3 ms·
I'm against taxes for the simple fact they're non-voluntary. I don't think there's anything wrong with people that that are willing to pay them, but I don't thi
by exabrial 8y ago
I'm against taxes for the simple fact they're non-voluntary. I don't think there's anything wrong with people that that are willing to pay them, but I don't think forcefully [meaning, eventually you will be arrested by someone with a gun] taking another person's money is justifiable by any society.
- TheBeardKing 8y agoI would like to agree with you, except that if I were completely honest I would sometimes lump it with things that I should pay for like NPR and Wikipedia, and which I normally do, but some years I skip out on to spend on other niceties. Keeping government running and infrastructure maintained is much more important and should not be voluntarily withheld.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoI too read Atlas Shrugged as a teenager.
- a_c_s 8y agoIn the USA one won't be arrested nor go to jail for simply not paying taxes as it is merely a civil offense, not a criminal one. https://tax.findlaw.com/tax-problems-audits/can-you-go-to-jail-for-not-paying-taxes.html https://tax.findlaw.com/tax-problems-audits/can-you-go-to-ja...
- rmidthun 8y agoI think you need to read that linked article a bit more closely. "You can go to jail for not filing your taxes. You can go to jail for lying on your return. But you can’t go to jail for not having enough money to pay your taxes. " That is, if you intentionally avoid paying taxes by either not filing or filing a fraudulent report, then you certain can go to jail. See Al Capone for the most famous example.
- toasterlovin 8y agoWould love to know how you think emergency response or national defense would work in a taxes-are-voluntary scenario.
- mullingitover 8y agoThis is reasonable. I'd prefer that rather than forcibly collecting taxes, non-payers could simply be, peacefully, stripped of citizenship and exiled.
- stale2002 8y agoYep, it is totally "non violent" to throw people into the sea, where they can be "non violently drowned to death". The ocean is the only place not claimed by a nation. That's the point. You cannot buy land, and have it declared yours, not subject to the authority of a nation. If you support violence, that's fine. Go ahead and say so, and make that arguement. Lots of people support the government's monopoly on violence. It is not a particularly controversial opinion to have. But don't pretend like exiling people from land that they own is "non violent". Just be honest with yourself and say "yes. I support the government's monopoly on violence". It's not hard, nor controversial.
- kaibee 8y ago> If you support violence, that's fine. Go ahead and say so, and make that arguement. Lots of people support the government's monopoly on violence. It is not a particularly controversial opinion to have. If someone is squatting in your house, benefiting from money you spend on it, you are justified in evicting them. > The ocean is the only place not claimed by a nation. That's the point. You cannot buy land, and have it declared yours, not subject to the authority of a nation. This has been true since basically the dawn of human civilization. Just in those times, you were subject to the authority of invaders. > But don't pretend like exiling people from land that they own is "non violent". Just be honest with yourself and say "yes. I support the government's monopoly on violence". It's not hard, nor controversial. Owning land is a concept that only exists inside of a system of government with a mechanism to enforce property rights. If they decide they don't want to be subject to the rules of society, they don't get to have their cake and eat it too.
- stale2002 8y ago> kaibee 1 hour ago | parent | on: The Golden Age of Rich People Not Paying Their Tax... > If you support violence, that's fine. Go ahead and say so, and make that arguement. Lots of people support the government's monopoly on violence. It is not a particularly controversial opinion to have. If someone is squatting in your house, benefiting from money you spend on it, you are justified in evicting them This argument is only valid if you believe that the 200 countries in the world own every single inch of land in the world. > . Just in those times, you were subject to the authority of invaders. Yes, and this would be described as violence. And that's fine. If you believe in the authority of the monopoly on violence of governments, all you have to do is say so! That's it! This is merely a descriptive claim I am making. That the act of owning every plot of land in the world, and preventing other people from owning it, and then kicking people off of 100% of the land, is violence. If there was an ever expanding mirror world, where people could up and leave too, then this would not be violence. Or in other words, owning 100% of something is violence, but owning 0.00001 % of something is not. And all you have to do is say that you support the uncontroversial opinion of the government monopoly on violence, and we are good to go. Easy!
- Retra 8y agoIt would seem then that anybody who fails to pay their end of a transaction would get off scot-free? Because they only way you can maintain the usefulness of money is if you enforce payment where it is due.