7 ms·
>immune signals sent from the gut can compromise the brain’s blood vessels This is known, Rhonda Patrick talks about it on Joe Rogan (I can hear you groaning).
by hammock 8y ago
>immune signals sent from the gut can compromise the brain’s blood vessels
This is known, Rhonda Patrick talks about it on Joe Rogan (I can hear you groaning).
What confuses me is that this ties new research to old, outdated research (the old wisdom that salt leads to high blood pressure). No sources, but latest studies show excess salt is not harmful in healthy people.
- dzhiurgis 8y agoMy doctor still recommends me use less salt due to my high pressure. Is he an idiot?
- rootusrootus 8y agoMine still tells me I should avoid eggs because they will raise my cholesterol. I wouldn't call him an idiot, just not quite up to date on the latest nutritional studies. Not a big deal since our understanding of nutrition seems really weak and changes pretty often. In any case, there is this: https://www.acsh.org/news/2018/08/10/spoonful-salt-makes-blood-pressure-go-down-13289 https://www.acsh.org/news/2018/08/10/spoonful-salt-makes-blo... Which suggests that salt intake does raise blood pressure slightly, but it's a very small effect and does not measurably impact actual cardiovascular outcomes.
- hackits 8y agoI think it is folly to diss-regard your doctors advice.
- stubish 8y agoI've found it is folly to blindly accept doctor's advice, at least for general practitioners. Second opinions and personal research are a must for anything that matters, unless you have been lucky enough to find a good doctor one and are able to stick with them. Respect for the GPs who are capable of saying 'I don't know' or 'I'll need to research this'. Even specialists disagree, leaving you with the choice of which you trust more. They can't all be right.
- yetihehe 8y ago> Even specialists disagree, leaving you with the choice of which you trust more. They can't all be right. That leads to confusion and general mistrust for doctors. If skilled doctor doesn't know what he does, how can I? If I don't know better than doctor, how can I know who gives better advice? How to find that good advice?
- rootusrootus 8y agoI've had enough doctors that my viewpoint is different. They are human and can absolutely be wrong. Challenge them if you don't agree with their recommendation, a good doctor will tell you why they gave the advice, what the probable consequences are for ignoring it, and how confident they are. If your doctor reacts negatively to being challenged, find another.
- hackits 8y agoLook I'm not going to bother defending a doctors point of view, but simply say that within reason seek other professional advice or a different doctor if you have concerns. Though it is concerning that you've just simply brushed off a doctors recommendations so lightly just show me that I'm not going to persuade you either way.
- chrisco255 8y agoTotal tangent, but since our understanding of nutrition is weak and has shifted so much over the decades, why is it not also reasonable to doubt our understanding of Earth's climate and the extent to which CO2 impacts temps?
- chrischen 8y agoProbably because all the scientists have not been shifting that consensus like the latest diet fads??
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI think the answer there is that if you are wrong and crazy to question our current understanding of nutrition, you are probably only hurting yourself and maybe your kids. If you are wrong and crazy about climate change, you are hurting everyone on the planet. And it's a very charged topic because we already have plenty of people who don't want to inconvenience themselves to benefit the climate, so questioning climate change tends to give such people more justification for behavior that is selfish to the point of monstrous already. I'm an environmental studies major. I think it's complicated. I tend to not bother to argue it. My doubts are not some kind of definitive proof that the assertions of others are wrong. I mostly think it's not worth debating at this point in time. There are plenty of negative changes that are well documented, such as species going extinct, species on the Endangered Species list, etc. We don't really need to prove global warming one way or the other to know that we need to make some changes in a big way and very soon because the course we are on is clearly a crash course.
- pjc50 8y agoThe climate is a simpler, easier to measure, and easier to experiment on system than the human body. Also there are lots of different bodies which all change over time, but there is only one atmosphere. The science of climate change is also multi-level, gradually converging on details with more and more sophisticated models, but the core of it rests on the absorbtion and re-emission spectra of CO2 and water vapor, which is some fairly simple long-settled experimental chemistry. (Wikipedia traces it to this fascinating little paper by Eunice Foote in AAAS in 1856! https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=6xhFAQAAMAAJ&pg=PA382&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=6xhFAQAAMAAJ&pg=PA382&re... )
- coldtea 8y ago>I wouldn't call him an idiot, just not quite up to date on the latest nutritional studies Since "the latest nutritional studies" are a dime a dozen, and one says one thing, another says the opposite, it's wise to ignore them altogether until they are grown more and established into a concrete set of suggestions. I'd ignore anything that hasn't reach the level of "nutrition 101" in a university course, and is still on "just published on a peer reviewed journal" level.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThe older I get, the more I just settle on nutritional advice that goes something like "the more processed it is, the more likely it's not good for you" and "everything is fine in moderation" and "eat what you want, just eat less".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aviv 8y agoAn idiot would be a person taking seriously nutritional advice from a doctor that spent a grand total of ~5 days learning about the subject in medical school.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMost doctors know very little about what food does to the body. If you have a specific medical condition, a best practice is to start a folder of some sort and collect good information there and try to understand it yourself. Another good thing to do is keep a health journal where you track, to some degree or other, specific metrics pertinent to your specific condition. What I have concluded is that a lot of advice of that sort is over-simplifying a complex biological process. Figuring out what makes sense in terms of diet involves fleshing out your own mental models for the pathology of the condition in question.
- lugg 8y agoMy experience has been roughly in line but I usually find they're somewhat knowledgeable. Just remember they're stuck with recommending guidelines or else so they haven't got much room to move when the guidelines are a total farse.
- riskable 8y ago> Most doctors know very little about what food does to the body. This is bullshit. "Most doctors" know very little about the electromechanical processes involved in a keystroke but they still know it results in a letter appearing on the screen. A doctor's job is to keep you alive and to a lesser extent, healthy. They are not in the fitness businesses but they sure know that fit people have less health problems. Problems that they ultimately get stuck treating. Do they know the chemical processes at work (in detail) in the brain when you eat something? Probably not... Not unless they're a gastroenterologist/neurologist. But do they know that eating loads of sugar every day can lead to Type II diabetes? They sure do! I'd even go so far as to say, "Doctors know quite a lot more than most people" about such things! They also know loads of things about salt! Ask any psychiatrist about the effects of high salt intake on various mental conditions (and their respective treatments). Ask any pediatrician what would happen if you fed a tablespoon of salt to a baby. Ask a dermatologist about salt in general (wow, take a seat and be prepared for a lecture).
- SonicSoul 8y agoThis comment is strangely defensive (are you a doctor?). I’ve had to deal with all kinds of issues over past decades and the “doctors know little about food” hypothesis is 100% true in my case. Without getting into too much detail looking back over past dozen doctors or so maybe 1 focused on factors related to nutritional effects for causes/cures of conditions i was dealing with. And knowing what i know now, nutrition was more effective in treatment/prevention than anything they prescribed. It almost seems to me like they follow a manual that treats symptoms and when-in-doubt-do-surgery type solutions.
- gadders 8y agoI always understood the salt issue as a public health suggestion. EG if 1 person in a hundred has salt-sensitive hypertension, telling everyone to lower their salt intake will help that 1% of the population. The other 99% are just inconvenienced. Obviously, they could tell people that this is the reason and treat us like adults, but they don't seem to want to.
- bvinc 8y agoMan, Rhonda Patrick is awesome. With so much disinformation in the field of nutrition, everything she says is well thought out and researched.
- glastra 8y agoCertainly. The first sentence already instilled a sense of "they're full of it" in me. I know that's biased. I checked one of the papers they refer to [0] and... well, they fed mice (not humans) a diet with an 8- to 16-fold increase in salt. As with all nutrients, there is an optimal intake range, and anything below or above that is by definition sub-optimal. In humans, the optimum for sodium intake per day seems to be well above dietary recommendations, but also well below 16 times the amounts described in those recommendations. Also, it is worth noting that the first sentence in the linked paper is again repeating the same unreasoned "we all know salt is bad" dogma. Diets high in salt in the western world are also high in many, many other things that are bad for you. Epidemiology is useless to derive new information, it only works to establish future work or to deny previous hypotheses. [0]: http://sci-hub.tw/https://www.nature.com/articles/s41593-017-0059-z#Sec12 http://sci-hub.tw/https://www.nature.com/articles/s41593-017...
- coldtea 8y ago>I checked one of the papers they refer to [0] and... well, they fed mice (not humans) a diet with an 8- to 16-fold increase in salt. As with all nutrients, there is an optimal intake range, and anything below or above that is by definition sub-optimal. In humans, the optimum for sodium intake per day seems to be well above dietary recommendations, but also well below 16 times the amounts described in those recommendations. Is there some underlying assumption that those researches are idiots and didn't know all that? The logical interpretation is that they gave 8- to 16-fold increase in salt purposefully, because they cared to see whether there are any specific effects mediated through salt. In over words, they want to put the effects on full blast to magnify responses and be able to see some novel connection, not to see how a mouse cops with mild over-consumption of salt. Specifically, the article says that they found it resulted "in increased vulnerability of the brain to autoimmunity", which one wouldn't expect from sub-optimal salt intake alone. This is not some rehash of "very high salt = blood pressure, duh!".
- glastra 8y agoOh, not at all. They are not idiots. That paper was written with a purpose which was properly met (mainly getting to publish and, to a lesser extent, to confirm a previous notion or bias). The issue is reporting of results to the public. Someone feeds mice a ridiculous amount of salt and notices they have some health issues. Let's assume for an instant that this is somehow useful for some reason (I mean, salt poisoining has been known for millenia and people actually commit suicide by drinking saturated salt solutions). Even in that case, journalists are still distilling the whole thing into "more salt is bad", which is what the average person will understand. The general public doesn't read scientific literature with a critical thinking mindset, if at all.
- rednerrus 8y agoBring that up young Jamie.
- jshowa3 8y agoExcess salt is a known factor of kidney stones and kidney failure. It also a factor in profuse diarrhea and dehydration. Saying its not harmful in healthy people (depending on how you define healthy) is a pretty ignorant thing to say.