9 ms·
The Cube Rule of Food Identification
- gmoore 8y agoI love it!
- Stratoscope 8y agoYou can't argue with this logic!
- rtkwe 8y agoThe only thing I'd change is to rename the sushi category to something broader like wrap. Sushi is a really specific foodstuff to me to be the name of that category.
- jdmichal 8y agoI thought the same. Wrap or burrito, though both have the problem that they can be closed at one or both ends, thus changing their category... The tweet screenshot from @Phosphatide has Japanese along the top, so I'm assuming that's why the immediate reference was sushi.
- rtkwe 8y agoThat brings up an even more interesting/disturbing question does a burrito turn into a salad after the first couple bites because one (hopefully only one) end is open now.
- bpicolo 8y agoBurrito should be the top-level "Calzone" category, because fusion burritos are such a big thing. See: sushiritto
- Stratoscope 8y agoI prefer fission burritos. They are easier to split.
- Stratoscope 8y agoAh, but note the fact that nigiri sushi is a variety of toast. Personally I found insight in yebyen's words of wisdom: > obviously, a steak is a salad, and soup is a wet salad Also, mashed potatoes are a salad, and salad in a bread bowl is a quiche.
- nonsince 8y agoMashed potatoes, being made of starch, are a kind of toast
- stcredzero 8y agoOr, is it interpretable like rice? What about mashed potatoes with a pool of gravy in the center?
- peterwwillis 8y agoA bunch of croutons on the bottom of a plate look like toast, but you can't lift them all by picking up just one. Unless you're cooking your mashed potatoes in a way I've never seen, you won't be able to pick them all up by lifting one part of the mashed potatoes.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoYou raise a fascinating point.
- mjevans 8y agoYes, you can. Super-sets/classes - A calzone is still a sandwich since it implements the sandwich class (distinct bread on two sides of a food; which could be an additional slice of bread. E.G. Folding a slice of bread over half of a different slice of bread can be a sandwich. However making an S-curve does not cause a distinct middle layer (though if the edges are sliced off suddenly it is). ).
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> A calzone is still a sandwich since it implements the sandwich class (distinct bread on two sides of a food). Huh? A calzone has the same bread on every side, not distinct bread on two sides. It's a single bread wrapped around a filling.
- Stratoscope 8y agoThe bottom of the calzone tends to be toastier. So perhaps calzone is a variety of toast?
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoBut toast stops being toast once something other than filling is a top it! Doesn’t matter how toasty the bottom layer is.
- mortenjorck 8y agoMy only objection is the somewhat capricious way the rule is reapplied based on serving. The author classifies pumpkin pie as an instance of toast, not quiche, because the photo they found was of a single slice, while cheesecake, deep-dish pizza, and key lime pie are all labeled quiches because the photos are of an entire pie. An Uncrustable is even labeled a calzone only when “unbitten” because it apparently becomes a quiche the moment you bite into it! While this may be topologically consistent, it’s not useful as a taxonomy to have foods dynamically change categorization as you serve or eat them.
- Stratoscope 8y agoI don't know about you, but the foods I eat change categorization dramatically after I eat them!
- gagege 8y agoSeveral times, in fact!
- yebyen 8y agoI lost it when I got to the Bonus Round... because obviously, a steak is a salad, and soup is a wet salad? I mean how could you not get that...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- eindiran 8y agoThere are a few missing variations that aren't symmetric to one of the 6 existing categories. I wonder if this implies that there are other categories possible that haven't been made yet. The one with the most possibility is two starch faces, as in (2), but the starch faces share an edge.
- AaronFriel 8y agoThat's just a degenerate case of the taco.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoIs a hard shell taco that has split a sandwich?
- AaronFriel 8y agoObviously, and a burrito cut in half is a quiche. Throw away one half, cut off the end, and what remains is a sushi.
- yayana 8y agoNo, there is no acceptable state between burrito and salad. A split taco is an initial demonstration of innate knowledge and some motor control, best done before the staff retreats.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoMos Burger [0] would like to have a word. [0] https://goo.gl/images/zK3YJs https://goo.gl/images/zK3YJs
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoI immediately thought of this with the pumpkin pie slice. Also, the site indicates that a whole double-crust pie is a calzone, while a slice of double-crust pie is a taco. Having food categories change as they are served and consumed seems fundamentally unstable and can lead only to chaos. The single slice could easily pass through three or four stages during consumption alone! I think a food's category must be fixed at the end of preparation, for the sake of all sanity.
- draw_down 8y agoIt's a nice thought and everything, but the matter has been settled already. There are four foods: substance, soup, pizza, and sandwich. Substance is one food, like a steak. Soup is multiple foods, like a steak with ketchup on it. Pizza is monobreadular, sandwich is polybreadular; therefore tacos and burritos are pizzas. http://alanjamesart.tumblr.com/post/158858916670/the-four-foods http://alanjamesart.tumblr.com/post/158858916670/the-four-fo...
- justchilly 8y agoWhat about the cone? Hand Roles. Ice cream cones. Some crepes. Or is that a type of Soup/Salad/Bread Bowl...
- stcredzero 8y agoHand Roles Effector/manipulator on the world? Data interface with keyboard/mouse? Surrogate life partner?
- masklinn 8y agoCones are obviously quiches/bowls. > Some crepes. Crepes are not trivial to classify: obviously a plain flat crepe with some topping is a toast, a "walkaround" (usually sweet) crepe is a quiche and sushi/wrap crepes exist (e.g. galette-saucisse[0]) but what about the "complète" where the crèpe is folded back on the filling but not entirely? Functionally it's closer to a calzone or a toast (it's not eaten from the "opening") but technically it looks more like a quiche. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galette-saucisse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galette-saucisse
- mazelife 8y agoThis gets us classifications all the way from "no starch at all" (i.e. soup) to "non-starch surrounded on all sides by the starch" (i.e. calzone). But I posit the existence of an eighth category... that is to say the inverse of the calzone, which would be "starch surrounded on all sides by a non-starch"? An anti-calzone, if you will. Seems rather rare, but not impossible (e.g. turkey with stuffing).
- skykooler 8y agoAnother example would be a glazed donut (starch surrounded by sugar).
- delecti 8y agoDoesn't the toroidal topology of a donut mean that both the starch and sugar are simultaneously surrounding each other?
- fanf2 8y agoBut what if it is a donut that is both filled and glazed? Is the glaze just on top or all the way round? What does a beef Wellington count as? It has multiple nested layers... what if you made a turducken and wrapped each bird in a flatbread of some kind, before stuffing it in a larger bird?
- CiPHPerCoder 8y agoBeef Wellington is in the same class as calzones. Possibly as a cascade thereof.
- FakeComments 8y agoI think co-calzone is probably most sensible. Though the whole topic is a mess: an open-faced sandwich suddenly is a self-dual food.
- AaronFriel 8y agoSelf duals are entirely reasonable! A unified theory of food would be incomplete if we excluded such beautiful symmetries.
- jetrink 8y agoSandwiches are like fascism. In Ur-Fascism, Umberto Eco talks about the difficulty of defining the "know it when you see it" category of fascism. We start with a set of concrete examples and we seek to define the category based on the qualities shared by those examples. One example might have qualities A and B, a second B and C and a third, C and D. The first thing shares no qualities with the last, but they all belong to the same category by a kind of transitivity. Sandwich is an agglomeration of qualities that tend to cluster together.
- perfmode 8y agoIn fact, all concepts can be viewed this way.
- laszlokorte 8y agoIt's the same with "knowledge". Classical knowledge is understood as justified true belief. But you can come up with countless counter examples where someone is justified in believing something that is indeed true but you would not attest that person any knowledge of the fact. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gettier_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gettier_problem
- quakeguy 8y agoEco knew a toast from a Toast.
- mark-wagner 8y agoIn his Philosophical Investigations, Wittgenstein's response to this problem are the concepts of "language games" and "family resemblance." From https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wittgenstein/#LangGameFamiRese https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wittgenstein/#LangGameFam...: > Still, just as we cannot give a final, essential definition of ‘game’, so we cannot find “what is common to all these activities and what makes them into language or parts of language” (PI 65). > There is no reason to look, as we have done traditionally—and dogmatically—for one, essential core in which the meaning of a word is located and which is, therefore, common to all uses of that word. We should, instead, travel with the word’s uses through “a complicated network of similarities overlapping and criss-crossing” (PI 66).
- empath75 8y agoTopologically a toast is the same as a taco and a bread bowl. And a burrito or wrap for that matter.
- andrewla 8y agoI'm a sandwich descriptivist rather than a prescriptivist. I know what a sandwich is, and any definition that say that a hot dog is a sandwich or that a sub/hero/hoagie is not a sandwich is a definition that I do not accept. Similarly, a bagel with cream cheese (that is, both halves of the bagel sandwiching cream cheese) is not a sandwich (despite the use of the word "sandwiching" in the definition), but a bagel with turkey inside is a sandwich. I'm comfortable without a definition, though I look forward to hearing the reports of the intrepid theoreticians that can yield definitions that satisfy these criteria, much as I laud the efforts of the adjective-ordering folk in descriptive grammar. My rule of thumb is that if I went into a restaurant and asked the waiter "I want a sandwich, but I don't care what kind -- surprise me!" and they brought me an object, how angry would I be at the waiter who brought me that object.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoI would love to hear your thoughts on the infamous melt versus grilled cheese debate.
- andrewla 8y agoUsing my rule of thumb above: if I asked the waiter for a grilled cheese, but I didn't care what kind, I expect the waiter would be somewhat perplexed by this, since "grilled cheese" is a sufficient descriptor that there's basically one sandwich that satisfies the description. If I asked for a melt but didn't care what kind, then I feel like the possibilities expand, and would include a regular grilled cheese.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Using my rule of thumb above: if I asked the waiter for a grilled cheese, but I didn't care what kind, I expect the waiter would be somewhat perplexed by this, since "grilled cheese" is a sufficient descriptor that there's basically one sandwich that satisfies the description. Even if you take grilled cheese narrowly enough that it must have nothing but cheese between the bread, there are a fairly wide array of potential breads and potential cheeses and combinations of cheeses that there is definitely more than one sandwich that fits the description, even before considering that, in use, “grilled cheese” allows for additional ingredients.
- 2bitencryption 8y agoThis reminds me of the "grilled cheese" v. "melt" debate from Reddit a few years back. I really enjoy this kind of "ridiculous topic" + "hyper-analysis" humor.
- minism 8y agoOne I enjoyed was a discussion on a gaming podcast about whether fireballs in street fighter were a form of magic or not, eventually leading to the question "is Guile a wizard?"
- Waterluvian 8y agoReminds me of this game review. I wish I could find the original: https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/2959/baldurs-gate-is-such-a-terrible-game https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/2959/baldurs-gate-is-s... All you have to do is misunderstand the genre of something and then review it as that. I need a YouTube channel about this.
- guruhacks300 8y agoLooking for an hacker that can handle any hacking related issues down to university upgrade, credit card top up, clearing criminal records, bank transfers, website hack , bank hack,spy, deleted unwanted data from source, Facebook hack, phone hack, Instagram hack etc You can contact lulzsek he is the best person for the job via WhatsApp,Skype and email or ICQ WhatsApp : +14438217809 Skype:lulzsekhackinc@outlook.com Email: lulzsekhackinc@outlook.com ICQ:745929862
- dwighttk 8y agoYeah, but who would win in a fight between grilled cheese and a taco?
- droopybuns 8y agoThese kinds of sites give me anxiety. It isn’t good to see large communities of humans burning mental calories to come to the same set of conclusions (I’m on team sandwich because $REASON | I’m on team taco because $REASON). It is a mental D.o.s. directed towards humans that tend towards herding.
- ericlewis 8y agoIt's a joke.
- davidkuhta 8y agoChoose team calzone then, the comfort of a wall on all sides may help with the anxiety.
- the8472 8y agohttps://xkcd.com/356/ https://xkcd.com/356/
- EamonnMR 8y agoOr maybe a mental fork bomb aimed at black and white thinkers.
- wtfrmyinitials 8y agohttps://www.xkcd.com/774/ https://www.xkcd.com/774/
- porphyrogene 8y agoLasagna does not have pasta (its starch component) on the bottom or the top. A wrap (such as a falafel wrap, as it is pictured on the site) is a taco, not sushi.
- ericlewis 8y agosushi is often wrapped the same as a taco
- porphyrogene 8y agoRight, but that's not the point. I am referring the sushi standard defined in the article based on the cube illustration. In reality there is sushi that conforms to nearly all of those designations. Furthermore, tacos are filled, not wrapped.
- city41 8y agoI shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description of "sandwich", and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it.
- phkahler 8y agoWhile I can appreciate the fun factor, I hope this is not a turning point where HN becomes like Reddit. Get this off the front page please.
- tom_ 8y agoClick the 'flag' button.
- pesfandiar 8y agoIt seems the distinguishing feature of the joke is that it has its own domain name.
- posterboy 8y agoThe problem is one of significance to machine learning, I believe. 6 DoF for the classification of food within the domain of dough products is ... seemingly too little.
- Stratoscope 8y ago"Please don't submit comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoIf anyone is wondering why toast (1) is listed as an example of a sandwich (2)... I recently learned from a kind HN commenter that toast sandwich is a sandwich where the filling is a buttered piece of toast.
- Waterluvian 8y agoI know it when I see it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- curo 8y agoNo true Scotsman would classify enchilada as solely sushi, when the extra layer of cheese on top puts it in a superposition of being sushi AND toast.
- gagege 8y agoI was unaware the Scottish, as a whole, had so much to say about sushi and enchiladas. ;)
- cortesoft 8y agoThis is because the categories are meant to capture some information about an object, but we expect them to capture all of the information about an object. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/yA4gF5KrboK2m2Xu7/how-an-algorithm-feels-from-inside https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/yA4gF5KrboK2m2Xu7/how-an-alg...
- quakeguy 8y agoOk, i tried to take it serious, but i'm dying here of laughter. I am still convinced this is meant in a quite serious way, bbut. Gneehehehhahah.... FLAG IT!
- EamonnMR 8y agoI subscribe to the belief that the key feature of a sandwich is it's horizontal alignment and stacking. Therefore a hot dog isn't a sandwich because it's split in the middle, not stacked horizontally.
- js8 8y agoIn Czech Republic, we have "sausage in a roll", which is the same thing as hotdog, except they make a hole in the roll (from one side only) and stick the sausage and sauce in it. So you can nicely hold it in your hand like ice cream cone. Recently, some companies here have started making classic hotdogs. But I never understood why - "sausage in a roll" is so much superior topology (for eating on the run). On the contrary, I don't understand why Americans won't adopt "sausage in a roll" instead.
- crooked-v 8y agoCorndogs are a similar concept and are common as fairground food, but with a cornbread rather than wheat bread layer. For a traditional hot dog, though, the key thing is the toppings. Some American styles, like the Coney Island dog, can have as much topping as there is hot dog.
- Zarel 8y agoPronto pups exist, which are corn dogs but made with a wheat-based batter. Pretzel dogs and bagel dogs also exist; they sound pretty close to what OP was talking about. https://www.google.com/search?q=bagel+dog&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=bagel+dog&tbm=isch
- morley 8y agoIt's been a long time since I've been in Prague, but don't the vendors in Wenceslas Square sell normal hot-dog type buns? http://czechoutchannel.blogspot.com/2007/05/wenceslas-square-sausage-stands.html http://czechoutchannel.blogspot.com/2007/05/wenceslas-square... I remember getting American-style buns and the rolls that you're referring to. I prefer the American-style buns because when you take a bite from the roll version, the excess sauce drips out the other side, whereas you can maneuver an American-style bun such that it doesn't drip.
- js8 8y agoIf it's done well, it won't drip out. See the post about Ketwurst above, that's exactly what I mean (and I didn't know it was - it seems, might be a myth - invented in GDR).
- mattnewport 8y agoSo is an open-faced sandwich an oxymoron?
- aero142 8y agoMost of the sandwich debate is caused by ignoring adjectives. In the case of a submarine sandwich, it's a sandwich except we apply the adjective submarine to say we are modifying the bread situation. An open faced sandwich is just like a sandwich except we remove the top piece of bread. Which is why a hotdog is not a sandwich. We could have an adjective to say we are modifying the bread and another to say we are modifying the filling, but then there is nothing left of the sandwich portion, which is why we have a new word for it.
- logfromblammo 8y agoWhether you call it sandwich or not, the mathematical description of a hot dog is well within the bounds of the mathematical description of a sandwich. Fiddling about with adjectives is about as useful as saying that squares are not rectangles or rhombuses because otherwise they would be called rhomboid rectangles or rectangular rhombuses. The hot dog is a special case of a sausage submarine sandwich. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sausage_sandwich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sausage_sandwich
- tsumnia 8y agoNo. It is two toasts.
- laszlokorte 8y agoThe hotdog is classified as taco because it has three sides of the cube but I would argue that a hotdog consists only of two perpendicular sides of the cube because the angle between the buns is only about 90 degrees.
- blt 8y agocritical insight, should be reported to the author
- misterbwong 8y agoThis is an awesome way to explain object-oriented modeling/leaky abstractions to a non-techie.
- the_cat_kittles 8y agoreading these comments is weird. i interpret this page as a kind of satire of a modern pretentious analytical techie orientation that hubristically "solves" things by creating some alluringly simple model and ignoring all the ways it doesn't work. it adopts the mores and tone of a modern tech talk, and presents its idiotic results with a straight face. so its super funny. a little less funny when you have to explain it to people. people who are taking this at face value- really?
- naringas 8y agothus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannelloni https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannelloni are sushi and real mexican tacos are too
- yellowapple 8y agoSee? Poutine and steak are salads! And they said my diet is unhealthy; who's laughing now?
- delecti 8y agoI understand that many of the examples are just absurdism in action, but I have trouble understanding the resistance to labeling a hot dog as a sandwich. But on the other hand, my wife likes to troll me by calling buttered toast a "butter sandwich", so maybe some rigor in our definitions would do my life some good.
- ttoinou 8y agoI used to believe all theses things were sandwiches. How misinformed was I
- c3534l 8y agoI would argue that sandwiches follow a prototype semantic representation in American English. That is, there are a handful of "ideal" sandwiches which are the first thing you think of when it comes to a sandwich. Some items are conventionally not sandwiches. These items might have many similarities with things which are sandwiches, but because of their cultural or culinary significance, are in their own special category. A person may judge an object based on their relative sandwichness which is really a distance metric in which items closer to one of the platonic ideals of a sandwich than they are to a not-a-sandwich are considered to be a sandwich. This way of mentally representing categories of objects, while natural, makes forming precise, rule-based definitions of sandwich classification inherently difficult and inconsistent. Any algorithm for classifying a sandwich must either contain rules which are not universally applied in all situations, or which classifies (or fails to classify) foods as sandwiches which are not conventionally considered sandwiches. As a non-sandwich example of the same phenomenon, consider whether or not an item is considered to be furniture. A few items are universally considered to be furniture: beds, couches, desks, wardrobes. These items together form a semantic boundary, but that boundary is not necessarily uniform. Having legs certainly matters, but not all furniture has legs. Being not easily movable matters, but chairs are easily moved and if couches are furniture, so are chairs. Likewise, items which are not movable at all, such as shelves built into the wall may not be furniture depending on who you ask. Appliances have electronics, and appliances could be considered a special category of furniture, or simply not be considered furniture. Some people would classify lamps as furniture, but not televisions. The issue is that semantic boundaries are not symmetrical. Having features which differ from our platonic ideals and our prototypical example of the category are not weighted equally. Some features matter more, and all of those features together form a gestalt of sandwichness. An attempt to form hard and fast rules about which features are necessary to be a sandwich are well-meaning, but ultimately incorrect as they fail to appreciate the psychology of the sandwich, what it means to hold the concept of a sandwich in your head.
- tk75x 8y agoThe way I see it, anything between two other pieces of another thing (separate pieces or conjoined, doesn't matter) constitutes a sandwich. If we accept the origin story (urban legend?) of its origin as invented by the Earl of Sandwich so that he and his friends can snack without getting their hands dirty during card games, then the sandwich can't be defined as a specific food item, but by the act of putting one thing between two others. Furniture is anything used to "furnish" a space. If the shelf was attached to the wall after the wall is built, it's furniture. If it was built as part of the wall, it isn't.
- mcphage 8y agoI think the real mistake is assuming that the answer to “is this a sandwich” is either “yes”, or “no”. Something can be kinda a sandwich, or not really a sandwich, or slightly a sandwich, or definitely a sandwich, or not at all a sandwich, or anywhere in between. Furthermore, there doesn’t have to be a consistent set of rules defining what is and what is not a sandwich. Arguing about it is fun, though.
- anonymousisme 8y agoLet the flame wars begin!
- rprenger 8y agoThis classification is incomplete without including food with only 1 side, such as the rarely seen "Mobius Bacon".
- posterboy 8y agoI have a passing interest in linguistics[3] and so let me tell you, after intensive meditation about the topic I found that sandwich could well be cognate to German "Wecke", a bread bun, supposedly related to 'wedge'. I can't pin point "sand-" yet. I think that would be crucial to determine the precise meaning. I'm very much against either extreme, pre- or description, but I find that expanding the sample space back to include historic meaning may yield results able to satisfy both sides. Maybe I can still help out. We are actually talking about the club sandwich. Club sandwich could be, for all I know, which is very little about the club sandwiches history, cognate to Ger. "Klappstulle" (a 2-sandwich [to use the OP's typology] made by folding a slice over) at least the club part, and both could go all the way back to the Proto Indo European root whence glue (to stick together) compare Ger. "Kleber" (glue), "Kleie" (wheat-paste?), and perhaps Old English and Gothic "hlaif" (bread) then most likely in reference to dough, Ger. "klumpen" - 'clump', 'glob'. A club of people sticks together. The swinging and clubbing club could perhaps compare to 'key' (from Lt. clavis, from a sense nail, peg, hook), as stick, sticky and clavis, claudo show similar relations. "Klappe" means 'hatch', 'shutter', 'mouth', we say something "klappt nicht" (doesn't function), "(um)klappen" ... it's baffling that there's no good translation: The lid of box is a "Klappe", and closing it shut is "zuklappen"; A "klappe" that doesn't shut tight, flaps and makes noise, that noise is called "klappern" and from that all kinds of 'to make noise' "klappern"; Best fit would be 'clamp'. Now it depends at which time, if there was a relation at all, our dinners aligned or diverged. But, since you can't take a Hot Dog to work and eat it later--already cold--it cannot be a club sandwich, at least if folding is done primarily to stack and wrap them without making a mess of it. Well, I made a mess of it, I didn't check references on most my claims, but I'll have to wrap it up. As a working hypothesis I suppose "sand" relates to Ger. "Kanten", the thick end of a loaf, related to "Kante" (edge), but its Greek root has no secure origin so a link to the celtic word for rim, tire giving "waybread" or "wagonbread" (cp. Ger. "Weg" - way; "Wegebrot") is not too promising. It's just, I have that image of the thick end bread as a happy hobo's ration very present from cartoons. But a better candidate would relate to butter perhaps. Or how about "Shank", cog. Ger. "Schinken" (ham), "Schenkel" (thighs), as something two sided, angled. Anyone reminded of John Connery? That's ridiculous. How about "to send for" - Ger. "gemachte Brote". I mean, there was a time and place where ... wasn't common and bread had been eaten raw or at least separately (... "Belag" - topping, coating). [1] Wiki Commons has a picture of a ca. 8000 years old specimen in the form of a Spitzwecke https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Spitzweck_Reko_Oveg%C3%B6nne.jpg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Spitzweck_Reko_Oveg%C3%B... [2] from Latin canthus (“tire, edge of a wheel”), from Ancient Greek κανθός (kanthós, “corner of the eye, tire, etc.”). The Greek is not certain, maybe from Celtic or if that seems implausible not Indo European. [3] While I don't like anyone prescribing as if they were they majesty, I still dislike the descriptive approach that labels anything as correct that randomly comes up in the mash up of dialects. I'm especially weary of misunderstandings becoming fashionable.
- mimixco 8y agoWhy is pumpkin pie toast but Key Lime pie is quiche?
- eat_veggies 8y agoI'm guessing the distinction is down to slice vs entire pie, rather than flavor.
- alanbernstein 8y agoBecause there is no crust top on the pumpkin pie.
- bravura 8y agoMy friend has a deceptively simple answer to this question: If you put schmear/spread/sauce on the bread, it's a sandwich. If you put schmear/spread/sauce on the "meat", it's not a sandwich. The distinction is that in the latter, the bread is just a vessel to get "meat" into your mouth. In the former, the bread is part of the whole package.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoso, is a lobster a calzone?
- emmanueloga_ 8y agoWelcome to the wonderful world of Ontology, "the philosophical study of being, [...], existence, reality, [...] and the basic categories of being and their relations". [0] A narrower related field is Taxonomy, the practice and science of classification. I like the "cube rule" as a very coarse grained way of classifying food! Classifications of things can become pretty crazy, in particular when they try to classify very general and dissimilar things (example, the schema.org vocabulary [1]). Now someone should turn the cube rule to an OWL vocabulary so machines too, like we humans, can understand the difference between a hot dog and a salad [2]. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontology 1: https://schema.org/docs/full.html https://schema.org/docs/full.html 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_Ontology_Language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_Ontology_Language
- Papirola 8y agowhat about pretzels?
- X31 8y agoInteresting. It all comes down to topology - of the wrapper (or cover) and the fillings. BTW, what happens if the wrapper itself has filling, for example falafel wrap?
- BenoitP 8y agoIs this what HN has become?
- dgzl 8y agoTIL: any food not structurally supported by other food is a salad. Like French fries, steak, and milkshakes.
- tcpekin 8y agoThe definition that I have always stuck with is that a sandwich has leavened bread on two sides of whatever is in the sandwich. Therefore, hot dog is a sandwich, a taco is not, etc.