3 ms·
"A dense California Public Utilities Commission report laying out the case for the texting surcharge says the Public Purpose Program budget has climbed from $67
by michaelmrose 8y ago
"A dense California Public Utilities Commission report laying out the case for the texting surcharge says the Public Purpose Program budget has climbed from $670 million in 2011 to $998 million last year. But the telecommunications industry revenues that fund the program have fallen from $16.5 billion in 2011 to $11.3 billion in 2017, it said."
So you lied and said it was a charge to help poor people have access to phones and collected almost 25x the amount needed and used it as a slush fund. Now the slush fund is less profitable although still 11x the amount needed and you want to refill the slush fund. How about no.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoSomething feels off to tax an industry more when their revenue goes down. Am I missing something here other than the usual California hunger for taxes?
- nrmitchi 8y agoIt appears to be saying that a portion of those 16B in revenues go to fund the program, not that the companies are paying the state $16B/year.
- michaelmrose 8y agoIt seems you are correct.
- uberman 8y agoPoliticians love to earmark tax revenue to specific projects that people will support. I call it the "puppies are great excuse". The reality is that all revenue is part of giant slush bucket. Some expenses are discretionary and some not, but the bucket to pay is what it is. This is just the way politics and false promises work.
- FooHentai 8y agoI seem to recall there's term for when tax revenues are strongly linked to tax expenditure. Like when you tax road vehicles and use that exact tax to maintain the road network. But I can't recall the term right now. Seeing more of that thing, whatever it's called, seems like a desirable thing. The 'pooled funds' approach to tax/spending does lead to a lot of whacky outcomes.
- FooHentai 8y agoI may have been thinking of 'direct tax' here, but it's perhaps conceptually slightly different.