3 ms·
Speaking from experience, as somebody who works in quantum computing. * Theoretical physicists make hypotheses, and find abstract circuits to accomplish a goal
by klyrs 8y ago
Speaking from experience, as somebody who works in quantum computing.
* Theoretical physicists make hypotheses, and find abstract circuits to accomplish a goal; experimental physicists work closely to validate those circuits -- a cycle of experimentation, hypothesis testing, and lots of statistics (aka science).
* Circuit designers find concrete implementations of those circuits, and work closely with fab to produce them. Fab employs chemists and physicists to test, characterize, and refine their processes through experimentation, hypothesis testing, and lots of statistics (aka, science).
* When experiment-laden chips come back from fab, the circuit designers and theoretical physicists work with experimental physicists and lab technicians to characterize/validate the implementation through experimentation, hypothesis testing, and lots of statistics (aka, science).
* Individual devices are assembled into processors by an architect, who has a high-level understanding of the circuits, fab processes, and algorithms that use the processors -- coordinating a larger feedback loop with algorithm researchers involving experimentation, hypothesis testing, and lots of statistics (aka, science).
Scienceless design is a myth worthy of quashing. Our process isn't much different than those employed in the classical computing realm. I'd claim that quantum computing isn't even groundbreaking, in this regard: there's probably a billion person-hour trail of scientific studies that took us from the Antikythera device to the 7nm node (cough cough, or 10nm; who's counting?) and the architectures built thereupon.
If you're doing "design" without "science" as a subroutine; you're probably just following a recipe.