3 ms·
You are totally missing the point... 1) It's not a water-scarce environment. The Surf Ranch is surrounded by farms. 2) The Surf Ranch uses less water than its
by gamblor956 8y ago
You are totally missing the point...
1) It's not a water-scarce environment. The Surf Ranch is surrounded by farms.
2) The Surf Ranch uses less water than its surrounding properties, and uses less water than an activity that most people in dry climates regard as a waste of time (i.e. golfing).
Like all pools, it takes a lot of water. They don't just dump the water into the system. They have tanks on-site to reclaim most of it, and a neighboring overflow/storage pool to minimize water wastage.
And this is just the beta pool, where they're trying to figure out the wave mechanics. Commercial pools like the one in Florida will have more advanced water reclamation/recycling systems.
- reaperducer 8y ago1) It's not a water-scarce environment. The Surf Ranch is surrounded by farms. Being surrounded by farms doesn't mean it's not water scarce. People have been irrigating desert for thousands of years. The location is classified as BSk "semi-arid"†, just two notches above full-on desert. The Surf Ranch uses less water than its surrounding properties Re-read my comment above indicating that two wrongs don't make a right. And this is just the beta pool, where they're trying to figure out the wave mechanics What does it matter if it's a test pool, not? There are plenty of places with tons of water to spare in the same time zone. † https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemoore,_California#Climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemoore,_California#Climate
- gamblor956 8y agoIf you had followed up further on the climate classification, you would have seen that the classification is heavily based on the portion of the year during which rainfall is received, not just on the amount of rainfall received. Furthermore, a number of cities in otherwise extremely rainy locations (including Brazil and India) are also categorized as Bsk climates because they also receive most of their water in a limited portion of the year. If you want to see an example of a wasteful activity in the CA Central Valley, check out https://www.wsj.com/articles/harvard-quietly-amasses-california-vineyardsand-the-water-underneath-1544456396 https://www.wsj.com/articles/harvard-quietly-amasses-califor... (also posted on HN earlier today). The Surf Ranch replaced a farm, and over the year uses less water than the farm it replaced, so that counts as a net benefit.
- reaperducer 8y agouses less water than the farm it replaced, so that counts as a net benefit. No, it doesn't. Less waste is still waste. If you want to see an example of a wasteful activity in the CA Central Valley Continued whataboutism. You and I will just have to agree to disagree on the whole notion of two wrongs making a right.
- longerthoughts 8y agoI was more or less with you until this... >>uses less water than the farm it replaced, so that counts as a net benefit. >No, it doesn't. Less waste is still waste. If waste is bad and this wastes less, that is a net improvement from a waste perspective regardless of whether or not you think it's good for the world.
- floatingatoll 8y agoYour viewpoints would lead to the total cessation of all environmentally-impacting activities. While it’s admirable that you hold these views to the maximum extreme possible, you will find little traction with others who do not feel as extremely as you. That doesn’t mean anyone is right or wrong, but you’ll find people reject your views solely due to the extremism with which they’re expressed. Consider whether that’s the desired outcome and, if not, consider adjusting your approach accordingly. EDIT: If you have a personal story to tell about water waste, sharing that would go a long way towards helping the rest of us be able to connect with your position.