3 ms·
Did you read the article I linked to? I specifically gave an example of how one of the world's most prominent buildings -- far larger than a retail store -- was
by wpietri 8y ago
Did you read the article I linked to? I specifically gave an example of how one of the world's most prominent buildings -- far larger than a retail store -- was delivered not via waterfall planning, but flow orientation. And done on time and well under budget, something waterfall plans rarely manage to do in the construction industry?
So your theory that waterfall always works considerably better is demonstrably false.
As an aside, my brother builds houses, and I've spent a great deal more than 30 minutes talking with him about this. I agree houses are not software. But he agrees that waterfall thinking is often much more a problem for him than a solution.
- tomnipotent 8y agoException, not the rule. > So your theory that waterfall always works considerably better is demonstrably false. Uhmm, no? You pointed to a single building and you want to use that one exception to prove a point? Constructed during a time with considerably less federal & local bureaucracy? Seriously?
- wpietri 8y agoYou claimed that waterfall worked considerably better. I am offering you proof that it doesn't. Your one example is a store in a mall that you spent 30 minutes discussing. My example is the Empire State Building, which a process expert spent significant time researching. I'm open to the notion that waterfall processes work well somewhere. But my experience is generally that person in industry A says, "Oh, it really works in industry B." When I talk to somebody in industry B, they say, "Oh, I'm sure it works better in industry C." (Or, often, "industry A".) Your theory seems to be that the fact that waterfall is the now-dominant paradigm means it must be good. That was the theory in software, and still often is, despite theoretical and practical demonstrations otherwise. So it shouldn't be inconceivable that it dominates in other industries even though it doesn't work well there either.