7 ms·
10 years ago, I might have agreed with you. But, with SpaceX and other private companies venturing into space? I feel like humans are doing pretty well.
by alistairSH 8y ago
10 years ago, I might have agreed with you.
But, with SpaceX and other private companies venturing into space? I feel like humans are doing pretty well.
- Shivetya 8y agoFar too often people fail to see the world for what it is. The use of space is expanding so much and that if anything people are tuning out accomplishments because they are not eventful anymore. For some the end of the shuttle program was a downer but it was probably the single best thing to have happened to NASA in decades. the Shuttle program if anything held NASA back. The investment alone made it near impossible to not use it and the cost of using it doomed money for other development. Now we have Space X with a record number of launches, China going to the dark side of the moon, and even more private corporations reaching for space. We still have cooperation with Russia not withstanding all the political strife caused by their leadership. The EU has had great missions recently and even India is moving forward.
- DigitalWheelie 8y agoWhile I'm no fan of wasteful NASA spending, it feels wrong to explore for profit rather than curiosity.
- thelastidiot 8y agoIt was never for curiosity at the beginning but for military goals.
- skookumchuck 8y agoIs it so noble to lose money?
- JetSpiegel 8y agoPutting people on the moon was "lost money"? Only in the strict sense that money flowed into NASA from the Federal budget and did not flow back.
- gbear605 8y agoOf course, a lot of that money did flow back, since it went to people who paid income taxes.
- bdamm 8y agoProfit is the foundation of truly sustainable human activity. Christopher Columbus was in it for the money, too. Government can only spend what profit creates, so even government programs like NASA ultimately are feeding from the trough of profit.
- im_down_w_otp 8y agoI look at it through the lens of what they had available to them in terms of adjacent technology and capability compared to the present day. For example, when I stand in front of an SR-71 Blackbird and consider that it was created w/ slide rules & Friden mechanical calculators. When sophisticated automated design and analysis tools like FEA and CFD were still far, far away. It conjures a narrative for me, true or not, that they seemed to do so much with so little, and by contrast we seem to do so little with so much. Which results in a crude emotional response that is some hybrid of awe & despair. Then a few days goes by, and I snap out of it.
- exoesquitur 8y agoI think the newish perception that risk is unacceptable plays a part. I'm glad to see the "safety above exploration" mindset giving way a bit. Accidents are going to happen. Pioneers in dangerous endeavors understand this. It's good to see society remembering it as well.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoWhose risk? If we're talking risk of astronauts and test pilots, certainly--they know the dangers and they've decided it's worth it. My worry is that people who think "move fast and break things" is a good business strategy are now starting to move into transport, medicine, and other fields where the lives of random citizens are on the line.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Whose risk? Anyone's risk, even if there's no risk at all. Post on Reddit about how you replaced your own water heater and people will wag their finger at you for not having a licensed plumber do it all (as if the plumber would stop by the next day to check for leaks). People get off on trying to score virtue points virtue signaling about risk (not just on the internet, in real life too). The Christmas tree (or do I have to call it a holiday tree because the "risk" of offending someone is too great) across the room from me might spontaneously catch fire. It probably won't happen so I don't care, that won't stop some anonymous stranger on the internet telling me I should use modern LED lights because they run cooler. I understand not playing fast and loose with people's lives but the likelihood and magnitude of a possible bad outcome required to stall things has been getting smaller and smaller over the years and it makes getting anything and everything done more time consuming and costly. Before you could just put up a Christmas tree in the office if everyone wanted to, now you have to figure out if anyone could hypothetically be offended. Before you could just build a road or a bridge and deal with the environmental impact as it happens, now you have to do a study and account for the whereabouts of every drop of rainwater that will fall on whatever you're building before you even break ground. There is a risk of a potential bad outcome inherit to everything. Somehow society has perverted itself into thinking that risk is a binary and all risk is bad and not work it.
- codeulike 8y agoYep. For example, the cost per kg of putting something into space using the Falcon Heavy is about 40 times cheaper (per kg) than using a Space Shuttle was.
- dv_dt 8y agoWe are both more advanced and more behind. The only human capable space system right now is the Soyuz? (first flight 1966) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soyuz_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soyuz_(spacecraft)
- FlyMoreRockets 8y agoActually, the Soyoz is boosted by pretty much the same rocket that launched Sputnik in 1957. It was first developed as an ICBM. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-7_(rocket_family) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-7_(rocket_family)
- gandhium 8y agoNo, China putting their taikonauts to space using chinese rockets.