10 ms·
How “One-Plus-Five” Is Shaping American Cities
- vinceguidry 8y agoAmerica is a big place with tens of thousands of cities. There just aren't enough architects to make everything unique. Expecting her to be as architecturally diverse as Europe is asking too much. I'm just glad we're moving away from strip malls.
- jtbayly 8y agoUltimately what the author is asking for isn't architectural diversity but longer lasting buildings: "It is hard to imagine that fifty years onward folks would get excited about the one-plus-five buildings or contemplate an adaptive re-use. Too flimsy to last even that long, these buildings will probably have to be demolished once they become obsolete, unable to stand as the testimony of our times." He talks about strong or weak "bones" and contends that this sort of stick-built construction doesn't have good strong "bones."
- pixl97 8y agoEh, with any maintenance those buildings will last at least 50 years. In the US the bigger issue is, in 50 years will it make any sense for the building owner to pay to maintain the building? Putting up a long lasting building in certain places in Detroit 50 years ago may have made sense... but now it could be in a completely worthless ghetto, everybody has moved from the area. Or, as the saying goes "In the US, 100 years is a long time"
- com2kid 8y agoIt is good for the city! Those long lasting buildings are where affordable housing is found, it is where artists studios thrive, where community spaces are built. Cities need buildings that are durable, long lasting, and that have depreciated in value!
- rsync 8y ago"He talks about strong or weak "bones" and contends that this sort of stick-built construction doesn't have good strong "bones."" I used to have this bias and, to some degree still do - at least aesthetically. However, after building two homes I have come to really appreciate the strength and earthquake resiliency of stud walls clad with plywood sheathing. This kind of shear-wall structure is very strong and quite inexpensive. A "good building" made of brick or stone - like you see in Europe and the East Coast (and that I find very aesthetically pleasing) are very, very fragile to earth shaking. I don't think the "bones" are the problem - the problem is the dressing. Double thick insulation in the walls, noise isolated (or simply double-thick) sheetrock and a 1/4 layer of rubber between the subfloor and the flooring surface (and perhaps some other ingredients) are all you need to make a studwall/stickbuilt structure very, very "solid" and noise isolated, etc.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoHe's also asking for architectural diversity, though. He spends a long paragraph complaining that the buildings are "trite," "predictable," "without true historic reference," and all the other stuff that I associate with smug architects who design pretty, unusable public buildings. His other arguments make sense to an extent, but frankly I tend not to trust any architectural commentary from people who judge a building by its cover, and I think the criticisms in these comments bear that out.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago> Expecting her to be as architecturally diverse as Europe is asking too much. The suburbs and shopping streets of London or Dublin contain row upon row of identical buildings.
- kazen44 8y agoas do many european cities, especially outside of the city center. Things like this are not uncommon: [0] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/54/Modzelewskiego_Street._Blocks_of_flats._-_panoramio.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/54/Modzelew... [1] https://www.bijlmer.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/900x450.jpg https://www.bijlmer.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/900x450.j... [2] https://farm1.static.flickr.com/461/18997407772_c525f69da1_b.jpg https://farm1.static.flickr.com/461/18997407772_c525f69da1_b...
- gnode 8y agoI don't think this is the issue. As the article talks about, architecture is shaped by regulation. Of course, you can usually construct exotic buildings if you have the money and the will to do so, but building codes explicitly approving a specific design will create a monoculture. That's not to say this is necessarily bad. It allows for safety and environmental standards in buildings people are able to afford because of minimal marginal compliance cost.
- CalRobert 8y agoI've spent at least 40 seconds looking at this page and still have no idea what "one-plus-five" is referring to.
- klodolph 8y agoSix-story building, bottom floor is retail (one), remaining floors are residential (five).
- Retric 8y agoClose but no. They add a five story wood structure on top of one story of something more solid like concrete. This cost effectively increases space without massively increasing costs over a five story wooden structure.
- klodolph 8y agoI think we both read the same thing, and decided that opposite parts of it were the key point, "The first level capped by the concrete deck is retail, parking, meeting rooms or amenities and the floors above it are apartments, condos, or dormitories erected under the 3A construction type classification of the building model code IBC." I focused on usage, you focused on construction.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Retric 8y agoThe issue is you can have retail in a wooden building. Which seems like the point of this construction over a 5 story wooden building with retail on the ground floor. 3A limits building heights, but by changing the ground door you are allowed to build a taller structure. PS: I agree that Retail is a common use for the ground floor of these buildings. But it’s not the only use for the ground floor.
- klodolph 8y agoAs a related not, at least in NYC the six-story building is very common, and this is apparently because a seven-story building will typically require a water tower to regulate water pressure.
- saalweachter 8y agoIt’s also the cutoff for what most people will tolerate in a walk up, and the sixth floor is already pretty discounted, so if you add more floors you’re probably looking at an elevator to boot.
- dajohnson89 8y agoWow, I couldnt imagine more than 3 stories without an elevator. Just think of groceries, wet shoes, heading outside then realizing you forgot your sunglasses, etc.
- timerol 8y agoThis article seems to be putting on some strong rose-colored glasses. It appeals to the idea that people in the past all lived in beautiful, long-lasting buildings. The reality is that the long-lasting buildings are the only ones that still exist. The bulk of humanity has always lived in cheap construction. Affordable housing is not a bad thing, especially with modern fire codes. The last paragraph starts with "For centuries the quality of their buildings and a certain permanence set cities apart". That's a really good joke. The author even points to this earlier with "The sameness [of 1+5s] isn't like East Berlin's "Plattenbauten" (precast concrete buildings) around Alexanderplatz, nor has it the uniformity of some of Baltimore's rowhouse neighborhoods." I'm legitimately not sure whether those cheaply constructed neighborhoods are supposed to be positive examples or not.
- OedipusRex 8y agoSameness at scale.
- NickM 8y agoThis article seems to be putting on some strong rose-colored glasses. It appeals to the idea that people in the past all lived in beautiful, long-lasting buildings. The reality is that the long-lasting buildings are the only ones that still exist. Well sure, but at least some houses used to be beautiful and long-lasting; nowadays, even large, expensive mansions are typically built in a cheap, slapdash manner, using techniques and materials that are not nearly as long-lasting or durable as the ones that would've been used to build a nice house a century ago. For a really obvious example, just look at roofing materials; a good slate roof can last over a century with minimal maintenance, but nobody builds houses with slate roofs anymore. Instead, even high-end homes use asphalt shingles that last 20-30 years tops.
- peteradio 8y agoSteel roofing is becoming more and more common. Wonder what the expected life expectancy is on those bad boys.
- 8y ago
- jdblair 8y agoAll of the spectacular construction fires in Oakland in the past few years have been this type of construction. The enormous open wood frame structures were like carefully constructed bonfires built of dry wood. Lots of surface area and ventilation to feed the fire once it got started.
- drewmate 8y agoI haven't lived in Oakland too long, so I don't have memory of these fires, but they certainly haven't stopped the momentum of 1+5's in my neighborhood. Just in the last ~2 years I've seen 3-4 (block-sized) buildings like these go up in my immediate vicinity. Honestly, I'd never considered them to be negative; they're quick to build and encourage street-level retail and walkable neighborhoods. That seems like exactly what the Bay Area cities (and many other US cities) need right now. To me, they seem like a strict improvement over large residential-only blocks popular in the last 25 years.
- jdblair 8y agoI don't think they're a negative, either. Build, build, build!
- dmckeon 8y agoIf the wooden stud walls are still exposed during construction, bonfire is a fair comparison, but once the wooden walls are covered by sheetrock, and doors and windows are in place to reduce available air, the scenario is different. In the East Bay case, a arson suspect has been arrested on DNA evidence. https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/East-Bay-housing-development-fire-marks-fifth-13329636.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/East-Bay-housing...
- jdblair 8y agoI wasn't trying to suggest the design is not fire safe. Fire codes ensure it will be safe when completed.
- OedipusRex 8y agoI've lived in two of these types of buildings, I live in one currently. The first one I lived in was at a big state college and was put up in very short time. The craftsmanship, or lack thereof that went into this building was very noticeable. My roommates outlet was at a 20 degree angle, the doors hollow, and the paint was very cheap. The one I currently live in is a bit better, it's in a Midwestern state capitol and has nicer amenities but the doors are still hollow, and the paint is still cheap.
- purple_ducks 8y agoHow is the inter apartment noise containment?
- OedipusRex 8y agoI don't hear anyone around me but I only share one wall with another apartment and I'm on the top floor so no one above me. That said, noise leaks to and from the hallways.
- nhf 8y agoI think that's more of an economic incentives thing rather than any issue with this particular type of construction. You do a 1+5 building with soundproof doors, varied paint schemes for each unit, real wood flooring (not laminate), and so on. There's nothing about the building that prevents that. Developers have no incentive to do that stuff though because in most markets there's a big deficit in new construction and people will rent it, even if the doors are hollow and every wall is off-white.
- unethical_ban 8y agoI like the style, in that I like mixed development and midrise density, but I agree. A lot of this stuff is being thrown up with little thought to longevity.
- deegles 8y agoHas someone done the math comparing these structures to all-concrete structures in terms of CO2/energy usage? I'm sure concrete lasts longer, but if a mostly wood structure lasts half as long but creates less than 50% of the emissions then it should come out ahead?
- max76 8y agoThis is really hard to accurately predict. The average wood structure with concrete foundation lasts 120 years. We have a good understanding of how much CO2 is costs to build an all-concrete structure today, and we have a good understanding of how much CO2 it costs to build a conventional building today. How much CO2 will it cost to build the replacement building in ~100 years from now? What will the energy requirements of a conventional building built 100 years from now be compared to the energy requirements of our options today? Think about how much different a structure built in 1918 is compared to one build today.
- Someone 8y agoIt could even come out a win at “last’s half as long” and “costs 60% of”, if a portion of the concrete buildings get abandoned or demolished before their life expectancy is up because of changed requirements. Extreme example: many Olympic Games venues don’t need a life expectancy of decades.
- jgamman 8y agoanother thing to consider is that approx. half the emissions associated with a building come from heating and cooling during its lifetime. saving 10% in carbon for the construction and then skimping on say, double glazing and passive solar means you lose out over the long term.
- oftenwrong 8y agoAnother growing architectural trend in American cities is what is often called a "Texas Doughnut" or "Dallas Doughnut": a multi-level parking garage wrapped in apartments. Ground-floor commercial space may be included as well. http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-RDQh277PWAY/UXx7Ya3u-ZI/AAAAAAAAA-E/MdMXoVqC6-M/s1600/Dallas_donut.jpg http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-RDQh277PWAY/UXx7Ya3u-ZI/AAAAAAAAA-...
- InclinedPlane 8y agoThat is impressively hideous, it looks like living in a mall.
- amyjess 8y agoYou don't see it from street level, though. It's just ugly from an aerial view. At street level, all you see is the outside of the building, which looks like a regular building, and you have a few tunnels here and there that lead to the parking garage. Here: https://goo.gl/maps/CFbDSxyhkXP2 https://goo.gl/maps/CFbDSxyhkXP2 Other than that little tunnel, you wouldn't be able to tell there's a parking garage inside.
- oftenwrong 8y agoIt is a mall, more-or-less. There are shops and restaurants in and around it. To be fair, it looks much better from street view than it does from the satellite view. For most American cities, "impressively hideous" is standard issue. https://goo.gl/maps/sbkieWpfdv62 https://goo.gl/maps/sbkieWpfdv62
- logfromblammo 8y agoNevertheless, topologically superior to having the parking surrounding the building as a surface lot.
- calcifer 8y agoWow, looks horrible. Much better to make that a communal garden and have the garage underground.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- russellbeattie 8y agoI've seen a few of these being built in Mountain View... now I understand that it's a trend. I haven't been inside one, but it has to be better than the Karate Kid-style apartment building with all the entrances facing inwards towards a central courtyard/pool/garden which is common around California. Those are like living in a Motel, where every noise from your neighbors echoes around the central area. The other style is the 'mega-apartment' complexes which have their own issues as well. I have been inside those, and they're universally depressing. I wonder what it is that Americans can't figure out how to create housing which encourages community instead of killing it. Maybe the One-Plus-Five is the answer?
- sand500 8y agoI don't see a problem with the 1+5 style. I think the street level retail is important for making the area seem lively especially if they are built near the caltrain station "downtowns" like Palo Alto, Mountain View or Sunnyvale. I certainly prefer this style to gated or enclosed apartment communities style. The best style I saw was in Northern Virginia where around every DC metro station was a cluster of high rise apartments, high rise offices and malls with regular suburb once you walk a couple of blocks away.