8 ms·
Ask HN: Which mobile platform is your favorite?
It seems the war is picking up momentum between Apple IPhone($100m VC fund), RIM Blackberry($150m VC fund) and Google Android ($10m cash prize pool) to attract mobile developers to their platforms. With that much activity Microsoft and Nokia can not be far behind, so we have a potential 5-side rumble!
Much in this battle is up to enterprising hackers - which platform would you pick and why? Which one is joy to program, which one is the pain in the neck?
It would also be fun to come back to this thread in two years and revisit our sentiments.
- briansmith 18y agoBased on what's happening today, I'd say that (1) Symbian will take control of the phone-first-computer-second market and, (2) Windows Mobile will slowly take over the computer-first-phone-second market, (3) Apple's marketshare will mirror its computer marketshare, (4) Android will get squeezed out of the market unless there is an ad-subsidized phone revolution (unlikely), (5) Either Nokia or Microsoft will buy RIM, and (6) price is going to be a much bigger factor in the long-run at the top of the market, and Nokia, Samsung, and Sony-Ericcson have a big advantage there because of its experience building mass-market feature phones. Look at what is happening today at MWC: Samsung, Sony-Ericcson, and Nokia all announced amazing Symbian-powered devices. HTC and LG both made huge commitments to Windows Mobile, and Windows Mobile got a huge upgrade. Meanwhile, Android was almost absent from the show, and Apple literally didn't even show up. There's only one commercially-available Android phone, being subsidized by only one major operator (AFAICT). I can't find any evidence that it is gaining any momentum; in fact, the evidence seems to show that Symbian has gained a lot of momentum at its expense. Besides that, Symbian just seems technologically superior. Nokia just announced a Symbian-powered phone with a one-MONTH standby time. The G1 cannot even last through a single day. If you've programmed for both, you can see why: everything about Symbian's design revolves around a relentless desire to conserve resources. Android's main contribution might end up being the open-sourcing of Symbian. The iPhone gained a lot of mindshare but soon it will be one out of many similar devices. Feature-for-feature, every single other manufacturer has them beat, hands down. The iPhone's only advantage is in ease-of-use. That's a big advantage now, and the iPhone will continue to thrive as long as its competitors provide sub-par user experiences. But, once the other vendors get their acts together, the iPhone won't have any advantage whatsoever. The same applies to Mac OS X on the desktop as well. Samsung, Nokia, and Sony-Ericsson are close to having application binary compatibility across their smartphones. And, Nokia has started moving Symbian down market into midrange phones. If they can all agree to build compatible phones and if S60 replaces Series 40, Symbian will have an absolutely massive market share. I think Windows Mobile will succeed in the corporate world if they can build enough tools into the platform to make building mobile enterprise applications as easy as they've made enterprise development on the desktop. At some point I think Microsoft's leverage in the corporate IT world will cause a lot of problems for Blackberry.
- briansmith 18y agoSymbian is a pain in the neck to program for, but you can do anything you want on it, and it has (and will have) a huge marketshare. iPhone and Android are a walk in the park but they both have severe limitations (especially the iPhone). The iPhone is the easiest one to deploy to (thanks to the App Store). I don't have any experience with WinMo. So far, Symbian is my favorite.
- vlad 19y agoI like iPhone now through next summer, an iPhone/Android 60/40 split afterward over the following year, by which time (two years from now) RIM should be in trouble, possibly even worse than Microsoft, who knows how to make software, hardware, and SDKs, and might release a great business phone with 3G, WIFI, and a great keyboard by then (that of course uses Exchange ActiveSync instead of the required $60-100/mo per phone Blackberry connection plan that RIM requires.)
- mattmaroon 19y agoI'm still skeptical that anything will make a dent in RIM's core base. They might shut it out in the consumer market, but not business. iPhones are clearly never going to, unless they offer a model with a dedicated keypad and multiple carriers. Android, we'll see about, but I suspect the Blackberry brand name is one of the most valuable around and will withstand a lot.
- vlad 19y agoThanks for your response. If HTC, Palm, Sony, Nokia, or anybody else releases a great Google Android or Microsoft Windows Mobile phone for business use that comes with a great keyboard and is equivalent in functionality to a Blackberry, with easy-to-use developer-focused SDK's that Google and Microsoft have, while Blackberry sticks with their (from what I hear) poor platform and continues to charge a big extra monthly fee for their data plans, I can imagine RIM will be stuck in an unfortunate situation two years from now, as Palm is today. In my opinion of how quickly things can turn around, Palm used to be the darling of the Apple world, having roots in Apple's Newton project, and the PalmOS operating system supported Macs while Windows devices did not. As soon as the iPhone came out, Mac users of Palm Treos were probably the first in line to buy the real thing (an Apple phone). Also, Palm themselves put Windows on their phones even before the announcement of the iPhone (turned out to be a good decision for them, since they weren't doing much with the PalmOS, because they couldn't really modify it after all--they chose to have backwards compatibility in order to state that they have over 60,000 applications.) There's also the issue that RIM, a Canadian company, is the only company that forces every message to go their country before it reaches its destination, which means state and federal government officials, and the military, will have an easy choice to use one of the other platforms, as many departments have done already in the United States. The governments in France and India have also voiced such concerns to ban the Blackberry. Note that I am not referring to stock prices here, but the general status of the platforms at that time.
- DenisM 19y agoI will start myself having programmed both for Google Android and Windows Mobile. In the grand scheme of things, the two platforms are comparable in the amount of joy and pain they cause and it takes roughly the same amount of effort to get things done. Windows Mobile: + C# (popular, easy to learn language) + IDE with debugging - IDE costs money + Decent compatibility, debug once - run anywhere - Compatibility is not perfect - there are two distinct flavors (touchscreen and non-touchscreen) and while its possible to write compatible code it still takes effort + Native Emulators for different form factors - Network connectivity in emulator is a pain to configure + Once you configure it you can simulate network conditions very well -- Windows Forms UI is quite primitive and does not have even basic layout. Huge pain in the neck. I hate it. - The View and Controller of Model-View-Controller are merged into one (class Form), as a result you can't easily separate View from business logic. Thus it is harder to test. + Allocation profiler and unit tests - No regular profiler, no code coverage - Stagnant - very little has changed in recent times + Large install base (10 mil) Android: + Java - popular, easy to learn language + Single UI model for all devices (touchscreen) + Free IDE with debugging (Eclipse) + Working network connectivity in debugger - Not as rich connectivity options - Debugging is half-assed - it hangs all the time (search for "19% bug") and you can't eval random expressions, only local variables. But then again it gets the job done. + The Intent / Activity / View model is nice - View and business logic are separated. It's also quite cool that application consists of late-bound activities - basically you can expand existing application by developing a newer implementation of existing activity. In other words, it's hackable that way. The whole way how Google rethought the idea of "application" is very fresh and I like it - it seems to make sense to me. + Regular Profiler (don't remember about unit tests and allocation profiler) + Rapidly evolving - zero install base
- jamess 19y agoFrom the software engineer's point of view, there can be no question that Symbian is by far the nicest platform to work on. It's got the same two decades of heritage as pretty much every other popular operating system that exists today, but it shows what can be achieved if the people who designed the OS in the 80s were thinking clearly about the future. It's so refreshing to work on an Operating System where character sets aren't anything you have to worry about, that has Unicode designed in to every component from the file server on up. To use processes rather than DLLs as the basic unit of code reuse is just great, and with platsec to have a decent mechanism for policing access to those processes... Well, I could go on and on, but I better not. It also helps to have a quarter of a billion phone installed base, and almost 1 in every 10 phones shipped being a Symbian phone. Not just Smartphones, mind, all types of phone.
- davidw 19y agoAndroid: it's open source. It might not be an initial advantage against something like iPhone, but in the end, I think it's very compelling.
- briansmith 18y agoSymbian is effectively open-source now (if a handset manufacturer wants it, they can get it), and it will be officially open-source soon.
- mcxx 19y agoWhat about OpenMoko? It will soon become available to the masses, it's fully open, cheap, extendable etc.
- jamess 19y agoWhile I've met many of the guys who work at OpenMoko and think they're great engineers, OpenMoko just isn't any sort of serious mobile platform. They can't even claim the kind of industry support SavaJe had before they went tits up. They're also making a touch screen handset/platform which makes them automatically a niche player everywhere except China. If one of the first tier handset manufacturers expressed some interest in the platform, it might be worth considering, but in advance of that extremely unlikely event it's just an amusing novelty.
- axod 19y agoThe web. I just don't see the point in native apps these days when you can do pretty much all of it via webapps.
- DenisM 19y agoThat's an excellent point. One of my favorite bloggers Michael Mace put a very detailed argument to that end: http://mobileopportunity.blogspot.com/2008/02/mobile-applications-rip.html http://mobileopportunity.blogspot.com/2008/02/mobile-applica... [quote] Summary: The business of making native apps for mobile devices is dying, crushed by a fragmented market and restrictive business practices. The problems are so bad that the mobile web, despite its many technical drawbacks, is now a better way to deliver new functionality to mobiles. [/quote] The web, alas, is slow. One interesting idea I have is potential of convergence between two worlds,manifesting itself in Flash mobile and Silverlight mobile. Maybe these are the future then.