6 ms·
all Linus and the kernel team can do is make the kernel itself In some sense that's a self-imposed limitation. Linus could have chosen to create an OS (like BS
by wmf 8y ago
all Linus and the kernel team can do is make the kernel itself
In some sense that's a self-imposed limitation. Linus could have chosen to create an OS (like BSD) instead of a kernel.
- chomp 8y agoYeah, Linus is in a power position and could lean on teams to create his vision of Linux on the desktop. But he's a very tech oriented guy and that's ok. He has a tech vision of what the core of the OS should do, and I think the community needs that as much as a person who guides the frontend vision (which is absent for now).
- stickfigure 8y agoAlso... this is the guy who invented git. I'm not really sure we want him working on a desktop UX.
- ivalm 8y agoI mean... I like git... Linux kernel and git are perhaps the two most constant aspects of my job. What is the problem?
- RussianCow 8y agoThe point is that inventing Git and designing a good UX require completely different skill sets.
- chipperyman573 8y agoGit is easily (edit: one of) the best version-control software available, hands down. But, you can't deny that it's very difficult to use. There's an incredibly steep learning curve and the software is very unforgiving. This can be argued to be a good thing (git just gives you the tools to shoot your own foot), but for an average user, a DE needs to be easier to use than git. I guess what I'm trying to say is, git is great for experienced users, but most users don't want to have to be experienced just to use a computer.
- doubleunplussed 8y agoI wouldn't say easily. Mercurial has a credible claim to that title as well, if you ignore network effects that favour using git.
- chipperyman573 8y agoThat's fair. I updated my post to reflect that.
- jnurmine 8y agoGit has a learning curve, yes. Everything has a learning curve. It helps to actually read the documentation, to go through a few tutorials and to generally play around with Git. Is it intuitive without prior experience? No. Nothing nontrivial is. As an example: I have not grokked Blender though I have tried a few times. But I have tried it fully intuitively, just exploring the UI without really reading documentation at all (when I have time I will study it more). Does the UX make sense? No, not to me. Does it mean Blender has a bad UX? No, I don't think so! It has a learning curve like everything else, and learning it is something I have to do if I want to be able to use it. I cannot expect someone else to learn it for me.
- chipperyman573 8y ago>It helps to actually read the documentation, to go through a few tutorials and to generally play around with Git. Yeah, that's the problem. People don't want to do that. Keep in mind, you're not talking about people you find on HN. You're talking about Grandma Sally and Aunt Susan. These are people who can barely use Gmail. They don't want to crack open the documentation
- jnurmine 8y agoWhy would they use Git at all, then?
- deleted 8y ago
- groestl 8y agoI like git as well but UX wise... just look at the number of different syntaxes to delete something.
- perfmode 8y agoGit doesn’t scale. FB and Google have had to stray from the beaten path. Git, with its limitations, imposes non-trivial workflow constraints on millions of developers worldwide. It’s far from ideal. It’s an application ripe for disruption.
- tpush 8y ago> Linus could have chosen to create an OS (like BSD) instead of a kernel. The BSD people also don't make a GUI.
- JdeBP 8y agoOn the contrary, they have. Lumina, for starters. * https://lumina-desktop.org/ https://lumina-desktop.org/ (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14282349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14282349)
- cyphar 8y agoNot really, GNU existed for a while before Linux and Linus' kernel slotted into the missing hole in GNU (since Hurd _really_ wasn't ready and likely won't ever be). So I would argue that Linus chose to build an operating system, and ended up with focusing on a kernel because the rest of the system already existed. The BSDs (and Solaris) all branched from the original Unix tree, and thus have historically always just been a full OS. GNU was trying to do the same, but from scratch and as free software, but Linux came about just as GNU was getting very popular (people would replace the proprietary Unix utilities with the GNU ones). Also, the BSDs and Solaris all use GNOME or KDE -- which aren't developed solely by those people. I think this is quite reasonable actually, since desktop environments really shouldn't be tied to a single Unix-y OS.