3 ms·
> It is really too bad we can't implement a revenue neutral carbon dioxide tax. Start at a low level and gradually ramp it up until we are carbon dioxide neutra
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> It is really too bad we can't implement a revenue neutral carbon dioxide tax. Start at a low level and gradually ramp it up until we are carbon dioxide neutral or a bit negative.
As long as it's revenue neutral it doesn't even need to be ramped up, it can start at 100%. If you're suddenly paying an extra $500/month in carbon tax but at the same time you're getting the same $500/month back in lower taxes or higher EITC etc., nothing immediately changes unless you make different choices -- and then you pay less.
Then the "ramp up" is automatic, not because the amount of the tax increases over time, but because the amount of carbon being burned (and therefore taxed) goes down which makes "revenue neutral" result in a smaller "refund" payment. You buy an electric car and receive $500/month, but as more people buy electric cars, the amount you receive drops to $400/month, then $300 etc.
The amount relative to a traditional vehicle never changes -- by the time you're receiving $300 with an electric car while paying nothing, the person with a gasoline car is also receiving $300 but is still paying $500, so "stop burning oil" is always $500/month ahead of continuing the status quo, whether it's $0 vs. $500 or -$200 vs. $300.