3 ms·
Oddly, most truly disastrous projects I have seen, have had no small amount of over engineering. There has been a bit of not understanding the requirements. B
by taeric 8y ago
Oddly, most truly disastrous projects I have seen, have had no small amount of over engineering.
There has been a bit of not understanding the requirements. But more is in not understanding current personal capabilities or needs.
Think of it as training for a marathon. At the end of the day, it is knowable how many calories you will need to burn and how far you are going to run. You are still far more served by running several five and then ten kilometer races, than you are studying the marathon track you want to run. Similar goes for software. Make a few customers happy. Then more. Then more. Don't stall out thinking you need to be at Twitter scale for day one. Not even Twitter did that.
- sgt101 8y agoI've seen this too. My conclusion is that this happens when people who are strong communicators and networkers - influential even if they don't think of themselves that way - either misunderstand the need or value of some component, or they wilfully use the project to do a thing that they personally want to do. This "project as a vehicle for something else" is really catastrophic and is often a way for someone to exit the organisation with a gilded CV. What's important is that it screws everyone else. On the other hand, the obsessed super engineer is not being malicious, they believe wholeheartedly that they are right. The thing is to recognise which is which... one is a cancer that must be cut out fast, the other is a hugely valuable contributor who is misaligned (and in this case much listening is in order as it might be the project is misaligned).
- Retric 8y agoTwitter also failed regularly. The cost of failure varies, but in government work their are non zero risks of your failures making national news. For example the healthcare.gov’s failure the scale. Twitter only scaled well when they started over rather than trying to use Agle to bolt on add hock solutions.