3 ms·
No idealism here mate, we are accusing the Labor party of lying about their motives and reasoning. This bill was bipartisan (shame on both their houses and all
by roenxi 8y ago
No idealism here mate, we are accusing the Labor party of lying about their motives and reasoning. This bill was bipartisan (shame on both their houses and all that).
Saying they would "die on their sword" is wrong. Nobody would care if they said "we're waiting 6 months because we want time to debate". They do that sort of thing all the time, doesn't raise a blip. This is a fringe issue! Nobody understands or cares about cybersecurity, that is the only reason that they can get something like this passed.
To claim the Liberals would run a scare campaign is one of the most baldfaced lies since "I thank the honorable [opposition] member for their question" in parliamentary Question Time. Scare campaigns don't need to be run based on facts, politics has moved beyond that. If a scare campaign is in the works it will go ahead regardless. Labour are still going to get called soft on crime if the Liberals think it will win them votes.
- ux-app 8y ago>Saying they would "die on their sword" is wrong. Nobody would care if they said "we're waiting 6 months because we want time to debate". Again, be realistic, and account for the context of the situation. The LNP, in cahoots with our corrupt media made this a "keep Aussies safe over Christmas" issue. No one in Australia is strong enough to take on the Murdoch media cabal. If Labor opposed, and even a minor incident occurred over Christmas they would have jeopardized their chances of election. For what? An issue that the vast majority of Australians don't care about? Idiocy. I'm as disappointed as any other punter, but I've been unable to convince any of the tech-illiterate in my social circle that it matters.
- ripdog 8y ago>keep Aussies safe over Christmas Which is even more disingenuous when you consider that the bill won't even take effect until March, and probably won't lead to any backdoors until significant time after that.
- ux-app 8y agoyou're preaching to the choir here mate. It's corrupt though-and-through, but the Murdoch media controls the narrative in this country, and the vast majority of Australians a) don't care and b) only consider the "but what about ISIS on whats app" argument. How do you win in this scenario?
- ripdog 8y agoOh, I was intending to preach to the choir :) Just pointing out a little bit of extra hypocrisy that some might have missed. Honestly, I don't know how we could possibly win in this scenario. A corrupt media stoking unfounded fears in an ignorant public is a very powerful thing.
- tschwimmer 8y agoZDNet reports that the Aus Govt. can start issuing the notices in question as of now: https://www.zdnet.com/article/whats-actually-in-australias-encryption-laws-everything-you-need-to-know/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/whats-actually-in-australias-e... Search for "IT'S THE LAW NOW, SO WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?"
- starbeast 8y agoYou have said this one way or another a few times, but I just thought I would point out that "nobody cares about this but it will ruin their chances of election to oppose it", doesn't on the face of it make a whole lot of sense.
- ux-app 8y agoIt's simple. Nobody, besides us nerds, cares about the details. Unfortunately it's extremely easy for those in the media to paint this as 'isis loving Labor allows terrorists to communicate secretly' and that gets every man and his dogs attention, because privacy and civil liberties is a thorny, complex issue, but terrorist bashing is easy low hanging fruit we can all agree on.... right?
- mickael-kerjean 8y ago> This is a fringe issue! It depends how you present things, get some press release that say: "The Australian government knows all about your visits to Youporn" would talk to people way more than "Australia new encryption law". About that, see the episode about government surveillance on last week tonight that tries to explain all the NSA programs when it comes to dick picks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEVlyP4_11M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEVlyP4_11M
- ehnto 8y agoIt definitely effects all Australians. Meta-data hoovering spoke to more people than usual due to the same framing, "The gov wants to record what sites you look at". That's why we had much better engagement on that bill. This recent bill barely popped up in my tech heavy bubble. I only knew about it from a reddit post.