4 ms·
I never had the patience to argue with climate skeptics because I figure once in a lifetime is enough and I wasted my youth arguing with creationists. It would
by philwelch 16y ago
I never had the patience to argue with climate skeptics because I figure once in a lifetime is enough and I wasted my youth arguing with creationists. It would be trivial, given a database of counterarguments to creationist talking points, to write a chatbot to argue with creationists. There are only so many times you can explain to people that the second law of thermodynamics doesn't apply to the earth because the earth isn't a closed system before you realize your part in the argument could be just as productively filled by a chatbot.
Once again, I'm not claiming to know anything about global warming, other than knowing well enough to steer clear of arguing about it. So I can't speak to this specific case. However, from past experience with other controversies I understand the mindset behind this type of thing.
- eitland 16y agoI too have spent a lot of time arguing with people who didn't understand the difference between beeing politically correct and being right. A lot of people will argue about any matter; climate change, religion, Middle East, economics or anything else, even if they now nothing about it and spend more time watching sitcoms than reading up on science or religion or anything.
- lotharbot 16y agoPick any religious, political, or philosophical position. Chances are, most holders of that position make similar statements about it most of the time, and detractors give pretty similar critical responses. It would be trivial to write a chat bot, either pro or con, for a lot of topics. Replacing yourself with a chat bot is just like arguing in person, except that it doesn't try your patience or waste your time, only the other guy's, and it doesn't give you any opportunity to learn or be exposed to novel ideas.
- khafra 16y agoThere's nothing saying it can't flag responses from its interlocuter that don't match a response in its database, to give you the opportunity for learning. I think that feature would make this a complete system suitable for educating newbies, discouraging talking-point idealogues, and letting everyone spend more time in the debate areas of greatest marginal benefit.
- ewjordan 16y agoReplacing yourself with a chat bot is just like arguing in person, except that it doesn't try your patience or waste your time, only the other guy's, and it doesn't give you any opportunity to learn or be exposed to novel ideas. I don't see any problem with this, as long as you're actually right when you do it. It's never a waste of time to truthfully tell someone that they're wrong, as long as you give them the information that's necessary for them to realize why. And in my experience, most of the "novel ideas" that the anti-evolution folks have to offer while discussing evolution are very much worth skipping.
- colomon 16y agoAre you kidding?! I watched an anti-evolution video about a decade ago, and it was so creatively wrong it has been an endless source of mirth for me since. "You see, there was a giant ice shield around the Earth in the early days, and that messed up carbon dating. Then God melted it to create the flood!"
- anthonyb 16y agoI can remember explaining evolution one Sunday morning to a pair of Jehovah's Witnesses who were very confused about how it all worked ("No, no, evolution isn't random. How it works is that you have this population of animals who are all slightly different..."). They lasted maybe half an hour or 45 minutes before they fled. I figured it was a public service - every minute they spend with me is one less minute that they're sinking their hooks into weaker prey :) I think I still have their little blue book of "How life began" somewhere. They lent it to me, but never came back to collect it.
- J3L2404 16y agoThis band was practicing one afternoon when Mormons came to the door http://www.myspace.com/captaincreationandthegodrobots http://www.myspace.com/captaincreationandthegodrobots They said they liked the music, but I never told them the name of the band - I kind of wish I had.
- bilban 16y agoI'm sure you could review the dialogue if needs be.