3 ms·
I think this settles the debate whether Apple will be moving to its own ARM Mac. AMD will need to move and execute its plan to perfection. Hopefully they gain
by ksec 8y ago
I think this settles the debate whether Apple will be moving to its own ARM Mac.
AMD will need to move and execute its plan to perfection. Hopefully they gain enough market share to make a difference and making enough profits for long term survival. Finger crossed.
- npunt 8y agoMy read is Apple is most definitely on for ARM Mac and this is too little, too late (I assume that's your reaction as well). Doesn't seem like much IPC increase and mostly just catch up on both features and process. I'm sure these Intel chips will make their way to Macs whenever they ship (2019 or beyond), but its likely * Cove is the last new Intel arch Apple uses if they can release some A-series Macs by around ~2020. It seems like the only interesting IP Intel may have to Apple is Optane (theoretically), and the only value Intel offers Apple for more than the next 12mos is Xeons slated for Pro machines. When you consider that the trend is integrating everything into SoCs, and their features are more tightly designed according to actual usage up the stack in OS and apps and use cases, and they're shipped on a strict yearly cadence, and their R&D benefits from a massive market of iDevice sales, and their value is inherently better captured via device sales and direct customer relationship... it's kind of nuts that Apple is still with Intel. That's not even accounting for the 10nm delay, nor Intel's weird market segmentation of features, nor Intel's margins, nor Intel's clear organizational issue (per article) of decoupling IP & process that add risk to the roadmap. Even if Intel gets to EUV before TSMC (they won't), it's just not structured right. This can't last much longer.
- ksec 8y agoApple will still need to SoC from 5W ( MacBook ), 7W- 15W (MacBook Air), 25-45W ( MacBook Pro ), 65-95W ( iMac ), 95-200W ( iMac Pro and Mac Pro ) all these combined of only 20M unit per year. I hope I am wrong, not sure if it make any financial sense.
- npunt 8y agoI might simplify that further into three segments with different silicon strategies: Low (~15m units) - MacBooks except 15" MBP Med (~2-4m units) - 15" MBP, iMac, and Mac mini High (<1m units) - iMac Pro and Mac Pro In LOW, silicon-wise its essentially free since they already have a SoC powerful enough w/A13X+. They can always bump up the wattage/frequency and/or decrease the chassis size to define a slightly new market segment where compute expectations are lower (e.g. the Air approach). Between LOW & MED is the mobile workstation use case of the higher spec 15" (or larger) MBP. Cheapest solution: add a discrete GPU. In MED, they could still use A13X+ and add discrete GPU at higher SKUs. Alternately, they could create a beefier chip ("A13XL"?) that would just bolt more cores onto the CPU/GPU. Between MED & HIGH would be the semi-pro use case of the higher spec 27" iMac (or even certain use cases of Mac Mini). Hard to say what cheap solution is here beyond better GPU. In HIGH, it feels like Intel is here to stay for a while. These use cases still really need the beefy Xeons and are dealing with lots of pro-level edge cases which favors staying with x86, ECC, etc, and cost-wise it's very low volume. On these Pro machines where price is less of an object, and to keep up with the rapid feature development roadmap they get from A-series, it feels like they'd do the 'why not both' strategy and throw in an A13X+ as the primary processor and a Xeon as a co-processor with it's own RAM. Just like GPUs are co-processors today. The OS, everyday apps, and specific tasks that favor the A-series would run on the A13X+, while certain instructions and legacy x86 programs/VMs/etc would be routed to the Xeon. --- The more I think about it the more this co-processor approach really makes sense for the next 5 years of Pro-level Macs, since it avoids the cost of creating new low-volume, high complexity silicon. It's fun to speculate because it represents quite an interesting business + technical + market segmentation challenge. They don't want to siphon off or detract Mac users any further than they already have, but also need to start reaping the benefit of their highly competitive and high volume chips.
- ksec 8y ago1. You ignore the Tape Out cost on leading Edge node, with yield unforeseeable due to higher voltage and frequency usage. 2. Adding a Discreet GPU still requires a new set of drivers that is previously not written on ARM Mac. The 5M Mac will require addtional hundred million of investment, time, and testing. The Co-Processor approach also requires additional OS and software support. Testing cost also. The only way I see is Apple employ a similar strategy to AMD, chiplet design, where a small CPU Core Die could be used for lots of different configuration. We will have to see how EYPC 2 perform to judge whether it is a good solution.