3 ms·
Total tangent, but since our understanding of nutrition is weak and has shifted so much over the decades, why is it not also reasonable to doubt our understandi
by chrisco255 8y ago
Total tangent, but since our understanding of nutrition is weak and has shifted so much over the decades, why is it not also reasonable to doubt our understanding of Earth's climate and the extent to which CO2 impacts temps?
- chrischen 8y agoProbably because all the scientists have not been shifting that consensus like the latest diet fads??
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI think the answer there is that if you are wrong and crazy to question our current understanding of nutrition, you are probably only hurting yourself and maybe your kids. If you are wrong and crazy about climate change, you are hurting everyone on the planet. And it's a very charged topic because we already have plenty of people who don't want to inconvenience themselves to benefit the climate, so questioning climate change tends to give such people more justification for behavior that is selfish to the point of monstrous already. I'm an environmental studies major. I think it's complicated. I tend to not bother to argue it. My doubts are not some kind of definitive proof that the assertions of others are wrong. I mostly think it's not worth debating at this point in time. There are plenty of negative changes that are well documented, such as species going extinct, species on the Endangered Species list, etc. We don't really need to prove global warming one way or the other to know that we need to make some changes in a big way and very soon because the course we are on is clearly a crash course.
- pjc50 8y agoThe climate is a simpler, easier to measure, and easier to experiment on system than the human body. Also there are lots of different bodies which all change over time, but there is only one atmosphere. The science of climate change is also multi-level, gradually converging on details with more and more sophisticated models, but the core of it rests on the absorbtion and re-emission spectra of CO2 and water vapor, which is some fairly simple long-settled experimental chemistry. (Wikipedia traces it to this fascinating little paper by Eunice Foote in AAAS in 1856! https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=6xhFAQAAMAAJ&pg=PA382&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=6xhFAQAAMAAJ&pg=PA382&re... )
- riskable 8y agoNot yet mentioned: Collectively, the human gut evolves. Over quite a short timespan! Climate is basically rock solid by comparison. For example, a new type of food may become quite popular over the course of like five to ten years. In that time millions upon millions of people will undergo a change in their gut flora from eating that food--even if only on occasion! Who TF knows what the long term impact of such an evolutionary change could be? 90% of the time it's probably nothing but 10% of the people might develop IBS later in life because their gut bacteria suddenly evolved in such a way as to throw off the "balance of power" (as it were... The many zillions of gut bacteria are constantly at war with each other to process food faster and more efficiently).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat's easy to answer. The problem with nutrition is not that science does not work. So extrapolating from "it is difficult to study nutrition scientifically" to "it is difficult to study climate change scientifically" is unjustified. The issue with nutritional science is that you essentially have to rely on humans accurately taking some prescribed action and self-reporting it truthfully. As far as data points go, that is as flimsy as it gets. Isn't the vast majority of climate change skepticism just political ideology anyway? I really haven't met too many people that were interested in rebutting the science.