgia. But if somehow Yahoo did buy Google or Facebook I doubt Yahoo would have been up to the task to make it as successful as they are now.
- icedchai 8y agoThey literally could have bought both Google and Facebook if they shelled out more money. They tried to acquire both companies. You are right though. They would not have been as successful.
- JulianMorrison 8y agoIf they'd bought either they would have run it into the ground.
- butterfi 8y agoDon't dismiss early Yahoo, they were a colossus. I wonder how much Google and Facebook have benefited by watching Yahoo's fall from grace.
- rpiguy 8y ago
- JulianMorrison 8y agoOn day one they were the kings of the early web, but they were playing catch up from day two, because the original thing they made their names on was intrinsically useless as soon as the web got too big to enumerate - in about 1998. Since then their business has consisted of hanging things off the side of things hung off the side of things... and trying to sell advertising. Every good tool they made was a loss leader, orphaned from conception by the economic fact that doing it better would bring in no more revenue. They were never capable of being Google.
- wolco 8y agoThey were but run by marketers in the early days and poorly run near the end. They had so many chances but poor leadership.
- goobynight 8y agoWell, that's just looking at what happened and not the capabilities. They could have paid talent and they had a ton of traffic. You can basically build whatever from there.
- JulianMorrison 8y agoNah, missing the point. They had plenty of talent to build things. They didn't want to. Building things was a loss and a waste. If they were good enough to hold a large mass of people inside the eyeball-farm - then they were good enough. They never had Google's attitude that "what helps the web helps us".
- vanadium 8y agoTheir search index was great back in the 90s simply because it was so localized to a specific interest, location, theme, etc. Wayfinding was a hell of a lot nicer back then, but didn't scale in the face of Google. I do miss the intimacy of search on Yahoo from back then. And it was easy to control _how_ and _where_ you wanted your site to appear in the index. It's naive to think something similar would survive endless spam nowadays, but damn, I liked and really miss it.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Their search index was great back in the 90s simply because it was so localized to a specific interest, location, theme, etc. Wayfinding was a hell of a lot nicer back then, but didn't scale in the face of Google. To be fair, it didn't even scale in the face of DMOZ (née GnuHoo), which was similarly structured and human curated, but Wikipedia to Yahoo’s Britannica.
- redog 8y agoThey could still corner the Fantasy Sports Market.
- adjkant 8y agoESPN had way better last I checked
- glenstein 8y agoAgreed. And building on your point, I think even in the "late" era of Yahoo they had a chance of correcting course through their partnership with Mozilla. Mozilla has a real vision, and Yahoo could have moved the vast internet properties under its control into conformity with Mozilla's vision in various ways, and given real legs to things like Persona, or the various other beautiful Mozilla Labs projects. To me that's an ultimate what-if, and a missed opportunity for both companies.
- bagacrap 8y agoIt would be hard to "be Google" just through business decisions. The pagerank secret sauce is what vaulted Google ahead of Yahoo back in the day. Yahoo never had better tech than the competition so far as I know.
- stergios 8y agoEven after Yahoo missed the chance to buy Google, they missed other significant chances to control Google. Yahoo bought Overture (previously goto.net) which had the patents on internet advertising. I recall Google paying $300M to Yahoo for a license to the patents. I think this may have been under the helm of Terry Semel. My thinking back then was that Yahoo severely underpriced that patent.
- 77pt77 8y agoThey had calendars, email, chat, search, video. You could even read your email over the phone way before smartphones were a thing. All that lead gone to waste...
- QML 8y agoSo did Yahoo have a bigger impact on the 90s than Google on the modern generation of the internet? It sounds like Yahoo created a lot of the products we use today but Google incrementally improved them.
- 77pt77 8y agoNo. Google's impact is colossally larger. But in the 90s they had no real competition and some of their products were actually pretty good and convenient given the limitations of the time. Everyday I woke up with a phone call from yahoo at my chosen time telling me how many unread emails I had, the weather for that day and what events my calendar had. All went to waste...
- mywittyname 8y agoGoogle invented search as we know it. Before that, search results were basically paid advertisement followed by some links to tangentially-related pages. Searching wasn't really an expected use-case, IIRC, Yahoo was modeled more closely to a digital Yellow Pages than a search engine. That's apparently one of the reasons Amazon picked a name starting with an A. Yahoo turned down the option to buy early Google. They didn't see the value in search because it would take users away from their site. They wanted users to stay on their site and participate in discussions and such.
- dredmorbius 8y agoTough call. Yahoo was "the Internet's homepage" (before Reddit co-opted that), and was, when keyword-based search was kind of sucky and already getting gamed (HTML "keyword" headers, if anyone remembers those, Lycos, HotBot, Alta Vista, Ask Jeeves, ...) a pretty good way to find things. The Yahoo directory itself (Yang's Hierarchical Officious Oracle or Yet Another Hierarchical Officious Oracle) was carried forward for a while as DMOZ (since killed), and has certain similarities to Wikipedia, though that focuses on knowledge and not necessarily webpages. To that extent, I find Wikipedia more useful today, because it tells me what I'm looking to find out, rather than directing me to some page, which may, or quite probably, may not, have what I'm looking for. And in either case, almost certainly assaults my senses. Yahoo also served as an information hub. Before there was Google News, there was Yahoo News, Yahoo Weather, Yahoo Finance, Yahoo Maps (I think). One of the first online web-based email services (and still a large, though declining, share of the market, along with Aol and Hotmail, along with a few other relics). The consumerisation of Yahoo was already turning me off by the late 1990s, and I remember running across the first print magazine pushing that side of the company in San Francisco in the late 1990s / early 2000s, and deciding that the company had jumped the shark so far as I was concerned. I've always lead the crowd.... (I'm not bragging. I'm saying that if I predict something, give it another 20 years. Though I occasionally get closer the mark.) At the time, there wasn't anything on the Open Web that was close. There were entirely closed portals, most especially AOL, and other early online services (Prodigy, CompuServ, etc.). But the idea of one place you could go for all of that, no. Yahoo started the Portal Wars. (Best rejoinder ever: "My ass is a portal". One version of that (from 1999, and, of course, /.), here: https://linux.slashdot.org/story/99/03/04/1128220/redhats-new-web-site https://linux.slashdot.org/story/99/03/04/1128220/redhats-ne... So, at the time, Yahoo was huge. And the Internet was tremendously smaller than today -- about 100x fewer people online then than now -- call it 30 million rather than 3 billion users. Today, a social site with "only" 30 million MUA is considered a failure or minor player.
- utopcell 8y agoYou are holding Yahoo against its potential, because in absolute terms, Yahoo still commands about 10% of the US search market. That is nothing to sneeze at.