4 ms·
I don't understand how people can be tricked by the branding of the 'sharing economy.' The average seven year old is capable of understanding the difference be
by vkou 8y ago
I don't understand how people can be tricked by the branding of the 'sharing economy.'
The average seven year old is capable of understanding the difference between actual sharing (A friend giving you a lift), and 'sharing' (An unmarked taxi.) They could also probably grasp the difference between CouchSurfing[1], and AirBnB.
[1] Couchsurfing was the actual sharing economy, but as it turns out, you can't make billions of dollars from people letting out their couches to strangers, for the cost of company, and a home-cooked meal.
- Nasrudith 8y agoWell there are some grey areas in sharing - would a neighbor agreeing to drive you to the airport for gas money be sharing still? What about a friend? Probably a deliberate fuzzy borders exploitation. The set rates are the real breaker of sharingin my opinion - a tip and rating system would be truer sharing but would certainly exist on a smaller scale. It would be an interesting sociological experiment but it would probably end in disaster.
- pesmhey 8y agoI've found myself drinking someone's branding kool-aid before, and this is how it happened. You think to yourself what you've just laid out, that this is so obvious a seven year old should know better. So obvious, in fact, that it can't be real. "This is just an unmarked taxi." "No, we're way different." You think to yourself how no one could be that blatant, and you notice other people are buying into it, so you start to question you own worldview. Then it reaches a critical mass, where there's enough self-perpetuation to make you throw skepticism to the wind. And after some time, after seeing a few cracks in the brand, you think to yourself, god damn it, should have stuck to my guns.
- jandrese 8y agoOr: "This is just an unmarked taxi." "Except hailing/billing isn't stuck in the past so you don't have to get lucky to find an empty one on the street or call a surly dispatcher and wait 45 minutes. You also get the bill up front so you know how much it will cost before you even say yes. You can always pay by credit card too, you'll never arrive at the destination and then only be informed that the credit card reader is 'broken' and the cabbie can only accept cash. Added bonus: it's about half the price of a regular taxi." "Cool"
- RHSeeger 8y agoYour experience is almost exactly the opposite of mine. 1. Without fail, taking Uber costs me more than taking a taxi, same trip, same time of day. 2. The bill up front point is fair 3. As far as paying by credit card, know the rules of your city. In many cities, they must take credit cards or are not allowed to drive. As such, if they tell you at the end of the trip that you must pay cash, just tell them you can't. If they won't let you pay by credit then, just walk away. Even if it's not a city where they have to accept credit, just tell them you don't have cash and stick to it. If their credit machine really wasn't working, they should/would have told you at the beginning of the trip. 4. I never have a problem getting a cab (though, to be fair, I only do it in NYC... they're everywhere)
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoI live in NYC and Uber / Lyft are sometimes cheaper and sometimes more expensive. Their premium is correlated with how hard it'll be to catch a cab. So if it's raining, it'll be hard to catch a cab. Uber / Lyft will be more expensive than a cab, but easier to take. UberPool and Lyft's equivalent are basically always cheaper though, and I've found they work very well in Manhattan.
- pesmhey 8y agoIt's definitely better, no arguments here. My point is that Silicon Valley has branded everything it does as 'tech' when in reality, it's just a better taxi company, a better hotel company, etc. unencumbered by the old ways. Like, the reality would have been good enough, 'We're a taxi (or insert whatever industry you want) company doing things way better than before." Instead, it's 'We're using algorithms and this shit is out of this world!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'
- nipponese 8y agoThere is something about traditional engineering culture that sees marketing as big lie, but one of the reasons these companies have been so successful at transitioning public opinion is because they treat the whole business as iterative. Instead of thinking "boring finance dept" and "slimey marketing guys", they think "financial and social engineering".
- smacktoward 8y agoThe point was not to trick average people, it was to trick regulators by creating sufficient ambiguity around whether these companies were different enough from their already-existing counterparts to justify not applying the same regulations to them. And it worked! For as long as it needed to, anyway.
- will_brown 8y agoIt didn’t trick regulators...in my county (Miami-Dade) Uber racked up millions in fines and “settled” for $4M. There are ~3,000 counties in the US...and significant outstanding debts/legal liabilities. The only people tricked is investors who are unaware of the real legal liabilities and whose funds are being used to float the illegal operations and some drivers who now have criminal records from doing a job they were paid to do. Now they are going to trick the public with a public offering and offload these toxic shares.
- elliekelly 8y ago> Now they are going to trick the public with a public offering and offload these toxic shares. You're right, they'll offload them right into a bunch of retirement funds.