3 ms·
Calling bullshit on this. First, there's the US law and the SEC. Those are two things. The SEC doesn't produce laws; it merely follows and interprets them. Most
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
Calling bullshit on this. First, there's the US law and the SEC. Those are two things. The SEC doesn't produce laws; it merely follows and interprets them. Most laws that it interprets predate most blockchains. There is not much the US government has actually agreed on in terms of financial legislation recently other than to deregulate a lot of things.
It's true that the SEC is very strict on regulating securities (especially given recent history with e.g. mortage companies, enron, and other financial scandals). This has made the crypto ecosystem hard to navigate for people operating outside of the traditional financial system. This has not been helped by them evolving their interpretations and thinking over time. Call it progressive learning. So, it's hard but not impossible, and certainly not illegal.
This is why some of crypto companies with unicorn style valuations are operating in the US with money from US investors. I'm talking about companies like Coinbase and Stellar.
Stellar is a blockchain platform backed by US companies like IBM. The main use case for that platform seems to be stable coins. There are actually several companies offering USD backed stable coins. The point of these coins is not speculative trading as a security but value exchange via p2p transactions between trusted parties on the network. This is also the main use case for Ripple.
So, stable coins are very much legal and practical; and somewhat of an early success story for utility tokens. If you don't believe me, the top trading compant on stellarx.com (today) is a token by a company called stronghold.co: a USD stablecoin. There are five such coins on stellar currently. Stronghold.co are hiring in SFO and presumably operating there under US law and working within the rules set by the SEC.
The reason that Stellar is popular for this stuff is that the people behind it designed it such that it supports the use case well. E.g. it has a lot of built in stuff for dealing with AML that companies like stronghold.co can use to clear transactions or that others can use to clear transactions with them. AML is indeed not optional.
- Retric 8y agoWhen the law says regulations made by X must be followed those regulations have the force of law. Also, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 covers selling stuff. Using a computer to sell stuff does not matter. “It shall be unlawful for any person, directly or indirectly, by the use of any means or instrumentality of interstate commerce, or of the mails or of any facility of any national securities exchange, (a) To employ any device, scheme, or artifice to defraud, (b) To make any untrue statement of a material fact or to omit to state a material fact necessary in order to make the statements made, in the light of the circumstances under which they were made, not misleading, or (c) To engage in any act, practice, or course of business which operates or would operate as a fraud or deceit upon any person, in connection with the purchase or sale of any security."
- jillesvangurp 8y agoYep, mostly these things get decided in a court where the regulations get interpreted by expert witnesses, scrutinized by lawyers, prosecutors, judges, etc. Those interpretations can change over time, can be challenged in supreme courts, are clarified, etc. In this case you are interpreting the text of the law against a changed context (computers now exist) and making a judgement that "using a computer to sell stuff does not matter". There are a lot of not quite experts making similar value judgments about crypto stuff lately. So, this stuff is anything but black and white. Hence there are perfectly legal business operating in the US doing stuff with blockchains, crypto currencies, etc. that are so far not ending up in trouble over what they are doing and seemingly complying with however today's SEC chooses to interpret what they are doing. They might change their mind of course over time. If you are running a business doing this kind of stuff, the SEC is just one of many authorities you have to deal with. We've had some fun navigating the legal jungle that is the EU where each state has its own regulatory bodies, rules, practices, and politicians. The thinking on how to apply their laws is highly fluid. Right now, if you talk to two lawyers about anything crypto, you can get two completely different interpretations. Mostly they have a hard time understanding this stuff period.
- Retric 8y agoI am not sure how else you can interpret ‘by any means’. But, sure that is just the common interpretation of those words and could in theory change. Though, good luck convincing a judge of such.